Sunday
February 17, 1861
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“One Week Before Lincoln's Inauguration: Washington Prepares for War While Peace Talks Collapse”
Art Deco mural for February 17, 1861
Original newspaper scan from February 17, 1861
Original front page — The New York herald (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

This February 17, 1861 edition arrives at a knife's edge in American history—just days before Lincoln's inauguration and with seven states already seceded. The Herald leads with coverage of the Peace Convention in Washington, where delegates from border slave and free states desperately attempt to negotiate a settlement. But optimism is fading: the Republican caucus has just unanimously approved Bingham's Force Bill, authorizing revenue collection by federal ships outside insurrectionary ports. Meanwhile, the Southern Confederacy's Congress in Montgomery, Alabama is organizing itself with full executive departments and committees. The paper captures Washington as a city of intrigue—Lincoln won't stay at a hotel (remembering Buchanan's near-poisoning at the National Hotel), and Secretary Seward's influence grows as Lincoln's speeches disappointingly fail to address the crisis. The political machinery is grinding toward conflict.

Why It Matters

We're watching the final weeks before armed conflict. The Peace Convention represents the last serious attempt at constitutional compromise; by April, Fort Sumter will be fired upon. The Republicans' force bill signals they intend federal enforcement in Southern ports—a direct challenge to secession. Jefferson Davis and Alexander Stephens have just been elected president and vice president of the Confederate States, legitimizing the breakaway government. This paper captures the moment when negotiation still seems possible but coercion is already being planned. The tariff debates, the office-seeking, the naval reassignments—all are details of a nation literally coming apart at the seams.

Hidden Gems
  • The entire top half of the front page is dominated by a wildly repetitive advertisement for Bellingham's Stimulating Ointment for whiskers and hair growth—the word 'WHISKERS' appears dozens of times in different fonts. At the time, elaborate facial hair was a mark of masculine respectability, and this desperate advertising saturation suggests fierce competition in the patent medicine market. The product promised results in 'from three to six weeks' and cost $1 per box.
  • Lincoln's housing arrangements reveal security paranoia: he refuses hotels because Buchanan 'came so near being poisoned at the National Hotel in 1858.' The Herald notes this danger could occur 'at any time now by a sudden rise of the Potomac'—suggesting food/water tampering fears. Instead, he'll stay with Secretary Seward, who has taken General Cass's house.
  • The Peace Conference is debating whether slavery protections in territories apply only to 'present Territories' or 'future acquisitions also'—a technical distinction that masks the core irreconcilability: the North won't guarantee slavery's expansion forever; the South won't accept its containment.
  • Commodore Tatnall arrived in Washington 'in good health and apparently cheerful spirits,' while Commodore Armstrong attending a court of inquiry over surrendering the Pensacola Navy Yard is 'much depressed in spirits'—the naval officer corps is visibly fracturing over loyalty questions.
  • The Senate voted to retain the 'warehousing system' while throwing out the Chiriqui appropriation—arcane trade policy debates that consumed Congress while secession proceeded, showing how the institution was consumed by minutiae even as the nation collapsed.
Fun Facts
  • The Peace Convention delegates debating here—particularly Reverdy Johnson of Maryland—represent the last generation of politicians who believed constitutional amendment could solve the slavery question. Johnson's insistence on amending the Territorial clause to exclude 'hereafter to be acquired' lands reveals the core problem: even slavery's most moderate defenders refused to accept its ultimate extinction, making compromise structurally impossible.
  • Secretary of State Seward, mentioned prominently as Lincoln's host, will become one of the war's architects and Lincoln's closest confidant—yet the Herald reports Republicans fear he's 'overcard' and worry he and Lincoln 'must be at issue' over coercion policy. Within weeks, Seward will be orchestrating the very policies the Peace Conference desperately tried to prevent.
  • General Winfield Scott, mentioned ordering military reassignments, was 75 years old and the last commanding general to have served in the War of 1812. He would be sidelined within months as Lincoln turned to younger, more aggressive commanders—a symbolic generational transition from the old constitutional republic to modern total war.
  • The Confederate Congress's committee structure, listed in meticulous detail here, created a functioning government-in-exile that would last four years and fight the bloodiest war in American history. These 'committees' represented an alternative constitution being built in real-time.
  • The Herald's calm, almost business-as-usual tone covering secession and military preparations—sandwiched between whisker cream ads and naval transfers—captures how contemporaries didn't fully grasp they were witnessing the nation's dissolution. The war seemed unlikely right up until it wasn't.
Anxious Civil War Politics Federal Diplomacy War Conflict Military Legislation
February 16, 1861 February 18, 1861

Also on February 17

1836
A 750-Pound Cheese and the Slave Market: Inside Washington's Contradiction on...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Boots, Teeth, and Miracle Cures: Inside a Portsmouth Merchant's Struggle (1846)
The New Hampshire gazette (Portsmouth [N.H.])
1856
1856: When America Still Believed the Missouri Compromise Could Hold (Spoiler:...
New-York dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1862
"We Have Crossed the Rubicon": Union Troops March to Victory as Lincoln...
Cleveland morning leader (Cleveland [Ohio])
1863
Inside the Collapsing Confederacy: A Woman's Letter from Starving Virginia...
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1864
Inside Richmond's War Room: How the Confederacy Planned Its Last Great Gamble...
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1865
1865: The mother who spun, knit & mailed stockings to her soldier son in 12...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1866
1866: 'Pay Day Must Come'—A Prophet Warns Post-War America About Financial...
The Placer herald (Auburn, Placer County, Calif.)
1876
A Gentleman's Farewell: How Maryland Mourned Its Visionary Senator in 1876
Saint Mary's beacon (Leonard Town, Md.)
1886
Inside the Gilded Age: Arctic Explorers, Government Gossip & a $1.50 Glove Sale...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1906
1906: Russia fears war with China as Nome sells $1,400 rugs and serves 12¢...
The Nome tri-weekly nugget (Nome, Alaska)
1926
The prosecutor who nailed Scopes just got nailed himself (with a whiskey...
The Indianapolis times (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1927
California Drowning, Texas Guinan Jailed, & a Vengeful Millionaire's Plot: Feb....
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free