“Exclusive: What Ex-President Buchanan Really Said About the War (And Why It Matters Now)”
What's on the Front Page
The Portland Daily Press leads with a sprawling letter from correspondent 'P.' detailing travels through Pennsylvania during the Civil War. The writer visits Lancaster, Pennsylvania—once the state capital—and gains a surprising audience with ex-President James Buchanan at his Wheatland estate. Despite his controversial pre-war inaction, Buchanan declares himself a patriot, emphatically thanking Heaven for the fall of Fort Sumter under Union General Gilmore's guns and calling Charleston 'that nest of secession' deserving destruction. The correspondent also tours the Millersville Normal School, finding it temporarily closed due to Lee's invasion, with Professor Wickersham having summoned students and young men to form a full regiment. The letter emphasizes that teachers nationwide—in Pennsylvania, the West, and Maine—have answered the call to preserve 'our imperiled liberties.' On the editorial pages, the paper reprints Stephen Douglas's fiery 1848 speech defending Andrew Jackson's suspension of habeas corpus, arguing that necessity supersedes law when defending the country—a pointed argument in Lincoln's own contentious era.
Why It Matters
September 1863 marks a crucial turning point in the Civil War. Lee's invasion of Pennsylvania had just been repelled at Gettysburg three months earlier, and Gilmore's siege of Charleston was ongoing—the fall of Fort Sumter that Buchanan celebrates would occur just weeks after this publication. The paper's resurrection of Douglas's 1848 defense of martial law speaks directly to contemporary debates over Lincoln's suspension of habeas corpus and executive power during wartime. Teachers abandoning their posts to serve as soldiers reflects the devastating human toll the war was exacting. Buchanan's rehabilitation as a patriot, despite his widely-blamed inaction before secession, suggests Portland's Republican editors were reaching across political lines in unity against the rebellion.
Hidden Gems
- Ex-President Buchanan, living in rural Pennsylvania, received a complete stranger into his study after only a few minutes' notice—and spent a full half-hour in pleasant conversation. The casual intimacy of 19th-century access to famous figures stands in stark contrast to modern security protocols.
- The Portland Daily Press cost $1.00 per year in advance, with a 25-cent penalty added for every three months of delayed payment—a subscription model that made non-payment actually more expensive, a clever 1863 collection strategy.
- Professor Wickersham didn't just encourage students to enlist; he personally 'at once summoned around him his students and other young men' and 'with a full regiment entered the service of the State as their Colonel.' A college president becoming a military colonel was a direct casualty of war's demand.
- Anderson's Hoop Skirt Depot (located at 331 Congress Street, opposite Casco Street) was having a 'Closing Out Sale' with 'Immense Reduction in Price'—three years into a brutal war, fashion retail was still thriving in Portland.
- A yacht called the 'SIBYL' was being sold for an unspecified 'cheap' price and was 'now running as a packet between Isle of Shoals and Portsmouth, N.H.'—regular commercial maritime traffic continued between Maine and New Hampshire despite the war raging hundreds of miles south.
Fun Facts
- James Buchanan, the 15th President and widely blamed for inaction before the Civil War, lived another four years after this 1863 interview and died in 1868. His reputation never recovered—he remains ranked by historians among the weakest presidents, yet here the Portland editor presents him as a converted patriot, suggesting even Buchanan felt compelled to publicly support the Union cause by 1863.
- The paper republishes Stephen Douglas's 1848 speech defending martial law and suspension of habeas corpus—Douglas, Lincoln's great political rival, had died just two years earlier in June 1861. By 1863, the editor is ironically using Douglas's own expansive logic about wartime necessity to justify Lincoln's controversial emergency powers.
- The Portland Daily Press charges advertisers $1.25 per square daily for the first week, then 75 cents per week after—yet business kept coming. Coal dealers, dry goods merchants, and real estate agents were still investing in advertising aggressively even in wartime, suggesting economic activity in Maine remained robust despite the national crisis.
- Professor Wickersham's Normal School at Millersville was 'the oldest normal school of the State' of Pennsylvania, training 300-400 future public school teachers. That its closure and the departure of its principal to lead a regiment into battle represents the hollowing-out of civilian institutions for military need—an understated tragedy embedded in a travel letter.
- The correspondent notes that Lancaster's windows had white shutters 'which at night are shut and bolted with as much care as are the doors'—a reminder that even in the North, security consciousness had heightened during wartime, with real fears of Confederate guerrillas and saboteurs reaching into Pennsylvania towns.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free