“1866: When Western Newspapers Declared Independence from New York—Plus a Hero's Death in the Flames”
What's on the Front Page
The Chicago Tribune for December 14, 1866, leads with the **Western Associated Press declaring independence from the New York monopoly**—a pivotal moment in American journalism. By a vote of 10-3, western newspapers claimed the right to manage their own telegraph news collection and distribution, breaking free from what the paper calls "an intolerable despotism and strangulation." This wasn't merely industry gossip; it fundamentally redistributed power over information flow across the nation, promising a "republican form of government" among western papers.
But tragedy dominates the local pages. A **devastating fire in Waukegan consumed multiple buildings** and claimed the life of Captain Hiram M. Hugunin, a respected 68-year-old civic elder who had been Waukegan's corporate president and built the city's lighthouse pier. While attempting to douse flames with a pail of water, Hugunin fell through a trap door into the cellar below. The building collapsed, burying him beneath burning ruins. Total property loss exceeded $500,000. The paper devotes considerable space to Hugunin's legacy, noting he "left no family behind him" except a daughter, Mrs. Maria Gilbert, and that his "memory and good deeds as a public man will be none the less revered."
Why It Matters
December 1866 captures America just eighteen months after the Civil War's end, during a tumultuous Reconstruction period. The Western Associated Press story reveals deep anxieties about centralized power—the same tensions that defined the war itself. As Congress debated how to reconstruct the South, American newspapers fought their own battles over who controlled information. The AP split reflected broader regionalism: the West demanded autonomy from Eastern elites.
Meanwhile, the paper's coverage of colored schools in Louisville, the Colorado statehood bill in Congress, and freedmen's education initiatives shows the nation grappling with the war's aftermath. Even international dispatches—Russia proposing a congress on Turkish Christians, Mexico's Emperor Maximilian "undecided," Fenian privateers threatening British vessels—reveal a fractured world struggling to rebuild after unprecedented conflict.
Hidden Gems
- The Waukegan fire destroyed the entire stock of attorney Blodgett, Upton & Williams, including a 'fine library valued at $5,000' and office furniture—they had 'no insurance.' Losing a specialized legal library in a single fire was professionally catastrophic in an era with no photocopiers or digital backups.
- Captain Hugunin 'settled in your county with his family in 1811'—making him a Waukegan pioneer from the era when the region was barely settled. His death in 1866 symbolized the end of an earlier frontier generation.
- The Springfield dispatch mentions the Illinois Soldiers' College valued at $50,000, with a proposed endowment fund of $50,000 'to be used as a college for disabled soldiers and a home for the orphans of soldiers.' This was one of the nation's earliest benefits programs for war veterans—five years before the Grand Army of the Republic formalized veterans' advocacy.
- The tariff bill mentioned in the Washington section 'provides for a six-cent duty on foreign wool'—protectionism was already reshaping American manufacturing just as the country reunited.
- A colliery explosion at Barnsley, England killed 300 miners. The Tribune reports it matter-of-factly in just three lines—illustrating how industrial catastrophes, while shocking, were becoming routine news in the industrial age.
Fun Facts
- The Western Associated Press's revolt against New York's monopoly would eventually lead to the formation of competing wire services. Within a decade, this competitive pressure forced dramatic improvements in telegraph transmission speed and reliability—technological innovation born from the desire for independence from centralized control.
- Captain Hugunin built Waukegan's lighthouse pier mentioned in the article. Chicago's harbor infrastructure—the piers, breakwaters, and navigational aids—was largely built by men like Hugunin in the 1820s-1850s. These structures enabled Chicago's explosive growth into a Great Lakes shipping hub that would eclipse East Coast dominance by the 1880s.
- The Waukegan fire's insurance claims show the nascent insurance industry was already sophisticated in 1866: policies with Hartford, New York, and Chicago companies with specific coverage amounts ($3,500 for the saloon, for instance). Yet A.P. Yard lost $130 'with no insurance'—showing how insurance was still unequally distributed by class.
- The Illinois Soldiers' College proposal presaged the GI Bill by 77 years. This 1866 attempt to create housing and education for disabled veterans and war orphans was radical for its time—most Civil War veterans received pensions but little institutional support. The state's reluctance (the article suggests it needed legislative persuasion) shows how slow American society was to systematize veteran care.
- The mention of 'colored children' attending schools in Louisville is quietly revolutionary: just one year after the Civil War, the Tribune reports on African American education without editorializing against it. By 1866, the Radical Republicans who controlled Congress were pushing Reconstruction legislation that protected freedmen's rights—a radical shift from pre-war coverage.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free