Saturday
February 11, 1865
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Illinois, Cook
“The Day Peace Died: Lincoln's Complete Account of the Failed Confederate Negotiations”
Art Deco mural for February 11, 1865
Original newspaper scan from February 11, 1865
Original front page — Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Chicago Tribune's front page is dominated by President Lincoln's full account of the failed Hampton Roads Peace Conference, delivered to Congress just days earlier. The complete documentary history reveals how Francis P. Blair Sr. served as an unofficial intermediary, carrying messages between Lincoln and Confederate President Jefferson Davis. The conference, held near Fortress Monroe, collapsed when Confederate commissioners Alexander Stephens, John A. Campbell, and Robert M.T. Hunter couldn't agree to Lincoln's non-negotiable terms: restoration of national authority, no backing down on slavery, and complete disbanding of rebel forces. Elsewhere on the page, military news suggests the war's end may be near, with speculation that Charleston and Wilmington will soon fall to Union forces, and ultimately Richmond itself. The Tribune warns against complacency, urging Illinois to fill regiment gaps with fresh recruits. In Congress, the debate over the peace terms splits along predictable lines, with Representative Brooks of New York arguing Lincoln should have offered an armistice, while Thaddeus Stevens acidly suggests Brooks seems well-suited to serve as the rebels' advocate on the House floor.

Why It Matters

This February 1865 front page captures one of the Civil War's most dramatic moments—the last serious attempt at negotiated peace before the Confederacy's final collapse. With Sherman marching through the Carolinas and Grant tightening his grip on Richmond, both sides knew the war's outcome was increasingly inevitable. Lincoln's transparency in releasing the complete correspondence shows his political mastery: by proving he genuinely sought peace while maintaining firm principles, he deflected any criticism that his administration was prolonging unnecessary bloodshed. The failed conference actually strengthened Lincoln's position and weakened Confederate morale. Within two months, Richmond would fall, Lee would surrender at Appomattox, and Lincoln would be dead. This page documents the precise moment when America's last chance for a negotiated peace slipped away, making the war's violent conclusion inevitable.

Hidden Gems
  • The Tribune's subscription prices reveal the newspaper economy of 1865: daily delivery in Chicago cost 25 cents per week, while a full year by mail cost $12—equivalent to about $200 today
  • Gold closed at 210½ with 'a weak feeling'—meaning it took over $2 in greenbacks to buy $1 in gold, showing massive wartime inflation
  • A heartbreaking personal notice asks readers to verify reports of William E. Ross of the 9th New York Cavalry, captured at Cold Harbor and feared dead in Confederate prison—his brother H.R. Ross of Chicago hasn't heard from him since a brief letter from Libby Prison
  • The House of Representatives fined 'some twenty-five members' for being absent the previous night without leave—apparently congressional absenteeism required enforcement even during wartime
  • Major Harry Gilmore arrived at Fort Warren prison in Boston, delivered by the very Major Young who had captured this Confederate raider
Fun Facts
  • Francis P. Blair Sr., the unofficial peace negotiator mentioned throughout the front page, was 74 years old and had been Andrew Jackson's political advisor—he was literally bridging the Jackson era with Lincoln's presidency
  • Representative Thaddeus Stevens, quoted making cutting remarks about Brooks defending the rebels, would later lead Lincoln's impeachment proceedings against Andrew Johnson and become the most radical Republican in Congress
  • The 'Fisk metallic coffin patent' mentioned in congressional proceedings refers to Almond Fisk's airtight burial cases—the same company would later bury Lincoln himself in one of these coffins
  • Fort Warren, where Confederate Major Gilmore was imprisoned, held over 1,000 Confederate prisoners during the war and was known as the 'American Bastille'—yet it was considered one of the most humane Civil War prisons
  • The Tribune's confident prediction that 'Charleston and Wilmington will be among the names inscribed on the standards of our boys in blue' proved remarkably accurate—Charleston fell just 6 days after this paper was printed
Tragic Civil War Diplomacy War Conflict Politics Federal Military
February 9, 1865 February 12, 1865

Also on February 11

1836
Emperor of Morocco's Gift Horse Now Breeding in Virginia—Plus the Fire That...
Richmond enquirer (Richmond, Va.)
1846
War or Law? Congress Debates Whether America Can Break Its Treaty to Claim...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
1856: When Millstone Patents and Swampland Were Government Business—Plus, the...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1861
Feb. 11, 1861: A Farmer Forces His Daughter's Suitor to Win Her Through...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1862
Inside the Crescent City at War: Bounties, Deserters & the Last Days Before...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1863
Two Ships Lost, One Victory Claimed: How Chaos at Sea Exposed Cracks in the...
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1866
Mississippi Reels From Reconstruction: A Newspaper Pleads for Restraint (While...
The daily clarion (Meridian, Miss.)
1876
Congressman Blaine Explodes on Democrats' Currency Flip-Flop: How Maine's...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
Mark Twain Goes to War With Namby-Pamby Parenting (and Admits Publishing...
The Republican journal (Belfast, Me.)
1896
Wife Elopes with Boarder, Pension Slashed, Courthouse Opens: Maine's 1896...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1906
The $7.5M warship that made every navy obsolete + a deadly train robbery in New...
New-York tribune (New York [N.Y.])
1926
The Family That Chose Death Over Shame (and Edison's 79th Birthday Questions)
The Cordele dispatch and daily sentinel (Cordele, Georgia)
1927
How Coolidge's Navy Gamble Could Have Changed Everything (If It Hadn't Failed)
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free