Tuesday
February 10, 1846
The daily union (Washington [D.C.]) — District Of Columbia, Washington D.C.
“Should America Arm for War or Peace? A Florida Senator's Urgent 1846 Warning”
Art Deco mural for February 10, 1846
Original newspaper scan from February 10, 1846
Original front page — The daily union (Washington [D.C.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

Senator Westcott of Florida dominates the front page with an extended congressional speech defending a bill to augment the naval forces of the United States. Speaking before the Senate on February 10, 1846, Westcott argues passionately that America must strengthen its navy—particularly its armed war-steamers—to defend its Atlantic and Gulf coasts against potential British aggression. He emphasizes that the American coastline stretches nearly 5,000 miles from the Rio del Norte in Texas to the St. Croix in Maine, and is virtually defenseless against Great Britain's 'tremendous naval power.' Westcott insists this is fundamentally a peace measure, not a war preparation, and warns that failing to act would be 'suicidal sacrifice' of American commerce. He cleverly separates the naval bill from the heated Oregon territorial dispute, arguing that strengthened defenses will actually *encourage* peaceful negotiations with Britain by showing American resolve and unity.

Why It Matters

This debate crystallizes the anxieties of the pre-Civil War era: American territorial ambitions (Oregon was disputed with Britain; Texas and California were targets for Mexican expansion), naval vulnerability, and the question of how much military preparation signals peaceful intent versus warlike aggression. The U.S. Navy in 1846 was still a minor power compared to Britain's global dominance. Westcott's plea for coastal defense would echo through the next decade as America increasingly asserted itself in the Western Hemisphere, eventually leading to the Mexican-American War later that year and the expansionist policies that would reshape the nation.

Hidden Gems
  • The paper itself announces its publishing schedule: 'The UNION will be published tri-weekly during Congressional sessions, but weekly during the recess'—showing how lawmakers' schedules dictated newspaper production in Washington.
  • Subscription rates reveal a tiered system: annual subscriptions could be paid in advance, with postmasters' certificates accepted and endorsements required, suggesting subscription fraud was a real problem even then.
  • Westcott references the senator from Indiana, Mr. Hanneman, whose amendment supported armed steamers—these new war-steamers were cutting-edge military technology that would revolutionize naval warfare within decades.
  • The speech reveals congressional concern about interior American states: Westcott warns that if Gulf commerce were destroyed, 'every city, town, hamlet, and neighborhood in the great valley would denounce the fatuity'—showing how Mississippi Valley states depended on Gulf trade routes.
  • Advertising rates listed: twelve lines for $1.50 for three insertions, with a thirty-cent charge per additional insertion—print advertising was becoming a quantified, standardized business.
Fun Facts
  • Westcott mentions armed war-steamers as cutting-edge naval weaponry—by 1861, the CSS Virginia (formerly USS Merrimack) would become the world's first ironclad warship and change naval combat forever. The steamers Westcott was fighting for in 1846 would be obsolete within 15 years.
  • The senator's fear of British naval dominance was justified: in 1846, Britain had roughly 5 times the naval tonnage of the United States. Yet within 50 years, American industrial capacity would eventually eclipse Britain's; this bill was essentially the first step toward American naval supremacy.
  • Westcott carefully separates this naval bill from the Oregon controversy—but historians would later note that the very military preparations he advocated helped embolden American negotiators, who ultimately settled Oregon at the 49th parallel in June 1846 (just four months after this speech).
  • The paper itself identifies as 'LIBERTY, THE UNION, and THE CONSTITUTION'—published in Washington D.C., this masthead reflects the political fault lines of 1846, when debates about union, liberty, and constitutional interpretation were growing more heated.
  • Westcott advocates for defenses stretching from Texas to Maine—remarkably, he's describing the future American continental empire, though he doesn't yet know the Mexican-American War begins in just weeks, and that the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo (1848) will add exactly those southwestern territories he mentions as needing defense.
Anxious Politics Federal Military Diplomacy Politics International
February 9, 1846 February 11, 1846

Also on February 10

View all 11 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free