“The Empress Who Refused to Leave the Vatican—Plus Johnson's Civil War Still Raging”
What's on the Front Page
The New York Herald's October 21, 1866 edition is dominated by international intrigue and domestic political turmoil in the immediate aftermath of the Civil War. The lead story concerns the Empress of Mexico, Carlotta, who has dramatically presented herself at the Vatican to seek Pope Pius IX's blessing for her husband Emperor Maximilian's religious policies. According to a Rome correspondent, she arrived unannounced at nine in the morning and refused to leave until nearly six in the evening—essentially staging a sit-in at the papal residence. The Pope reportedly denied her request outright, yet she remained in his private study while he conducted his regular audiences. Back home, the paper reports on General Sheridan's military buildup along the Texas frontier, where cavalry forces are being concentrated "for the purpose of protecting the frontier" amid lingering post-war tensions. Meanwhile, Washington is abuzz with President Andrew Johnson's political battles: Colonel John W. Forney's supporters serenaded him at a fair building, where Forney denounced Johnson as "calamitous and treacherous," accusing him of fomenting a "second rebellion" by returning power to former Confederates.
Why It Matters
In October 1866, America was barely a year past Lee's surrender, caught between reconstruction and revenge. Johnson's lenient policies toward the South were sparking fierce Republican opposition—visible here in Forney's fiery denunciations. The Mexican situation reflected broader anxieties: Maximilian's French-backed empire was collapsing, and European powers were still eyeing American weakness. The frontier troop movements under Sheridan suggested lingering Confederate sympathies in Texas required military oversight. This was the moment when Congress would soon override Johnson's vetoes and impose Radical Reconstruction, reshaping the nation's political future. The Herald itself was a battleground of opinion—covering both the angry Republicans and the President's defenders with equal ink.
Hidden Gems
- Fractional currency dominance: The Treasury report shows the government was actively destroying old paper currency ($230,800 worth that week alone) while printing new fractional currency ($611,600 received), a direct consequence of wartime financial chaos and the need to rebuild monetary stability post-war.
- The Empress's feminist power play: Carlotta essentially forced a private audience with the Pope by refusing to leave—a remarkable act of defiance for a woman in 1866, and one the correspondent explicitly notes by calling it 'A FEMALE PUZZLE IN THE VATICAN.'
- A bank heist with brutal violence: The page concludes with a developing story of a gang that attacked R. Butterfield, cashier of the National Bank in Houlton, Maine, striking him with a slung shot, gagging him and his wife, and threatening to kill their infant child to steal from the bank vault—suggesting post-war criminality was turning violent and organized.
- Japanese diplomatic visitors heading to Richmond: The paper notes Japanese merchants who 'have left for Richmond' after a stay in Washington, 'won the esteem of all with whom they came in contact by their modest and gentlemanly demeanor'—Japan was just beginning diplomatic engagement with America, and this visit was still exotic enough to merit commentary.
- Colonel Denis F. Burke's Irish-American prisoner advocacy: A Fenian officer meets with President Johnson to demand better U.S. consuls in Ireland, highlighting the Irish-American political lobby and lingering tensions over imprisoned Irish-American soldiers—a key demographic conflict of the Reconstruction era.
Fun Facts
- Empress Carlotta's Vatican standoff would end in tragedy: Within months, Maximilian would be executed in Mexico by firing squad in June 1867, and Carlotta would suffer a mental breakdown, spending her remaining 60 years in various European asylums—making this October 1866 moment her last act as an effective political player.
- General Philip Sheridan, commanding the Texas frontier in this dispatch, would become the architect of the Indian Wars on the Great Plains over the next decade and later serve as commanding general of the entire U.S. Army—his consolidation of cavalry forces here was practice for larger strategic operations.
- Colonel John W. Forney, the Republican firebrand denouncing Johnson, was Philadelphia's most powerful newspaper publisher and a Lincoln loyalist; he would help elect Grant in 1868 and shape Republican ideology for a generation—this Herald report captures him at peak political influence.
- The Japanese merchants visiting Richmond were part of Japan's Iwakura Mission (1871-1873) preparatory missions, touring to understand Western industrial and political systems before Japan's Meiji Restoration modernization—America's first serious diplomatic relationship with Japan was beginning.
- The $6,268,131 in Treasury vaults reported that week included only $360,000 in gold and $2,600 in silver—nearly all the wealth was in paper notes, reflecting how the war had forced America off specie-based currency toward fiat money, a permanent financial revolution.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free