Tuesday
February 21, 1865
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.) — Cumberland, Maine
“Feb 21, 1865: Confederate Admits Arming Slaves Would Be 'Abolition' 📰”
Art Deco mural for February 21, 1865
Original newspaper scan from February 21, 1865
Original front page — The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The front page is dominated by a fascinating letter from "Wanderer," a correspondent writing from Fortress Monroe, Virginia, offering an insider's view of momentous Civil War developments. He reports on the recent removal of General Benjamin Butler from command (replaced by General Ord), witnesses the failed first bombardment of Fort Fisher, and describes the unsuccessful "Peace Conference" that took place just the week before. The writer predicts there will soon be "thunder all around" as Grant, Sherman, and other Union generals prepare for what he hopes will be a "sharp, short and decisive" spring campaign to crush the rebellion. The page also features a remarkable piece analyzing a speech by Confederate politician Thomas S. Gholson of Virginia, who delivered a devastating argument against the desperate Confederate proposal to arm slaves as soldiers. Gholson systematically dismantled the plan, arguing it would essentially amount to "abolition" and asking pointedly: "What is this but abolition? Our proposition would be: 'Go fight for us, and when the war is over we will make you free.' Our enemies say to them: 'Come to us and we will make you free now.'"

Why It Matters

This February 1865 front page captures the Confederacy at its moment of greatest desperation and internal contradiction. The debate over arming slaves reveals how the South's "peculiar institution" was collapsing under the weight of its own logic — Confederate leaders were literally considering destroying slavery to save slavery. Meanwhile, the failed Hampton Roads Peace Conference (February 3, 1865) had just ended Lincoln's last diplomatic attempt to end the war, setting the stage for the final military push. With Sherman marching through the Carolinas and Grant tightening his grip around Richmond, the war's end was approaching rapidly. The correspondent's prediction of a decisive spring campaign would prove prophetic — Lee would surrender at Appomattox just seven weeks after this paper was published.

Hidden Gems
  • The Portland Daily Press cost $8 per year in advance — equivalent to about $140 today, making it quite expensive for working-class readers
  • A Unitarian Church in San Francisco collected $70,000 in pew rentals for the year, suggesting the extraordinary wealth flowing through Gold Rush California
  • The correspondent describes Virginia's winter weather as 'mild and pleasant as September or October at the North, with no snow and but little frost' — a Civil War soldier's weather report from 159 years ago
  • Advertising rates were precisely structured: $1.50 per square for the first week, then 75 cents per week after, with special rates for 'Amusements' at $2.00 per square per week
  • The writer casually suggests that Commodore Porter and General Butler might settle their Fort Fisher dispute with 'pistols and coffee for two' — dueling was still a conceivable way to resolve military disagreements
Fun Facts
  • General Benjamin Butler, mentioned prominently in the letter, was known as 'Beast Butler' for his harsh occupation of New Orleans — he once ordered that any woman insulting Union soldiers be treated 'as a woman of the town plying her avocation'
  • The correspondent mentions being absent from Maine for 'many months' — this reflects how Civil War military service often lasted years, with some regiments serving their entire three-year enlistments
  • Thomas S. Gholson's statistical argument shows the Confederacy calculated only 300,000 male slaves aged 18-45 were available — revealing how precisely they had counted their human 'property' even as they debated freeing them
  • The failed Fort Fisher expedition mentioned here led directly to a second, successful assault in January 1865, making it one of the last major Confederate strongholds to fall
  • The writer's prediction of prisoner exchanges 'going on uninterruptedly' was significant — these had been suspended for months due to Confederate refusal to treat Black Union soldiers equally
Anxious Civil War War Conflict Military Politics Federal Civil Rights Diplomacy
February 20, 1865 February 22, 1865

Also on February 21

View all 11 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free