“How Louisiana Tried to Charm President Johnson (and Failed): Inside the Desperate Diplomacy of February 1866”
What's on the Front Page
Just eleven months after Robert E. Lee's surrender at Appomattox, Louisiana's state legislature is locked in heated debate over how to present itself to President Andrew Johnson. The General Assembly has approved a resolution to send commissioners to Washington to deliver resolutions expressing the state's "sentiments and purpose" regarding federal relations—a diplomatic mission meant to counter what lawmakers fear are damaging misrepresentations of Louisiana's loyalty to the Union. The Senate split over whether to rush the commissioners or deliberate carefully, with Senator Kenner warning against "antagonism between co-ordinate branches of government" after disputes between the Governor and legislature. Meanwhile, the House hears testimony that New Orleans' tax collection system is hemorrhaging money—$16,177 in 1865 alone—and that nearly 5,000 more business licenses were collected by the city than the state, raising questions about where the missing revenues went. The legislature grinds through dozens of bills: legitimizing children born out of wedlock, authorizing bridge construction across Bayou Lafourche, and settling relief claims for veterans of the War of 1812.
Why It Matters
This February 1866 session captures Louisiana—and the South—at a crucial inflection point. Reconstruction is underway, but its terms remain violently contested. President Johnson, the Tennessee tailor who had opposed secession and championed "popular rights," is being tested by a Southern legislature trying to prove it can govern itself responsibly without federal interference. The commissioners mission reflects the South's strategy: send respectable men to Washington to demonstrate that the region deserves rapid readmission to the Union without harsh punishment or federal oversight of the freedmen's rights. This legislature's concerns about appearing "factious and disloyal" reveals how desperate they were to avoid martial law and military reconstruction—anxieties that would prove prescient when Congress rejected Johnson's lenient approach and imposed military rule just months later.
Hidden Gems
- Senator Kenner's shrewd argument that there was no real antagonism when the Governor vetoed measures and the legislature overrode his veto—'Each branch had exercised only its constitutional right'—shows how Louisiana lawmakers were desperately trying to appear constitutionally normal, even as the state remained under contested authority just weeks after the Civil War ended.
- The mysterious missing 4,500+ business licenses: the text notes New Orleans collected 11,326 licenses in 1865 while the state only collected 6,321—a staggering discrepancy that suggests either massive tax evasion, data corruption, or administrative chaos in a city still reeling from occupation and war.
- A bill to 'legitimize Andrew Jackson Dunn' passed without fanfare—routine legislative language that masks the post-war social upheaval: children born during wartime chaos were being formally recognized by law, a small window into family disruption the war created.
- The Charity Hospital was depending on lottery ticket sales to stay solvent—Louisiana was so financially broken that the legislature had to authorize gambling to fund basic medical care for the poor.
- Only 21-23 senators showed up for critical votes on the President's commission—sparse attendance that Senator Palfrey complained about when the Governor's veto of the Vermillion Bay Canal project came up, suggesting mass legislative abdication or fear of taking controversial stances.
Fun Facts
- President Johnson, whom Senator McEnery praised as 'a firm and consistent advocate of popular rights,' would be impeached by Congress in just over a year—not for the lenient Reconstruction policies Louisiana hoped for, but for firing Secretary of War Stanton, triggering the constitutional crisis that nearly removed him from office.
- The text mentions Virginia, South Carolina, and Mississippi had already sent similar delegations to Washington to lobby the President. These coordinated missions reveal the South's unified strategy to avoid harsh Reconstruction, yet within 18 months, all four states would be placed under military rule anyway—making these diplomatic missions look pathetically optimistic in hindsight.
- Senator Kenner, who argued eloquently for careful deliberation and protecting Louisiana's constitutional position, was a wealthy sugar planter and railroad developer. He would later become a Confederate diplomat—his 1866 speech for constitutional propriety masks how deeply invested he was in preserving the planter class's power.
- The bill to authorize notaries public to celebrate marriages seems mundane, but it reflects post-war legal chaos: thousands of enslaved people had married informally, and their legal status was contested. Marriage law was a proxy battle over who had rights in the new order.
- Lieutenant Governor Voorhies presided over the Senate, yet the legislature was simultaneously debating whether to send commissioners to validate its own legitimacy to the President—a striking image of a Southern state government unsure if it still existed as a legal entity.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free