“What Was Found Above Benjamin Franklin's Deathbed? A 1866 Mystery From the California Frontier”
What's on the Front Page
The October 20, 1866 issue of the Placer Herald is dominated by a lengthy reprint titled "Franklin's Death-Bed," a deeply personal account of Benjamin Franklin's final moments. The piece, sourced from a Philadelphia newspaper, recounts how David Ritter visited Franklin's home only to learn from his nurse, Sarah Humphries (a Quaker woman renowned throughout Philadelphia for her care of the dying), that the great statesman had just passed away. What makes the narrative remarkable is Ritter's discovery of a portrait of Christ on the cross hanging above Franklin's bed—a detail that fascinated him, given widespread doubts about Franklin's Christian faith. Humphries defends Franklin's piety, explaining that "many who make a great fuss about religion have very little, while some who say but little about it have a great deal." The rest of the front page is filled with local business advertisements: boot makers, attorneys, dentists, and the United States House tavern offering fine liquors and cigars. An extensive Ayer's Cathartic Pills advertisement dominates the lower half, featuring testimonials from physicians across America praising the remedy for everything from headaches to rheumatism.
Why It Matters
Just one year after the Civil War's end, America was grappling with fundamental questions about national identity, morality, and the character of its founding figures. Franklin—dead since 1790—represented the Enlightenment ideals that had shaped the Republic, yet his religious beliefs had long been ambiguous to the public. Publishing this account in rural California suggests how deeply invested even frontier communities were in understanding their nation's philosophical heritage. Meanwhile, the advertisements reveal the booming post-war economy: professional services were flourishing in Auburn, and patent medicines like Ayer's Pills were becoming national phenomena, marketed through testimonials from respected physicians. This was America reconstructing itself, both politically and commercially.
Hidden Gems
- The newspaper explicitly states subscription rates and payment terms: one year cost $5.00 in gold and silver, payable in advance. The 'Law of Newspapers' section reveals that refusing to pick up your paper from the office was legally considered 'prima facie evidence of intentional fraud'—imagine being sued for newspaper abandonment.
- Dr. F. Walton Todd's office was located 'in building adjoining Temple Saloon' on Court Street in Auburn—suggesting medical practice literally adjacent to drinking establishments, which was apparently unremarkable at the time.
- Thomas Jamison advertised as both County Coroner AND General Undertaker, offering 'ready made coffins always on hand' and 'special attention given to disinterring and removing bodies'—a decidedly macabre one-stop shop.
- The Probate notice shows Charles H. Maloney and Eliza Maloney petitioning for distribution of D. H. Maloney's estate on September 17, 1866—less than two years after the Civil War ended, with the court hearing scheduled for October 20th, the very date of this newspaper's publication.
- Ayer's Pills cost 25 cents per box or 5 boxes for $1.00 (1866 prices), yet the advertisement spans nearly half the front page with endorsements from physicians in Baltimore, New Orleans, Washington D.C., Montreal, and Boston—this was a genuinely national brand at a time when most commerce was still local.
Fun Facts
- Benjamin Franklin died in 1790, and this account of his death-bed is being published 76 years later in 1866—suggesting the narrative had circulated in Philadelphia newspapers for decades before being reprinted in the California frontier, demonstrating how slowly information traveled and how hungry distant communities were for stories about the Founders.
- The narrative emphasizes Franklin's 'usefulness' and his daily habit of doing 'somebody a service,' reflecting post-Civil War America's anxious desire to rehabilitate the Founders as moral exemplars during Reconstruction—when the nation desperately needed shared values after four years of fratricidal war.
- Sarah Humphries, the Quaker nurse, was so renowned for her end-of-life care that many Philadelphians believed they 'could not sicken and die right' without her—in an era with no modern medical care, nursing skill was literally a matter of dignity and community status.
- The extensive physician testimonials for Ayer's Pills—from Dr. L.W. Cartwright in New Orleans to Dr. Alonzo Ball at the Marine Hospital in Washington—represent the beginning of pharmaceutical marketing as we know it: using authority figures and geographic diversity to build national brand trust.
- The paper cost subscribers $5.00 per year (roughly $88 in 2024 dollars), yet the single issue contains legal notices, professional ads, and national pharmaceutical marketing—suggesting that local newspapers were already consolidating into a national media ecosystem just 21 years after the Pony Express ended.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free