“75,000 Copies & No Surrender: How Newspapers Fought the 1864 Election—Plus Scalps on the Rio Grande”
What's on the Front Page
The Chicago Tribune announces a massive printing operation: they've already sold 75,000 copies of their "Campaign Document," a compilation of inflammatory speeches from the Democratic National Convention featuring Copperhead leaders like Clement Vallandigham, Fernando Wood, and Samuel Cox. The paper is now accepting orders at "zero dollars per hundred" to flood the country with this anti-peace propaganda just weeks before the 1864 election.
Meanwhile, the war grinds on. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton has shut down all appeals for draft postponement—"not a day or an hour" of delay permitted. Illinois's draft quota has been cut 50%, offering some relief, but the Tribune warns Chicago must meet its obligations. On the battlefield, Grant's army near Petersburg endures constant rebel fire, while a stunning quadrilateral brawl erupted on the Rio Grande involving French, Mexican, Federal, and Confederate forces. The 8th Illinois cavalry captured Brownsville and raised the American flag after pursuing rebel Col. Ford. Gold prices fluctuate nervously at 221⅞, reflecting wartime economic anxiety.
Why It Matters
This edition captures American democracy under extraordinary strain. Four years into the Civil War, the 1864 election represents an existential referendum—will the North fight on to preserve the Union and end slavery, or negotiate a peace that could leave the Confederacy intact? The Tribune's frantic push to distribute 75,000 copies of Copperhead speeches reveals how ruthlessly both sides wielded print to shape opinion. Lincoln's re-election was far from certain; many Northerners wanted peace at any cost.
Stanton's iron refusal to delay the draft signals desperation—Grant and Sherman need bodies. The military victories mentioned here (Texas captures, cavalry successes) were crucial momentum-builders for Lincoln's campaign. Every battlefield success strengthened the Union cause; every stalemate empowered the peace movement. This newspaper embodied the propagandistic warfare of 1864 America.
Hidden Gems
- The Tribune advertises that subscribers can form clubs: "Clubs of four copies, one year, 9.00" up to "twenty copies, 40.00"—showing newspapers were distributed collectively, not individually, and organizational memberships were how publications built circulation.
- A classified notice reports that the 11th Indiana Veterans voted 323 for Lincoln, only 16 for McClellan, while the 8th Indiana voted unanimously for Lincoln—proving soldiers' ballots were being actively tabulated and published as propaganda for the Union cause.
- Ex-State Senator McVey of Ohio was killed in a stagecoach accident on Friday near Winchester, with his son's legs broken—a reminder that 1864 transportation was so dangerous that a prominent politician could die casually en route between Ohio cities.
- The paper dismisses C. H. McCormick (the reaper magnate nominee for Cook County) as having 'not an instinct that is not in sympathy with the rebellion,' accusing him of being a Virginia-born slavery sympathizer—revealing how the Civil War fractured even industrial magnate families along regional lines.
- A Treasury notice announces that vinegar manufacturers using distilled alcohol bases are now classified as 'distillers' subject to Internal Revenue taxes—showing how wartime tax collection reached into the smallest manufacturing operations to fund the war machine.
Fun Facts
- The Tribune mentions Professor Goldwyn Smith of Oxford University touring America as a Union advocate. Smith was one of the few major British intellectuals actively defending the North; his support mattered enormously because British intervention on behalf of the Confederacy nearly happened twice during the war, and influential voices like his helped prevent it.
- Secretary Chase is on the campaign trail declaring Lincoln's certain re-election—yet historically, Lincoln himself was so pessimistic in August 1864 that he believed he would lose. Chase's confidence, published here, helped shift the narrative just as Sherman's fall of Atlanta (happening around this exact date) turned the political tide.
- The paper reports C. H. McCormick as the Democratic nominee in Cook County. McCormick's reaper company would eventually become International Harvester, but in 1864 his Southern sympathies cost him dearly politically; he lost decisively, as the Tribune predicted.
- Gold closed Saturday at 221⅞—a staggeringly high price reflecting panic about war continuation. For context, gold was $20.67 per ounce at the war's start; this premium shows how deeply Americans doubted currency stability under endless warfare.
- The St. Louis dispatch mentions that guerrillas' scalps were found hanging from bridles—a chilling detail showing how the Western frontier of the Civil War had devolved into frontier savagery, with atrocities becoming casual news items.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free