“February 1865: When Confederate-Union armies almost joined forces (plus a rebel's revenge killing)”
Original front page — Brownlow's Knoxville Whig, and rebel ventilator (Knoxville, Tenn.) — Click to enlarge
What's on the Front Page
The front page of Brownlow's Knoxville Whig blazes with the headline 'Peace Can we have Peace?' — a passionate editorial exploring whether the dying Confederacy might unite with Union forces against European interference. Editor William 'Parson' Brownlow, the fiery Unionist who'd been imprisoned and exiled by Confederates, envisions a grand reconciliation where 'the armies of Grant and Lee united for a common purpose' would march together to defend the Monroe Doctrine against meddling from England and France. The February 22nd, 1865 edition also carries the chilling account of John Kincaid's assassination — a wealthy rebel who'd persecuted Union families during the war, only to be gunned down by discharged soldiers from the First East Tennessee Regiment after he sued impoverished veterans for old debts. The killers called him out from a neighbor's house and shot him twice through the heart, with one witness writing they would 'cheerfully give in my voice for acquittal' if serving on the jury.
Why It Matters
This newspaper captures the raw, vengeful mood of East Tennessee as the Civil War winds down in February 1865. While Lincoln was preparing his magnanimous Second Inaugural Address about 'malice toward none,' the reality on the ground was far bloodier — a cycle of retribution where former rebels trying to reclaim their property faced frontier justice from Union veterans. Brownlow's fantastical vision of North-South reconciliation against European powers reflects the era's paranoia about foreign intervention, particularly British and French sympathy for the Confederacy. The paper appeared just weeks before Lee's surrender at Appomattox, capturing the desperate Confederate hopes and bitter Unionist rage that would soon explode into the violence of Reconstruction.
Hidden Gems
- John Kincaid was killed exactly 24 hours after discharged soldiers threatened it — they warned the Sheriff on Thursday that 'Kincaid would be killed before twenty-four hours,' and sure enough, Friday evening two men rode up and shot him dead
- The French Government had spent 45 million francs on Paris public improvements since 1852 — a curious international tidbit tucked at the bottom of this war-torn Tennessee newspaper
- Kincaid had sworn a 'long, nauseous oath of three foolscap pages' multiple times during the war to prove his loyalty, only to immediately persecute his Union neighbors afterward
- A wealthy rebel's cotton was seized by Treasury Agent William Homer in December 1864, leading to federal court proceedings where Kincaid had to prove he never gave 'aid and comfort' to the rebellion
Fun Facts
- William 'Parson' Brownlow, this newspaper's editor, was one of the most colorful figures of the Civil War era — a Methodist preacher turned radical journalist who was so hated by Confederates they imprisoned him and eventually banished him to Union lines, making him a Northern celebrity
- The paper's subtitle 'Rebel Ventilator' was Brownlow's sarcastic dig at ventilating (exposing) rebel crimes — he would soon become Tennessee's Reconstruction governor and enforce some of the harshest anti-Confederate policies in the South
- East Tennessee was so divided during the Civil War that it essentially experienced its own civil war within the Civil War — Unionists like Brownlow faced persecution, exile, and violence from their Confederate neighbors, creating the cycle of revenge described in Kincaid's murder
- The letter from 'G. Taylor' mentions Edward Everett, the famous orator who spoke before Lincoln at Gettysburg, had just died while serving as treasurer of East Tennessee relief efforts — Everett had channeled over $50,000 to help war refugees
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free