Friday
September 25, 1846
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.]) — New York, New York City
“How American Abolitionists Nearly Started a War With Britain (1846)”
Art Deco mural for September 25, 1846
Original newspaper scan from September 25, 1846
Original front page — New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The New-York Daily Tribune's front page is dominated by dispatches from London detailing a remarkable gathering of American reformers abroad. Elihu Burritt, an agricultural innovator and peace advocate, has launched the "League of Universal Brotherhood"—a pledged organization to abolish war worldwide. Working alongside William Lloyd Garrison (editor of the Liberator), Frederick Douglass (the fugitive slave turned orator), and Henry C. Wright, Burritt is orchestrating an aggressive anti-slavery agitation campaign across Britain and Ireland. His method is ingenious: he's publishing peace "recipes" titled "An Olive Leaf from the Housewives of New York to the Housewives of Old England" and securing space in Bradshaw's Railway Guide—a monthly publication with enormous circulation—to spread his message. The Tribune also reports on astronomical discoveries, including a newly observed comet, and covers New York State Constitutional Convention proceedings debating state debt and credit policies.

Why It Matters

In 1846, American anti-slavery activism was fracturing into competing factions, and this dispatch reveals a crucial ideological battle. Garrison and his allies were becoming more radical, now advocating for the dissolution of the American Union itself as the path to ending slavery. Many American abolitionists—even those deeply opposed to slavery—found this approach reckless and counterproductive. The reporter's skepticism about the British agitation campaign reflects a genuine American debate: could extremism alienate moderate antislavery sentiment and actually harm the cause? This tension between moral purity and pragmatic coalition-building would define abolitionist politics right up to the Civil War.

Hidden Gems
  • Elihu Burritt's League membership pledge included an extraordinary commitment: signers vowed 'never to enlist, enter into any army or navy, or to yield any voluntary aid or sanction to the preparation for or prosecution of war'—making it one of the earliest absolute pacifist pledges in American reform history.
  • The Tribune lists subscription rates: 12.5 cents per week for city subscribers, but country mail subscribers paid $5 per year—a significant price difference that reveals how newspaper economics favored urban readers in 1846.
  • A comet was discovered on July 30, 1846, and the same post also brought news of ships at Marietta ordering cables from England—the reporter notes this as a remarkable coincidence of 'Great Facts,' suggesting both astronomical and industrial progress arrived simultaneously.
  • Frederick Douglass is identified simply as 'the fugitive slave'—he had escaped bondage only about eight years prior (1838) and was still legally hunted; his presence at international reform meetings represented extraordinary courage and an emerging prominence.
  • The constitutional convention was debating whether New York should contract debt at all without voter approval—revealing anxieties about state finances and democratic accountability in the 1840s that feel oddly modern.
Fun Facts
  • Elihu Burritt, mentioned here organizing peace lectures in English railway guides, would become one of the 19th century's most prolific peace advocates—he eventually learned 30+ languages and spent decades working for international arbitration, living to see the first peace conferences at The Hague in 1899.
  • William Lloyd Garrison's American Anti-Slavery Society had become so radical by 1846 that moderate abolitionists were distancing themselves. Just two years earlier, the American Anti-Slavery Society had fractured over his increasingly extreme tactics—this London campaign would deepen those divisions.
  • The reporter's skepticism about dissolving the Union was prescient: just 15 years later, the Union would nearly dissolve, but over the question of slavery's expansion into western territories, not over British agitation. The fears expressed here about foreign interference in American affairs would haunt sectional politics throughout the 1850s.
  • Bradshaw's Railway Guide, which Burritt used to distribute peace messaging, was THE transportation reference of the era—founded in 1841, it became so ubiquitous that by the 1890s, Sherlock Holmes mysteries would reference it as the go-to source for tracking suspects by train schedules.
  • The comet discovered July 30, 1846, emerged during a year of astronomical excitement—Neptune would be discovered just weeks later in September, validating mathematical predictions and captivating the scientific world Burritt moved through.
Contentious Politics International Civil Rights Diplomacy Science Discovery
September 24, 1846 September 26, 1846

Also on September 25

View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free