“Did Jefferson Davis Order Lincoln's Assassination? A Shocking Claim Surfaces in 1866”
What's on the Front Page
The December 13, 1866 Evansville Journal delivers a nation still convulsing in the aftermath of the Civil War. The lead story reports a startling allegation: a French-Canadian informant named St. Maries claims that John Surratt—the fugitive son of Lincoln's conspirator Mary Surratt—revealed that Lincoln's assassination was a "preconcerted plot" orchestrated directly by Confederate President Jefferson Davis's cabinet in Richmond. This bombshell appears alongside grim dispatches from North Carolina, where vigilante groups called "Regulators" are systematically executing Northern transplants and lynching freedmen. Meanwhile, British authorities have seized the steamer Bolivar in the Medway, suspecting it of being a Fenian privateer carrying arms and powder—reflecting ongoing fears of Irish-American raids into Canada. Back home, the Second Auditor's report catalogs the massive fiscal burden of demobilization: over 91,000 accounts settled, with bounties for soldiers totaling $10.4 million and accumulated military debts exceeding $110 million. The closure of the Erie Canal and updates on railroad reconstruction projects signal the North's pivot toward commerce.
Why It Matters
This snapshot captures America at a critical inflection point. The Civil War had ended less than two years earlier, but Reconstruction was collapsing into chaos. The revelation about Lincoln's assassination speaks to lingering doubts about the conspiracy's scope—Americans were still trying to make sense of the national trauma. The violence in North Carolina represents the beginning of systematic terror campaigns that would define Reconstruction, eventually enabling white Southern Democrats to seize back power through intimidation. The Fenian threat was very real: Irish-American Civil War veterans, angry at Britain, were launching actual raids into Canada during these months. Meanwhile, the astronomical military expenditures reflected in the Auditor's report show why the postwar economy was so strained, fueling inflation and labor unrest. This was the era when Lincoln's vision of lenient Reconstruction was dying, replaced by radicals' determination to remake the South—a struggle that would define the next five years.
Hidden Gems
- The Surratt revelation appears casually midway through the telegraph section, yet it's potentially one of the most explosive claims ever made about Lincoln's death: that Jefferson Davis's cabinet directly ordered the assassination. This story seems to have vanished from mainstream historical accounts—most historians treat the conspiracy as Booth's independent plot.
- A letter from Raleigh, North Carolina tersely reports: "The Regulators are cleaning out the Yankees and the negroes. Northerners are being shot, and the negroes hung, daily." This matter-of-fact tone masks organized genocide. The paper treats this as ordinary news alongside weather and railroad updates.
- The Second Auditor's report itemizes $1.7 billion in Civil War claims processed in a single fiscal year—in 1866 dollars. For comparison, the entire U.S. annual revenue was under $300 million. The bureaucratic apparatus for paying soldiers and processing bounties was consuming the entire federal budget.
- Governor Wright, the American Ambassador to Prussia, is reported "seriously ill" in Berlin—a one-line mention that's historically invisible today, yet diplomatic correspondence from this period shows he was dealing with post-war German state politics.
- The Erie Canal is closing for winter—a reminder that this 44-year-old infrastructure marvel was still the lifeblood of American commerce, competing with rail lines just beginning their expansion across the continent.
Fun Facts
- John Surratt, mentioned in this dispatch, would actually turn up alive in Egypt in 1866 (this story may reflect rumors of that capture). He was extradited, tried for conspiracy in a sensational trial that summer, and bizarrely acquitted—the jury hung 8-4 for conviction. He lived until 1916, dying a free man.
- The Fenian raids mentioned here were real: thousands of Irish-American Civil War vets actually invaded Canada multiple times between 1866-1870, seeing it as a way to strike at Britain. The raids failed militarily but nearly dragged the U.S. into war with Britain over neutrality violations.
- That $110 million in military department audits? Adjusted for inflation, it's roughly $1.8 billion in today's money—and this was just one year of settlement processing. The U.S. wouldn't see federal budgets this large again until World War I.
- The Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, mentioned here with J.W. Garrett's reelection as president, was America's oldest major railroad (chartered 1827). It was actively rebuilding Southern lines during Reconstruction—essentially profiting from the war's destruction.
- The Atlantic Telegraph mentioned for market reports shows how by 1866, financial news was traveling instantaneously across the ocean via cable—yet violent deaths in North Carolina were still reported days late, revealing how unevenly modernity had reached America.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free