“Closing the City Hotel: Inside Washington's 1846 Auction Bonanza (+ a Miracle Cure for Kidney Stones)”
What's on the Front Page
The November 20, 1846 Daily National Intelligencer is dominated by auction notices—the City Hotel in Washington is liquidating its entire contents across 90 rooms, from mahogany dining tables and Brussels carpeting to a superior piano forte and an eight-day clock made by Willard of Boston. The sale, commencing November 25th, offers "one of the best opportunities that has been lately presented for furnishing and replenishing public or private houses." Alongside the grand hotel auction are smaller household sales scattered throughout the page: furniture auctions by Dyer and Green advertising mahogany sideboards, feather beds, and kitchen goods; a sale of Dutch bulbous roots from Haarlem; even a nearly-new hackney carriage being offloaded. The page reflects a bustling capital city where real estate and furnishings constantly change hands. But beneath the domestic commerce sits something more intriguing: Cowan's Vegetable Lithontriptic, a patent medicine claiming miraculous cures for gravel and kidney stone—backed by lengthy testimonials from Tennessee physicians and patients swearing to radical, permanent relief without the surgeon's knife.
Why It Matters
In 1846, America was mid-expansion and mid-conflict. The Mexican-American War had just begun (declared May 1846), and political tensions over slavery's westward spread were mounting toward the Compromise of 1850. Yet in Washington's newspapers, we see the granular reality: a thriving commercial city where hotels close, furnishings auction, and people bet their health on unregulated patent medicines. The proliferation of medical testimonials—endorsed by county clerks and congressmen like Milton Brown, M.C. of Tennessee—shows how credibility worked before the FDA. These ads reveal the desperation of the afflicted and the entrepreneurial opportunism that characterized 19th-century America, where a remedy with a few good letters could circulate nationwide.
Hidden Gems
- The City Hotel auction lists "A large and valuable lot of Wines and Liquors, which will be described in future advertisements"—suggesting the hotel's bar stock was so extensive it required separate cataloging, hinting at how central alcohol service was to high-end hospitality in 1846.
- Madame Delarue's fancy goods ad specifically advertises "Jet Ornaments for mourning" alongside French corsets and German cologne—mourning jewelry was a booming business in the 19th century, and the casual placement here reveals how normalized grief-wear shopping was.
- The Dutch bulbous roots auction from "J. D. Neeman, jr., Haarlem" shows Washington elites importing ornamental plants directly from Holland, indicating a sophisticated horticulultural market and transatlantic commerce in leisure goods.
- One testimonial states the patient discharged "at least one ounce" of sand and gravel-like substance after using Cowan's remedy—a viscerally specific claim meant to convince readers the medicine *worked*, yet entirely unverifiable by modern standards.
- The auction terms offer credit up to six months for "approved endorsed notes, bearing interest from day of sale"—revealing how 1846 merchants extended credit to buyers, essentially offering early installment plans for expensive furniture.
Fun Facts
- Milton Brown, M.C., the Tennessee congressman endorsing Cowan's Lithontriptic on this page, was a prominent Whig who would serve in Congress during the sectional crisis of the 1850s—yet here he's lending his name to promote a kidney stone cure, showing how politicians regularly monetized their reputations in patent medicine endorsements.
- The Willard eight-day clock being auctioned from the City Hotel was made by the Willard family of Boston, America's most celebrated clockmakers—their timepieces are now museum pieces worth tens of thousands, making this casual mention of a hotel auction item something that might have been historically priceless.
- Patent medicines like Cowan's Vegetable Lithontriptic dominated American newspapers until the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906—this 1846 ad, with its detailed testimonials and medical-sounding Latin name (Lithontriptic = "stone-breaking"), was entirely legal and common, yet most such remedies contained anything from opium to mercury.
- The City Hotel sale occurred just as Washington's hotel industry was booming due to influxes of congressmen, military officers, and war-related government expansion—hotels regularly liquidated and reopened under new management, making this 90-room auction a sign of rapid turnover in the capital's hospitality sector.
- Madame Delarue's import of Paris fashions (Winter Hats, French flowers, ribbands, corsets) to Georgetown shows how quickly European luxury goods reached American provincial cities—a testament to transatlantic packet ships and the emerging consumer culture that would define the antebellum period.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free