“When the AFL's Own VP Was Secretly Running a Capitalist Conspiracy—1927's Labor War Gets Exposed”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Worker's April 18, 1927 edition leads with fierce attacks on two fronts: Matthew Woll, vice president of the American Federation of Labor, for allegedly conspiring with big capitalists to crush militant unions, and Halsy Fiske, president of Metropolitan Life Insurance, for presiding over what the paper claims is a massive fraud scheme. The centerpiece exposes the "Big Four" insurance companies (Metropolitan, Prudential, John Hancock, Colonial Life)—which the Worker claims pocket $50 million annually from forfeited policies while maintaining assets of nearly $4 billion when they should hold only $2 billion. Meanwhile, Ben Gold and eleven other furriers union leaders face trial in Mineola on what the paper insists are fabricated charges, with Woll allegedly orchestrating the frame-up. In international news, T.J. O'Flaherty condemns Chiang Kai-Shek's betrayal of China's revolution, comparing him to Judas for accepting "thirty pieces of imperial silver." The paper also reports Illinois coal miners fleeing the mines in anticipation of a three-month shutdown, with one 60-year-old miner lamenting the loss of militant labor tactics.
Why It Matters
This moment captures the post-1924 fracture in American labor, where the AFL's conservative leadership clashed with Communist-sympathizing militants over union tactics and ideology. Woll represented the AFL establishment's anti-radical purge—he was simultaneously vice president of the federation and acting president of the Civic Federation, which allied with business leaders to stamp out leftist organizing. This dual role exemplified the corruption the Worker denounced: official labor leaders collaborating with capitalists against their own members. Meanwhile, the insurance exposé reflected broader 1920s skepticism toward giant corporations' opaque financial practices, even as the decade roared with speculation and wealth concentration. The China reporting revealed American progressives' divided sympathies—some supported nationalist revolution, others its Communist wing—a debate that would define the next two decades of U.S. foreign policy.
Hidden Gems
- The Civic Federation's executive committee reads like a who's-who of Gilded Age power: John Hays Hammond (financier), T. Coleman du Pont (U.S. Senator), Theodore Roosevelt Jr., and Nicholas Murray Butler (Columbia's president). That Woll sat on this board as "Acting President" while leading the AFL's anti-communist crusade made him, by the Worker's logic, literally the bridge between capital and organized labor.
- Matthew Woll's base of power came from his own union of photo-engravers—a small, highly-skilled craft union. The Worker notes these were organized "on the basis of complete cooperation with the bosses," revealing how 1920s labor was stratified between elite craftsmen who could negotiate and masses of unskilled workers with no leverage.
- The Metropolitan Life Insurance Company held assets of nearly $4 billion in 1927—during an era when the entire U.S. federal budget was roughly $3 billion annually. One insurance company's reserves exceeded the government's annual spending, and the Worker alleged most of it came from fraudulently withheld policyholder funds.
- Illinois coal miners were anticipating a three-month shutdown in April 1927, forcing families like the Montgomery County father-and-son pair mentioned to migrate to Chicago seeking any available work. This foreshadowed the catastrophic mining collapse that would worsen during the Great Depression.
- The closed-shop agreement signed by Chicago builders' unions on April 15, 1927 went into effect just days before this edition, representing a hard-won union victory—yet the Worker notes it simultaneously undermined the "Landis Award," showing how labor victories could have contradictory effects on union power.
Fun Facts
- Matthew Woll's name appears on this page as both a labor leader *and* an enemy of labor—simultaneously serving as AFL vice president and acting president of a capitalist-dominated federation that included railroad executives, bankers, and the heads of utility companies. This wasn't unusual for the 1920s, but it perfectly encapsulated the AFL's corruption that would lead to massive membership losses during the Depression.
- Halsy Fiske, the Metropolitan Life president attacked here, helmed the largest insurance company in America, which would remain so for another 70+ years. Metropolitan wouldn't face serious regulatory scrutiny until the 1960s—decades after this exposé—suggesting the Worker's charges either went unheeded or were dismissed as Communist propaganda.
- The paper's exposure of $50 million in annual profits from lapsed insurance policies prefigured modern insurance industry practice: the Worker identified what we'd now call 'forfeiture profit' as a core business model. Policyholders were essentially funding insurance company reserves through penalties for missed payments.
- Ben Gold, the furriers' leader on trial, would go on to lead the International Fur & Leather Workers Union for the next two decades, making him one of the most durable Communist-sympathetic labor leaders in America—meaning either the frame-up charges were dismissed or Gold's union was too powerful to crush despite Woll's efforts.
- The Worker mentions one Illinois miner saying 'We didn't fight the bosses in this do-nothing way in the old days'—a direct reference to the violent mine wars of the pre-1920s era. This was written just three years before the Harlan County coal wars (1931-1933), where those 'old days' tactics would return with brutal force.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free