Friday
December 23, 1927
Douglas daily dispatch (Douglas, Ariz.) — Cochise, Douglas
“The Marian Parker Murder: How a Teenage 'Plausible Liar' Terrified a Nation for One Week”
Art Deco mural for December 23, 1927
Original newspaper scan from December 23, 1927
Original front page — Douglas daily dispatch (Douglas, Ariz.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The nationwide manhunt for William E. Hickman, the 19-year-old accused of kidnapping and murdering 12-year-old Marian Parker of Los Angeles, has ended with his dramatic capture in a high-speed chase on the Columbia River Highway near Pendleton, Oregon. Hickman was arrested after evading a massive police cordon by slipping through Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Portland with two unwitting companions before state traffic officer Buck McWallen and Pendleton Police Chief Tom Gurdane cornered him in a furious chase. The crime itself is almost unthinkably brutal: on December 15, Hickman posed as a bank employee to extract Marian from her high school under false pretenses, then orchestrated a ransom scheme involving multiple threatening letters and phone calls to her father, Perry M. Parker, an assistant bank cashier. After Parker paid $1,500 in gold notes on December 17, the girl was returned to him dismembered. Hickman, exhausted and hysterical, now claims an accomplice named 'Andrew Cramer' committed the actual murder and mutilation, though police and detectives express deep skepticism of this alibi, characterizing Hickman as 'one of the most plausible liars in the world.' The capture has brought immense relief to southern California, where mothers report feeling freed from a week of paralyzing fear about their own children's safety.

Why It Matters

The Marian Parker case arrived at a critical moment in American criminal history. The 1920s saw the rise of organized crime and modern kidnapping as a deliberate criminal enterprise, yet police methods remained scattered and jurisdictional. Hickman's capture across state lines—from California to Oregon—demonstrated both the limitations and emerging possibilities of coordinated law enforcement. The case also arrived as the nation grappled with Prohibition's unintended consequences: the criminalization of alcohol had created a lawless culture that spawned more brazen, violent offenses. Just weeks away from Christmas 1927, the crime shattered the era's veneer of prosperity and innocence, forcing American families to confront that danger could lurk even in daylight, even in schools. The $100,000 reward and massive public manhunt signaled how celebrity crime and media sensationalism were reshaping American justice—this wasn't just a local murder anymore, but a national obsession.

Hidden Gems
  • Hickman initially told police he was 19, but his mother swore under oath he was under 18 to secure him juvenile probation on forgery charges—a lie that worked so well it set the pattern for his later deceptions. The detective noted this was the exact same 'plausible lying' that would enable him to deceive a teacher into releasing a child to his custody weeks later.
  • After the ransom exchange, Hickman actually drove just one block before abandoning the dismembered body at the curb—suggesting either panic or calculated cruelty, but the casual proximity is chilling: the girl's father was mere feet away while her remains were being casually discarded.
  • The newspaper reports Hickman claimed to have taken Marian to 'a motion picture show' the night before her death and quoted her saying 'I wonder what the school kids will say when I go back'—a haunting detail suggesting he may have been maintaining a facade of normalcy with his captive victim hours before her alleged murder.
  • Police found newspaper packages containing the missing parts of Marian's body scattered across Elysian Park, apparently thrown from a moving automobile—the killer essentially littering human remains across a public recreation area, revealing either recklessness or an eerie indifference.
Fun Facts
  • Hickman obtained his initial bank employment two years before the crime, meaning he had access to Perry Parker's personnel information long before the kidnapping—a detail that reveals how the crime was far more premeditated and calculated than his rambling confession suggests, contradicting his claim it was simply a scheme to raise college tuition.
  • The $100,000 reward placed on Hickman's head was astronomical for 1927 (equivalent to roughly $1.7 million today), yet he was captured by routine traffic officers during a routine pursuit—not by bounty hunters or organized search parties, a reminder that luck and procedural policing often catch criminals, not dramatic detective work.
  • Hickman's claim of an accomplice named 'Andrew Cramer' was so dubious that police immediately launched a 'far-flung roundup' of every man named Cramer with a suspicious record in Los Angeles—suggesting either Hickman's desperation to share blame or the era's limited ability to distinguish truth from elaborate lies without forensic evidence.
  • The case occurred during the Christmas season, and newspapers emphasized how the crime had 'killed the joy' of the holiday for southern California mothers—an early instance of how media coverage of violent crime against children could create widespread, paralyzing fear across an entire region within days.
Sensational Roaring Twenties Prohibition Crime Violent Crime Trial Transportation Auto
December 22, 1927 December 24, 1927

Also on December 23

View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free