Tuesday
September 20, 1864
The evening telegraph (Philadelphia [Pa.]) — Pennsylvania, Philadelphia
“VICTORY IN THE VALLEY: Sheridan Crushes Early at Winchester, 2,500 Rebels Captured”
Art Deco mural for September 20, 1864
Original newspaper scan from September 20, 1864
Original front page — The evening telegraph (Philadelphia [Pa.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Third Edition of this Philadelphia evening paper screams triumph: General Phil Sheridan has decisively defeated Confederate General Jubal Early in the Shenandoah Valley. The headline announces a crushing Union victory at Winchester, Virginia, with rebel generals Robert Rodes and John Gordon killed in action. The official war dispatches detail the scale of the rout—roughly 2,500 prisoners captured, five artillery pieces seized, nine Confederate flags taken, and an estimated 5,600 rebels left dead and wounded on the field. Though the Union suffered losses, including the death of General David A. Russell and wounds to generals Upton, Mcintosh, and Chapman, the victory is complete and decisive. Sheridan's forces drove Early's army through Winchester and down the Valley under cover of darkness. In Washington, the celebration is immediate: one hundred guns are fired near the War Department, flags fly everywhere, and an order will issue tomorrow for thousand-gun salutes across the nation. General Grant himself will fire a thousand shots in honor of the triumph.

Why It Matters

By September 1864, the Civil War had ground on for nearly four years with no clear Union victory in the Eastern Theater. Early's raid on Washington just weeks earlier had shaken Northern confidence, and voters were exhausted. This Sheridan triumph arrived at a critical moment—just weeks before the November 1864 election that would determine whether Lincoln and his war effort survived politically. The victory transformed the narrative from stalemate to momentum, reinvigorating Northern morale and essentially ensuring Lincoln's reelection. The Shenandoah Valley, source of Confederate supplies and a highway for rebel invasions north, would soon be systematically devastated by Sherman and Sheridan's scorched-earth tactics, hastening the war's end.

Hidden Gems
  • The page reports that Confederate agent Minor Noble had purchased 'two hundred thousand bushels of corn' in the Mississippi Valley—yet a Montgomery correspondent marvels that despite sending 'immense quantities' to Confederate armies, the supply seems inexhaustible, like the widow's endless store of oil and meal. This hints at the desperation of Confederate logistics even as supplies dwindled.
  • A brief notice mentions a Confederate shoe factory in Montgomery turning out '100 to 150 pairs of good sewed shoes' daily using a sewing machine that could produce twenty pairs per hour—revealing the South's improvisation and mechanization efforts even as Union armies closed in.
  • The cotton supply report from the London Times reveals that Egypt has abandoned cotton cultivation as unsuitable, Algeria produces just a million pounds annually (expected to quadruple), and Brazil produces no more than it did ten years ago. The report notes that India and Turkey are competing fiercely for the British market, with Indian cotton 'greatly in advance' but traveling through Russia overland. This shows how the American Civil War was reshaping global trade patterns in real time.
  • A brief news item reports that physicians examining draft exemption claims in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania charged twenty-five dollars per day—deemed 'exorbitant' and causing payment delays. This suggests both the prevalence of exemption claims and growing resentment over wartime profiteering.
  • The page includes a dispute over T. H. Foulds' lawsuit in Cincinnati against grain and hay contractors for $5,000 in personal damages after a bundle of gunny sacks fell from a window—revealing that even in wartime, commercial litigation proceeded and government contractors could be sued for negligence.
Fun Facts
  • General David A. Russell, killed at Winchester, was a Delaware native and career officer who had fought in Mexico and through the entire Civil War. His death marked another loss of seasoned Union commanders—yet the victory was so decisive that it boosted morale rather than dampening it, a sign the war was turning decisively in the Union's favor.
  • The page reports that rebel general Jubal Early's defeat came after he had, just weeks earlier, raided to the suburbs of Washington D.C. itself—close enough to make Lincoln and War Secretary Stanton anxious. Sheridan's decisive victory in Early's home region would end the Confederate threat to the North entirely.
  • Phil Sheridan, commanding the cavalry, was a relatively unknown figure when Grant brought him east in the spring of 1864. By September, he had become the dramatic face of Union cavalry success, replacing the cautious cavalry commanders of earlier years. Within months, he would be promoted to commanding general of all Union armies under Lincoln's successor.
  • The page mentions that New Albany, Indiana, was 'the first city in Indiana to fill its quota under the last call for troops,' with a surplus of one hundred men. This suggests that Northern communities were still able to raise volunteers or use conscription successfully—a capacity the Confederacy lacked by this point.
  • The market reports show stocks steady despite the war—Union, Pacific and Rock Island Railroad stock, commercial preferred, etc., all trading normally. The war was terrible, but Northern capital markets kept functioning, another advantage that would compound as the war continued into 1865.
Triumphant Civil War War Conflict Military Politics Federal Election
September 19, 1864 September 21, 1864

Also on September 20

1846
A Prophecy of Britain's Fall—From 1846: One Correspondent's Stunning Prediction...
Sunday dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1856
How America Bet Everything on Digging Rivers and Laying Rails—Just Before It...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
Escape and Snobbery: What Americans Read While Their Nation Burned (Sept. 1861)
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1862
Congress Just Abolished Flogging in the Navy—And Made Showing Up to Church...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1863
Is Richmond Evacuating? France Poised to Back the Rebels—War Turns Anxiously in...
New York dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1865
September 1865: When Confederate Militias Refused the Stars & Stripes
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1866
When Kansas Mocked a President: A Small-Town Paper's Savage Take on Andrew...
White Cloud Kansas chief (White Cloud, Kan.)
1876
How 16 Scandals Made Democrats Demand Reform: The 1876 Platform That Almost...
The Louisiana Democrat (Alexandria, La.)
1886
When a $20,000 Billiard Table Sparked Scandal: Inside Government Gossip from...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
75,000 pilgrims stormed Canton to see McKinley—and nearly tore his clothes off
The Indianapolis journal (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1906
1906: 'He simply lies, that's all' — A mountain politician's explosive...
Watauga Democrat (Boone, Watauga County, N.C.)
1926
Baby Dies as Church Riot Erupts: When 1926 America Got Violent
South Bend news-times (South Bend, Ind.)
1927
A Dying Sheriff's Last Request Made History—Texas Appoints Its First Female...
Brownsville herald (Brownsville, Tex.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free