“A Supreme Court Judge Dies, Georgia Picks Its Next Governor—and a Cotton Swindler Steals $85,000”
What's on the Front Page
Judge David Davis, a towering figure in American politics, died this morning in Bloomington, Illinois at age 71. A former Supreme Court Justice, Senator, and Labor Reform presidential candidate, Davis succumbed to Bright's disease of the kidneys, aggravated by complications from a carbuncle that first appeared on April 30. His funeral—set for Tuesday at 3 p.m.—will draw an extraordinary assembly of national figures, including Robert T. Lincoln and General John A. Logan as pallbearers. Meanwhile, Georgia's Democratic primary is heating up, with General John B. Gordon surging far ahead of rival Bacon in delegate selection across twenty counties. Gordon's commanding lead—with 118 delegates to Bacon's 65 from just 178 of 360 convention delegates—suggests his nomination for governor is nearly assured. The Savannah harbor appropriation also secured a crucial $175,000 boost thanks to efforts by local Representative James Freeman Norwood, after an initial clerical error in dispatch reporting nearly derailed the project.
Why It Matters
David Davis's death marks the end of an era. He had been a bridge between the Civil War generation and the Gilded Age—Lincoln's campaign manager, a Lincoln appointee to the Supreme Court, and a symbol of Republican power in the Midwest. His passing in 1886 occurred during a period when the Republican Party was fracturing over tariffs, monetary policy, and civil service reform, and his absence would remove a stabilizing moderate voice. Meanwhile, the Georgia gubernatorial race reflected the Democratic South's consolidation of power after Reconstruction's end. Gordon, a former Confederate general, embodied the "Redeemer" movement—white Democratic leaders reasserting Southern political control. These simultaneous stories capture 1886 America: the old guard dying, regional powers solidifying, and infrastructure investments (like Savannah's harbor) becoming flashpoints for political patronage and progress.
Hidden Gems
- A swindler operating between Texarkana, Texas and St. Louis executed a cotton fraud so brazen it was called 'one of the biggest cotton swindles on record'—he sent premium cotton samples to Eastern buyers, then shipped the lowest-grade, 'low, sandy and stained cotton' he could find, netting an estimated $85,000 in excess profits through coordinated wire transfers via Texas banks.
- The Missouri legislature was caught in flagrant impropriety: the Iron Mountain Railroad Company distributed free whisky and cigars to House members during debate on their elevated railroad bill, then hosted the entire chamber at a 'royal carousal' at a nearby saloon after passage—a scandal so obvious the Republican newspaper publicly called them out for it.
- A remarkable double-breaking locomotive accident on the Vandalia line: both driving-rods of a ten-wheeler engine snapped simultaneously while flying around a curve near Martinsville, Illinois, with one rod battering the cab to 'splinters' and knocking holes in the boiler, yet the engineer and fireman walked away uninjured when the tender 'providentially' jumped back onto the rails just before crossing a bridge.
- The New Pension Building in Washington was roasted by Congress during appropriations debate as 'an architectural monstrosity' and 'a cross between a horse car stable and a union depot,' with Representative Springer suggesting some ornamentation 'should be blown up with dynamite'—though others defended its commodiousness and ventilation.
- General Mahone's Republican State Central Committee in Virginia received explicit instructions to field a nominee in every congressional district for the fall campaign, including potentially pitting John S. Wise against his own cousin George D. Wise in the Richmond district—a rare public family political split during the Reconstruction era.
Fun Facts
- Judge David Davis's estate amassed 'several millions of dollars' through early Illinois land speculation—a fortune that would translate to roughly $80-100 million in today's money, making him emblematic of how Gilded Age fortunes were built on Western land acquisition rather than industrial manufacturing.
- General John B. Gordon, the leading gubernatorial candidate in Georgia, was a former Confederate general whose political resurrection represented the complete restoration of Southern Democratic power—by 1886, just 21 years after Lee's surrender, the South had already reasserted total political control through figures like Gordon, who would serve as governor and later U.S. Senator.
- Representative James Freeman Norwood's successful push for the $175,000 Savannah harbor appropriation illustrated how federal infrastructure investment became intertwined with regional political patronage—harbor improvements were vital to coastal cities' economic survival in an era when water transport still dominated commerce.
- The Fitz-John Porter relief bill mentioned on this page—expected to be signed Monday—would eventually restore the Union general's rank and reputation after his controversial removal during the Civil War, showing how even Civil War controversies remained live political issues a full 21 years after Appomattox.
- The pencil-and-paper logistics of selecting 360 convention delegates across Georgia counties in real-time, reported daily to newspapers, was how American parties actually organized before telephones and national conventions became coordinated—each county held its own mass meeting, and results trickled in piecemeal over days.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free