“A Preacher's Tribute to His Friend—a Gun-Slinging Whiskey Merchant in 1880s Arizona”
Original front page — Lake Charles commercial (Lake Charles, Calcasieu Parish, La.) — Click to enlarge
What's on the Front Page
This September 1886 issue of the Lake Charles Commercial is essentially a civic directory masquerading as a newspaper front page. The masthead lists every imaginable official from U.S. Senators (S. Eustis and Gibson, both of Orleans Parish) down through state officers, judges, parish officials, school board members, and town aldermen. Below the bureaucracy sits a curated collection of local business advertisements and opinion pieces clipped from other papers. There's poetry about golden wedding anniversaries, a darkly humorous account of a Tombstone, Arizona preacher defending his dead friend "Jim Baker"—a Christian gun-slinger and saloon owner who ran an "honest faro game" and contributed Apache scalp bounties to missionary work—and heated political commentary on tariff policy and the sudden silence of Republicans on "the Negro question" in their recent state platforms.
Why It Matters
In 1886, America was navigating the aftermath of Reconstruction and the consolidation of industrial capitalism. The tariff debate dominating this page's political commentary reflected a genuine national fracture: Democrats were positioning themselves as the party of "tariff for revenue only," while Republicans defended protective tariffs that favored manufacturers. Meanwhile, the Republican Party's strategic pivot away from championing African American rights—noted here as shocking and cynical—signaled the closing of the Reconstruction era and the coming tacit abandonment of Black voters to Southern disenfranchisement. Lake Charles itself, a small Louisiana port town, was precisely the kind of place where these national forces played out locally, through the election of representatives and the enforcement of federal policy.
Hidden Gems
- The Rev. Joel McWhacker of Tombstone proudly notes that his deceased friend Jim Baker "made as much as $500 a year in Apache scalp bounties, and always gave me the money thus earned as his contribution to the missionary fund"—suggesting that scalp-hunting for government bounties was a normalcy in 1880s Arizona, even worthy of pious moral approval.
- An advertisement for Leon Viterbo's boot and shoe factory boasts of 'The Largest Assortment of Ladies', Gents', Misses', and Boys' Boots and Shoes, at the lowest cash prices'—yet no actual prices are listed, only the promise of comparison shopping, suggesting competitive pricing transparency was a novel selling point.
- Dr. L.C. Anderson, a Dental Surgeon, advertises that he's 'A GRADUATE of the Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery' and offers 'Gas administered when desired, and teeth extracted without pain'—indicating that anesthesia in dentistry was still a specialty service, not standard practice.
- The entire front page is dominated by a civic directory listing officials, with almost no actual news stories—suggesting that in smaller towns, newspapers functioned as much as public record keepers and business directories as they did as news organs.
- A mysterious classified note warns: 'LOOT NOTICE' and mentions something about a house and January dates, but the OCR rendering makes it illegible—a reminder that some historical records are lost not to time but to the limitations of nineteenth-century printing and twenty-first century scanning.
Fun Facts
- The tariff debate raging in this newspaper's political columns would explode into one of the defining issues of the 1888 presidential election, just two years away. The Democratic 'tariff for revenue only' platform would lose decisively to Republican Benjamin Harrison's defense of protective tariffs—a victory that would lock American industrial policy into protectionism for decades.
- Rev. McWhacker's account of Jim Baker as a morally upright gun-slinger and saloon owner reflects a genuine frontier Christianity that was simultaneously being romanticized in dime novels and condemned by urban reformers—this tension would define American culture for another generation.
- The Republican silence on 'the Negro question' noted here as a stunning shift would solidify into the 'Solid South'—a Democratic voting bloc sustained by the virtual exclusion of Black voters—that would dominate American politics until the 1960s.
- Leon Viterbo's 'Strictly One Price Cash Store' advertised here was part of a retail revolution; fixed pricing and cash-only sales were still novel enough to advertise as moral virtue, contrasting with older systems of haggling and credit.
- Lake Charles itself, a sleepy Louisiana port in 1886, would boom into a petrochemical hub within fifty years—oil and natural gas discoveries would transform the entire region, making this small civic directory a snapshot of pre-industrial Louisiana.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free