“One Penny for Your Thoughts: How a Temperance Paper Launched Washington's Media Wars in 1846”
What's on the Front Page
The Columbian Fountain, a new temperance-focused newspaper edited by Ulysses Ward with assistance from Rev. J.T. Ward, launches in Washington, D.C. as a daily publication selling for one cent per copy. The masthead proudly declares the paper's mission: devoted to "Temperance, Morality, Literature, News, Science, Business and general interest"—though conspicuously excluding "sectarian, political, or personal character." The paper occupies offices on Pennsylvania Avenue near the railroad and promises readers a blend of "variety, amusement, and instruction." Alongside the publisher's declaration, the front page is crowded with Washington's commercial life: house furnishers, tailors, blacksmiths, dentists, and chemists advertising their services. A serialized story titled "Worth and Beauty" by Mrs. M.N. M'Donald begins, following the romantic misadventures of Edward Nealand, a perpetual bachelor navigating courtship with a dozen lovely cousins in New York society. Poetry from Wordsworth and reflections on Niagara Falls round out the literary content.
Why It Matters
In 1846, America was in ideological ferment. The Mexican-American War had just begun (June 1846), throwing the nation into heated debates about slavery's expansion into new territories. The Temperance movement was simultaneously gaining enormous momentum—it would become one of the century's defining moral crusades. This newspaper's explicit founding commitment to temperance reflects how thoroughly this cause had penetrated American civic life by mid-century. The fact that a new D.C. paper could launch with "temperance" as its primary mission speaks to the movement's mainstream appeal among educated, commercial classes. Meanwhile, the ads reveal a thriving urban commercial culture in the nation's capital—furniture dealers, importers of fine goods, and professional services clustered around Pennsylvania Avenue and Brown's Hotel, showing Washington's growing cosmopolitanism.
Hidden Gems
- Dr. C.H. Van Patten advertises as a dentist performing 'all operations upon the Teeth, Gums and Mouth, with the greatest care and skill'—and he's located 'next door to Todd's Hat Store' on Pennsylvania Avenue. Dental work in 1846 was performed without anesthesia or modern tools, making this advertisement both mundane and grimly horrifying.
- W. Whitney's Boot and Shoe Dealer specifically advertises boots 'suitable for plantation use'—a euphemistic reference to slave labor. This casual inclusion reflects how normalized the slave economy was in Washington commerce, even in a supposedly morality-focused publication.
- Saml. Devaughn's ad promises 'a large supply of best Sweedish Leeches, already on hand, to be applied or for sale'—bloodletting was still standard medical practice. He also sells ice 'whenever called for,' suggesting ice was a premium commodity before mechanical refrigeration.
- The mail arrangements section reveals the fragmentation of American communication: separate mail runs to the East (Baltimore, Philadelphia, New York, Boston), West, and South, with no mail service on Sunday mornings—reflecting both religious observance and the logistics of horse-powered delivery.
- Thomas P. Morgan's 'Improved Chemical Chloride Soap' promises to cure 'cutaneous diseases, particularly in infants' and remove 'grease, paint, tar, &c. from clothing'—the same product marketed for both medicinal and industrial cleaning, a practice that would horrify modern regulators.
Fun Facts
- The paper costs one cent—roughly 35 cents in modern money—making it genuinely affordable mass media. This pricing strategy, pioneered by "penny papers" a decade earlier, democratized news and helped fuel the rise of newspapers as the dominant information medium of the 19th century.
- Rev. J.T. Ward serves as Assistant Editor alongside editor Ulysses Ward (likely his son). Clergy-journalists were common in this era, reflecting how deeply religious institutions were embedded in American public discourse—the temperance movement in particular was heavily church-driven.
- The serialized story features characters like 'Ben Lyde, who drove a splendid pair of grays'—owning matched carriage horses was status signaling for the wealthy. Within 50 years, automobiles would make this entire social vocabulary obsolete.
- Pennsylvania Avenue is clearly the commercial heart of Washington, with ads clustering around 'Brown's Hotel' and the railroad depot. The nation's capital in 1846 was still a relatively modest city, and Pennsylvania Avenue was only beginning its transformation into the grand ceremonial boulevard it would become.
- The existence of multiple specialized newspapers (daily at one cent, weekly at three cents) shows how the market had already segmented by 1846. Readers could choose their medium based on frequency and price—print media ecology was surprisingly sophisticated even before the telegraph.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free