“1846: A Congressman's Furious Warning About Banks That Will Destroy America (He Was Right)”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Union's front page from May 28, 1846, is dominated by two major pieces of federal business. First, Congress has just passed **Public Law No. 18**, which establishes standardized values for foreign currencies at U.S. custom houses—a critical move for international trade. The Swedish specie dollar is set at 106 cents, the Prussian thaler at 69 cents, and the British pound at four dollars. This reflects America's growing role in global commerce and the chaos of operating without unified currency standards. Below that, Representative Harmanson of Louisiana delivers a fiery speech on the Independent Treasury Bill, passionately attacking the nation's paper money and banking system. He argues that the current credit system is destroying small merchants, enables bank speculators to monopolize business, and uses deceptive endorsement schemes to hide risky lending. Harmanson calls for a return to hard specie (real money) and accuses bankers of putting the labor and property of ordinary Americans 'up and down, as they please.'
Why It Matters
In 1846, America was caught between two competing visions of money: paper credit—fast, flexible, speculative—and hard specie—stable, limited, conservative. The Independent Treasury debate was the defining economic fight of the era. Just a year later, the Mexican-American War would begin, requiring enormous government borrowing. The banking system's instability would contribute to the Panic of 1857, proving Harmanson's dire warnings prescient. Meanwhile, the currency standardization law shows Washington grappling with the practical reality of a nation expanding westward and outward—you can't trade with the world if everyone quotes foreign coins at different values. This is the Jacksonian era's lasting legacy: a fundamental argument about whether banks should control money or government should.
Hidden Gems
- The subscription rates reveal how expensive newspapers were: $4 per year for daily delivery, or $1 for the tri-weekly country edition during Congress—at a time when a skilled laborer earned roughly $1-2 per day. This was a luxury good for the literate elite.
- Harmanson's steamboat analogy is oddly specific: he asks who would hire two competing steamboats between Washington and Richmond, then place freight control with one of them. This was a live debate in 1846—steamboat monopolies were actively reshaping American commerce along interior waterways.
- The law requires that 'a postmaster's certificate of remittances' serves as proof of payment for subscriptions—showing that small-town postmasters were operating as banking agents, a crucial but now-forgotten infrastructure for money movement.
- Harmanson claims 'there are more merchants ruined in the United States than in all the rest of the commercial world'—a stunning indictment he attributes entirely to the paper credit system, not to individual failure or bad luck.
- The endorsement system Harmanson attacks worked like this: if you borrowed $200,000, ten people would co-sign (endorse) your note, each technically liable for the full amount. He calls it 'a rotten chain'—and his warnings proved accurate; cross-endorsements would cascade during financial panics, ruining entire networks of merchants.
Fun Facts
- Harmanson speaks in 1846 about paper money destroying commerce, yet within a year the Mexican-American War would begin—and the U.S. government would finance it almost entirely through bank loans and paper currency, proving the 'bad men' he despised got exactly what they wanted.
- The currency law sets the British pound at exactly four dollars—a rate that would hold for nearly a century, until Britain abandoned the gold standard in 1931. This congressional act created one of history's most stable exchange rates.
- Harmanson's dream of a 'specie system' returned briefly during the Civil War (when the government issued greenbacks), but the U.S. wouldn't truly go all-in on paper currency until 1933, when FDR took the nation off the gold standard—90 years after this speech.
- The endorsement scheme Harmanson attacks was standard practice because credit reporting didn't exist. There was no way to verify someone's creditworthiness except by personal reputation and community vouching—the endorsement system was actually pre-modern finance's security system.
- By describing speculators who 'gradually press their paper credit, and stimulate every avenue of trade' to create artificial prosperity, Harmanson is essentially describing the asset bubble mechanism that would cause the 1857 Panic and would recur throughout the 19th and 20th centuries.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free