“War or Law? Congress Debates Whether America Can Break Its Treaty to Claim Oregon (1846)”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Union publishes a sprawling Congressional speech by Mr. Thompson of Mississippi on the explosive Oregon Territory question that threatens to plunge America into war with Great Britain. Thompson argues passionately that Congress must terminate the 1818 joint-occupation treaty—not to provoke conflict, but to enable settlement. The core tension: can the U.S. grant lands and establish laws in Oregon without violating treaty obligations? Thompson marshals legal ammunition from Secretary of State Buchanan, John Quincy Adams, and John C. Calhoun, all insisting that the treaty forbids unilateral American action. Yet thousands of settlers are already pouring into Oregon—carrying their families over the Rocky Mountains, establishing farms beyond the Mississippi's reach. Thompson warns that refusing to give notice to Britain will betray those pioneers, denying them the legal security and land ownership they deserve. The speech reveals America at a crossroads: does the nation honor diplomatic niceties, or stake its manifest destiny?
Why It Matters
This debate in February 1846 captures America at peak territorial hunger. Just months after the election of James K. Polk—who campaigned on 'Oregon and Texas!'—the nation faces a binary choice: diplomacy or dominion. The Oregon Territory stretched from present-day California to British Columbia, and both nations claimed it. Thompson's speech reveals the fault line between those who saw treaties as sacred (and war as unthinkable) and those who saw American expansion as inevitable and necessary. By December 1846, Congress would vote to terminate the treaty, but the boundary would be settled at 49 degrees—not the 54°40' that firebrands demanded. Still, this speech captures the raw hunger that would define the 1840s-50s: a young nation convinced of its divine right to expand, grappling with whether law or destiny should prevail.
Hidden Gems
- Thompson cites demographic transformation as justification for action: in 1818, only about 100,000 Americans lived west of the Mississippi River; by 1846, that number had exploded to roughly 9,800,000. A nearly 100-fold increase in less than three decades fueled the political pressure for Oregon.
- The speaker reveals that in 1818, steamboats were 'a curiosity, and almost unknown upon the western waters'—yet by 1846, steamboat technology had revolutionized western navigation and made the Oregon Territory suddenly accessible to ordinary settlers, not just fur traders.
- Thompson notes that in 1818, the only route to Oregon 'was supposed to be by doubling Cape Horn at sea...being situated more than 8,000 miles by land from the mouth of the Missouri'—but explorers had now discovered the South Pass through the Rocky Mountains, reducing the overland journey dramatically.
- The paper identifies editor Thomas Ritchie at the masthead, who was a powerful Democratic voice in Washington and would shape how this contentious debate reached ordinary readers across the nation.
- Subscription notices reveal the paper's distribution strategy: country papers would be published monthly during Congressional sessions and weekly when Congress recessed—showing how political calendars literally shaped newspaper publishing schedules.
Fun Facts
- Thompson invokes James K. Polk's election just two years prior on the slogan 'Oregon and Texas'—and notes they've already 'discharged our duty for Texas.' The Texas annexation had just triggered the Mexican-American War, which was already underway when this speech was delivered. Oregon would be the next domino.
- Thompson references Secretary of State James Buchanan's recent letter to British diplomat Pakenham as the definitive argument for American title. Buchanan would later become president in 1857, deeply weakened by his inability to prevent the Civil War—making his diplomatic triumph in Oregon one of his few celebrated achievements.
- The speaker cites John Quincy Adams' strict interpretation of the treaty—Adams had actually negotiated it as Secretary of State in 1818 and still defended it decades later. Adams was in Congress as a representative during this 1846 debate, aged 78, representing Massachusetts.
- Thompson dramatically invokes the 'hardy pioneers of the West, with their stout hearts and brawny arms' settling Oregon without government aid—a romanticization of what was actually often a brutal, disease-ridden journey killing thousands of settlers, especially women and children.
- The notion of 'exclusive sovereignty' Thompson demands would be achieved partially: the 1846 treaty set the boundary at 49 degrees, giving Britain present-day British Columbia and Canada, while the U.S. gained Washington, Oregon, and Idaho—a compromise that still shaped North American borders today.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free