“From Wilderness to Wonder: How Ohio Became America's Fastest-Growing State—And Why a War Hero Was Selling Whisky to Soldiers”
What's on the Front Page
The New-York Tribune leads with coverage of Ohio Governor William Bebb's inaugural address, a sweeping meditation on the state's meteoric rise from wilderness to civilization in just half a century. Bebb celebrates Ohio's transformation—"from two to four millions" in population within twenty years, with taxable property climbing from $400 million to a projected $1 billion. He credits the Northwest Ordinance of 1787 for Ohio's prosperity, particularly its provision forever prohibiting slavery north of the Ohio River. Yet the inaugural also covers the darker underbelly of westward expansion: Indiana's new legislature convening with heavy Whig majorities (53 to 46), and a scathing letter from a soldier accusing Lt. Governor Paris C. Dunning of profiteering during the Mexican-American War—selling whisky to troops at inflated prices and charging exorbitant rates for provisions like potatoes (37 cents per dozen) while soldiers went hungry.
Why It Matters
December 1846 captures America at an inflection point. The Mexican-American War (then just months old) is reshaping the nation's territorial ambitions and moral conscience. Simultaneously, Ohio and the Northwest Territory represent the fastest-developing region in the world—a laboratory for democratic expansion and, unavoidably, the slavery question. Governor Bebb's tribute to the Northwest Ordinance's anti-slavery clause reflects the growing sectional tensions that would explode into civil war fifteen years later. The charges against Dunning also reveal how Mexico's war was enriching speculators even as common soldiers suffered—a pattern that would fuel growing anti-war sentiment.
Hidden Gems
- The Tribune's subscription rates reveal the economics of 19th-century journalism: city subscribers paid 12.5 cents per week (or could prepay $2.50 for six months), while mail subscribers paid $5 per year—roughly equivalent to a week's wages for a laborer, making newspapers a luxury good.
- Lt. Governor Dunning allegedly charged soldiers 10 cents per tablespoon of whisky and refused to negotiate on price, claiming 'he knew of no way to make money and that he intended to get as much as he could.' This brazenly mercenary attitude toward troops during wartime was fodder for Democratic critics.
- Governor Whitcomb's Indiana budget revealed state expenditures of just $69,131 for ordinary purposes in 1846—a state serving 126,959 adult male citizens on less than 55 cents per person annually.
- The paper notes Ohio's 'eight hundred miles of navigable canals' and stakes in 1,200 miles of plank roads, with railroads soon to connect Lake Erie to the Ohio River—infrastructure that would define the Industrial Revolution's heartland.
- The address celebrates that Ohio's population enjoys 'more of the necessaries and comforts of life, and enduring fewer of its privations, miseries and wants than any equal number of men in any age of the world'—a claim made possible only by excluding enslaved people from the calculus.
Fun Facts
- Governor Bebb's passionate defense of the Northwest Ordinance's anti-slavery clause was becoming increasingly controversial by 1846. Eight years later, the Kansas-Nebraska Act would allow territories to choose slavery by popular vote, effectively repealing the Ordinance's legacy and accelerating the nation toward civil war.
- Paris C. Dunning, the accused whisky profiteer, was Lt. Governor-elect of Indiana in 1846. The letter reveals he volunteered to serve in Mexico 'during the canvass' (the election campaign) but then 'skulked off' before finally departing 'not as a soldier but as a partner'—illustrating how wealthy men monetized the war while poor men died in it.
- The Tribune itself was Horace Greeley's flagship paper, founded just 5 years earlier in 1841. By this date it had become the nation's most influential Whig publication, with Greeley's moral crusades (against slavery, for labor rights, for westward expansion) shaping national discourse.
- Ohio's projected growth from 2 to 4 million people in two decades reflected real migration patterns: the Northwest Territory was America's fastest-growing region, and by 1850, Ohio would be the third most populous state, behind only New York and Pennsylvania.
- The subscription model advertised here—weekly delivery at 12.5 cents, or semi-weekly and weekly editions at $2 and $3 annually—would vanish within 50 years as mass-market penny papers and later wire services transformed journalism economics forever.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free