Tuesday
May 16, 1865
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Illinois, Cook
“May 16, 1865: Jeff Davis Caught in Petticoats — 'The Most Terrible Sarcasm Ever Recorded'”
Art Deco mural for May 16, 1865
Original newspaper scan from May 16, 1865
Original front page — Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The capture of Jefferson Davis dominates this Chicago Tribune front page, with the newspaper reveling in the humiliating details of how the Confederate president was caught fleeing "in female attire" through the woods of Georgia. The Tribune spares no mockery, calling Davis a "consummate scoundrel" and "shocking coward" who "took refuge in his wife's crinoline and surrendered without spilling a drop of his craven blood." Meanwhile, the conspiracy trial of Lincoln's assassins continues in Washington, with damaging testimony emerging against theater stagehand Spangler, who allegedly helped Booth escape and was heard telling someone "Hush! Don't say anything about it" after the murder. The paper also dedicates significant space to boasting about its own circulation numbers, claiming 47,000 daily readers and outselling all other Chicago papers combined.

Why It Matters

This May 16, 1865 edition captures America in the immediate aftermath of Lincoln's assassination and the Confederacy's collapse. The nation was simultaneously seeking justice for Lincoln's murder while grappling with how to reunite a shattered country. Davis's ignominious capture in women's clothing provided Northern newspapers with a perfect symbol of the South's defeat, while the ongoing conspiracy trials kept the wound of Lincoln's death fresh in the public mind. The Tribune's aggressive self-promotion also reflects the fierce competition among newspapers to shape public opinion during this pivotal moment in American history.

Hidden Gems
  • Gold closed at 131⅜ in New York yesterday — meaning it took $1.31 in paper money to buy $1 worth of gold, showing the wartime inflation
  • The Chicago Tribune boasts that its Sunday edition announcing Davis's capture 'exceeded 18,000 copies, three fourths of which were sold in the city'
  • A cotton boat called the Martin Weilt was robbed by just four guerillas of '$18,000 in greenbacks and $30,000 in boots, shoes, drygoods' while anchored at Gaines' Landing
  • The paper plans to expand 'to a ten column sheet' at an additional cost of 'one hundred dollars per day' just for white paper
  • In Detroit, William Holt was sentenced to life in prison 'in solitary confinement at hard work' for murdering Simeon B. Smith on March 18th
Fun Facts
  • The Tribune claims Massachusetts has 176 national banks while Pennsylvania has 182 — this was the era of wildcat banking before the Federal Reserve, when individual banks issued their own currency
  • Jefferson Davis was educated 'at the public expense' at West Point, making his treason particularly galling to Northern readers who felt taxpayers had funded his military training
  • The paper mentions Mr. Harlan entering duties as Secretary of the Interior — that's James Harlan, whose daughter Mary would later marry Robert Todd Lincoln
  • Seven-thirty bonds worth 'a little over four millions' were issued — these were popular Civil War bonds paying 7.30% interest, helping fund the Union war effort
  • The mention of a 'Mexican loan' reflects the complex situation where French forces under Maximilian occupied Mexico while America was distracted by civil war
Triumphant Civil War Reconstruction Politics Federal War Conflict Crime Trial Economy Banking
May 15, 1865 May 17, 1865

Also on May 16

1836
May 1836: Railroads vs. Canals, and a Darker Commerce in Human Beings
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
A Penny a Day for Sobriety: How One D.C. Printer Launched a Temperance...
The Columbian fountain (Washington, D.C.)
1856
Inside New Orleans' Busiest Day: 1856 Shipping Chaos Reveals a City at Peak...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
The Day Arkansas Chose War: A Governor's Message & the Humanity Hidden in the...
Arkansas true Democrat (Little Rock, Ark.)
1862
Evansville, Indiana, May 1862: Life Goes On (While the Civil War Rages)
The Evansville daily journal (Evansville, Ia. [i.e. Ind.])
1863
"Ar'nt I a Woman?": How Sojourner Truth's Lost Speech Returned to Haunt...
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1866
Davis Goes to Trial (Maybe): How Washington Is Rewriting the Rules of War
The Evansville journal (Evansville, Ind.)
1876
When a Widow's Gossip Feared Love: A Maine Love Story From 1876
Oxford Democrat (Paris, Me.)
1886
Anarchist Arrested, 3,000 Bombs Hidden: America's First Red Scare Explodes (May...
Savannah morning news (Savannah)
1896
When a Gunfight Nearly Stopped a Republican Convention: May 16, 1896
The Dalles weekly chronicle (The Dalles, Or.)
1906
Murder Mystery in Maine: When Steam Gave Way to Suspicion (1906)
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1926
Ice chunks nearly doom the first flight over the North Pole (May 16, 1926)
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1927
Murder, Marines, and Midnight Thieves: May 16, 1927's Perfect Storm of American...
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free