“Mellon's Tax Fight & a $50K Inferno: Nov. 1, 1927”
What's on the Front Page
Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon's tax reduction plan is under fire from both sides of Congress on November 1st, 1927. Mellon proposed cutting taxes by $225 million, but Democratic Senator Furnifold Simmons of North Carolina and Texas Representative John Nance Garner are demanding a much bigger slash—up to $400 million. They argue Mellon's treasury surplus estimates are too conservative and that corporations deserve steeper tax cuts than the 12 percent reduction he's proposing. Meanwhile, a massive fire rages through South Sudbury, Massachusetts, destroying the C.O. Parmenter grain mill and lumber yards in a $50,000 inferno that threatens the entire residential section. Firefighters from six towns battle the blaze through the night while state police rope off streets choked with spectators. On a lighter note, German aviatrix Thea Rasche has publicly offered to co-pilot Frances Wilson Grayson's amphibian "The Dawn" on a transatlantic flight to Copenhagen, though Grayson seems cool to the idea and has also invited famous transatlantic pilot Clarence Chamberlin to take the controls.
Why It Matters
This snapshot captures the heated tax debates of the Coolidge era, when the government was collecting massive surpluses and politicians fought bitterly over what to do with them. The 1920s were defined by this tension: Should corporations or wealthy individuals get tax breaks? How much surplus was actually sustainable? These arguments would echo through the decade and collide catastrophically with the 1929 crash. The Mellon Plan itself represents the pro-business, anti-government taxing philosophy that dominated Republican administrations—a philosophy many blamed for the income inequality that contributed to the Great Depression. Meanwhile, the everyday disasters and human-interest stories remind us that behind the Jazz Age glamour, Americans still faced fires, family feuds, and labor disputes.
Hidden Gems
- The operators of the South Sudbury telephone exchange—Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence Pighe—'stuck to their posts and answered hundreds of calls' while their building was threatened by flames. This detail captures the pre-cell phone era when telephone operators were essential infrastructure, often working in dangerous conditions.
- Mary G. O'Brien, age 44, was ordered by a Boston court to leave her elderly parents' home after 'whistling, singing and brawling' and making 'insulting, false, derogatory and abusive statements.' The judge gave her two weeks to pack—a strangely specific legal remedy for family discord.
- Railroad trainmen and conductors west of the Mississippi River filed for a $1-per-day raise, which amounted to about 19 percent more pay. A year earlier, the same request went to arbitration and was rejected entirely, except for yardmen who got 7.5 percent.
- Henry Ford had 'an option on the property' where the grain mill burned in South Sudbury—he was apparently considering buying it at some point. Ford's reach into real estate opportunities was remarkably broad.
- Spider Kelly, the lightweight boxing contender who died at 55, came to Rochester, Minnesota 'seeking to regain his health' just ten days before his death from a blood clot following mastoid surgery. The description captures the desperation of 1920s medical tourism.
Fun Facts
- Secretary Mellon's tax debate appears on this page just four years before the stock market crash of 1929—the very surplus he was debating would vanish, and the tax policy favoring corporations would become a lightning rod for Depression-era critics who blamed the wealthy for hoarding gains.
- Clarence Chamberlin, mentioned here as a potential pilot for 'The Dawn,' was part of aviation's golden age—he had made a famous transatlantic flight in 1927 and was competing in the era's great air races that captured public imagination before the industry became routine.
- The New Britain Herald notes its circulation as approximately 4,000 for the week ending October 29th—this was a typical mid-sized Connecticut newspaper with deep local roots (established 1870), yet it ran Associated Press wires from around the world on its front page, making it a crucial node in the national information network.
- The German aviatrix Thea Rasche offering to fly transatlantic reflects the brief window when women aviators were celebrities and the Atlantic crossing was still death-defying; within a decade, commercial transatlantic service would make the stunt obsolete, and WWII would end this romantic era of pioneering female flyers.
- The railroad workers asking for a $1-per-day raise in 1927 were positioned before the coming Depression would reverse all wage gains—by 1933, railroad work was among the hardest-hit industries, and workers would have given anything to keep 1927's rates.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free