What's on the Front Page
The New Britain Herald's front page on December 7, 1927, is dominated by three sensational trials capturing the public imagination. The lead story covers the closing arguments in the Margaret Lilliendahl murder case in Mays Landing, New Jersey—a woman and her alleged lover, Willis Beach, stand accused of murdering her husband, Dr. A. William Lilliendahl. Prosecutor Hinkle demanded death or life imprisonment, branding the defendants' alibi about Negro assailants "false," while the defense countered there was no motive: "No money is involved and love is a far fetched notion." Equally lurid is the George Remus case from Cincinnati, where testimony revealed Remus's wife Imogene hired a man named Truesdale to murder her husband for $10,000 (with another $5,000 promised by a former Department of Justice agent). The dramatic courtroom collapse of Remus himself—and his daughter breaking into hysterics—left the jury weeping. A third tragedy involves an unidentified man plunging from the Woolworth Building, the world's tallest office structure. Meanwhile, President Coolidge submitted his $4.25 billion budget to Congress, with Treasury Secretary Mellon urging a modest $225 million tax cut while emphasizing fiscal restraint.
Why It Matters
December 1927 captures America at a critical crossroads. The nation was riding the economic euphoria of the late 1920s—the Jazz Age in full swing—yet beneath the surface lurked anxieties about law, order, and morality. Prohibition, now eight years in, had spawned organized crime and sensational trials involving bootleggers like Remus (described as the "king of bootleggers"). High-profile murder cases consumed public attention as tabloid journalism reached its peak. Politically, conservative Republicans like Coolidge were fighting to maintain fiscal discipline and a balanced budget, resisting calls for aggressive tax cuts despite the nation's apparent prosperity. The Senate's denial of the oath to Illinois Senator Frank L. Smith over campaign finance violations also signals emerging concerns about political corruption—a precursor to deeper troubles ahead.
Hidden Gems
- The Lilliendahl case involved their 9-year-old son, Alfred, who came to court 'with a box of crayons as big as an artist's drawing board'—a haunting detail suggesting a child present for his mother's murder trial.
- Truesdale testified he sat outside Remus's hotel room (No. 827 in the Sinton Hotel) planning the murder but couldn't act because 'there always was too many people about'—a chilling glimpse into an actual assassination plot that nearly succeeded.
- The Woolworth Building suicide note: an unidentified man 'fell or jumped' from the world's tallest office building, 'landed among the hurrying crowds' on Broadway and Park Place, yet 'no one was struck by the body'—a near-miss tragedy amid Manhattan rush hour.
- An advertisement's absence is telling: despite Prohibition being law, no beer or liquor ads appear, yet the Meriden couple's death from 'chronic alcoholism' underscores the drinking that persisted throughout the 1920s despite the ban.
- The couple from Meriden 'came here from New York last April' and 'had not worked since the day before Thanksgiving'—a reminder that even during the 'prosperous' 1920s, unemployment and transience were common realities.
Fun Facts
- George Remus, the 'king of bootleggers' on trial, had actually been to federal prison thanks to a Department of Justice agent named Franklin L. Dodge—the same man Remus alleged was now having an affair with his wife and helping plot his murder. This baroque revenge drama was playing out in real courtrooms as Prohibition created America's first major organized crime syndicates.
- The Woolworth Building, from which a man plunged to his death that same day, had only been completed five years earlier (1913), and at 792 feet was briefly the world's tallest building before the Chrysler Building surpassed it. Suicides from skyscrapers became a grim symbol of the Depression era just two years away.
- President Coolidge's emphasis on a 'balanced budget' and warnings against 'jeopardizing' fiscal restraint ring almost prophetic—he was determined to keep federal spending in check even as the stock market soared. Within two years, the Great Depression would expose the fragility of the prosperity he was guarding so carefully.
- The Lithuania-Poland dispute detailed inside involved a 'state of war' existing between the two nations—a hangover from the chaos of World War I and the redrawing of European maps. This obscure League of Nations controversy was part of the continental instability that would eventually feed World War II.
- Senator Borah, mentioned as defending Smith's right to a hearing, was a famous isolationist who would later oppose U.S. entry into World War II. In 1927, he was still fighting for due process and against hasty exclusions—positions that would define his career.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free