“A Slave-Holding Texan Calls Slavery a 'Monstrous Crime'—Inside the North's Desperate Push to Hold Its Coalition Together (1863)”
What's on the Front Page
The Portland Daily Press devotes its entire editorial section to defending the Lincoln administration's war policies against Democratic critics, assembling an extraordinary collection of testimonials from prominent Democrats who support the Union cause. The paper leads with "Facts Worth Remembering," methodically documenting that the controversial arbitrary arrests and emancipation measures were often initiated by Democratic generals and judges—not Lincoln, who actually countermanded or softened many of these orders. The editorial then showcases voices of unlikely allies: Joseph A. Wright, ex-Governor of Indiana, declaring that the President has constitutional authority for these arrests just as Andrew Jackson did; James T. Brady, the 1860 Breckinridge candidate for New York governor, spitting upon any Northerner who won't support the government; and most remarkably, Andrew Jackson Hamilton of Texas, a former slave-holder and Democratic congressman, openly celebrating that slavery must be crushed to save the Union. The page closes with General John A. Logan's fierce warning that Confederate leaders should never regain political power, and a Catholic Telegraph editorial from Cincinnati calling slavery "a monstrous crime" deserving of burial and oblivion.
Why It Matters
By September 1863, the Civil War had become a grinding, bloody stalemate after the Union victories at Gettysburg and Vicksburg just months earlier. The North faced a crisis of political will—many War Democrats opposed emancipation and wanted negotiated peace, while radical Republicans pushed for total victory and slavery's destruction. This front page represents a crucial propaganda moment: the Lincoln administration (through sympathetic newspapers) marshaling Democratic voices to prove the party wasn't monolithic in opposition, that prominent Democrats could embrace emancipation and total war. The paper is essentially building a political coalition to sustain support for what would become the hardest two years of fighting—and ultimately, the passage of the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery nationwide.
Hidden Gems
- Mrs. Manchester, a mysterious healer operating from Room No. 5 in Clapp's Block, advertises cures for spinal disease, liver complaint, and dropsy with enthusiastic testimonials—including one man who claims she cured his 15-year dropsy when Boston and Philadelphia physicians said he'd die within months. No medical credentials are mentioned; she's entirely unregulated.
- The paper costs $6.00 per year in advance (about $130 in 2024 dollars), but single copies are three cents—meaning subscribers were paying roughly 2 cents per issue while walk-up customers paid significantly more per copy.
- General Logan reveals that Confederate deserters are 'flocking into Jackson by hundreds' to take oaths of allegiance or join Union ranks, suggesting the rebellion's popular support was collapsing even as military operations continued.
- A Democratic General (unnamed in the article) threatened to hang Vallandigham 'to the nearest tree' if he returned across Union lines—yet Lincoln later allowed him to leave, showing the President's clemency toward war critics.
- Thomas Lucas announces a 'Great Closing-out Sale' of spring and summer dry goods at No. 125 Middle Street with no ending date specified in the visible text—a classic bait-and-switch advertisement technique that remains familiar today.
Fun Facts
- General John A. Logan, quoted extensively here as a War Democrat supporting emancipation, would become one of the most powerful Republicans in Reconstruction and serve as Vice Presidential nominee in 1884—his political evolution mirrored the nation's shift on slavery.
- Andrew Jackson Hamilton, the Alabama-born Texan slaveholder quoted calling slavery a 'monstrous crime,' would become Military Governor of Texas during Reconstruction and fight for Black suffrage—a remarkable personal transformation documented in a single newspaper page.
- The Catholic Telegraph's Editor Edward Purcell, whose abolitionist editorial appears here, was the brother of Archbishop John Baptist Purcell, making this a rare moment when a major American Catholic voice publicly repudiated slavery just as Pope Pius IX remained ambiguous on the institution.
- Joseph A. Wright, ex-Governor of Indiana cited as supporting Lincoln's arrests, had served as Minister to Prussia under Buchanan—he would later become a Reconstruction politician, showing how Civil War debates realigned party loyalties across diplomatic service.
- This page's obsessive focus on Democratic voices supporting Lincoln suggests the administration was genuinely worried about losing War Democrat support, which proved justified—the 1864 election would be alarmingly close, decided partly by soldier votes from Sherman's army.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free