Sunday
October 21, 1906
The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“The $60,000 Family Betrayal That Shocked 1906 New York”
Art Deco mural for October 21, 1906
Original newspaper scan from October 21, 1906
Original front page — The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

New York was rocked by a spectacular forgery scandal as Arthur C. Babbitt, a self-described "consulting engineer," was arrested at the Hotel Navarre for stealing nearly $60,000 through forged checks bearing the signature of his wife's uncle, retired Army Captain William H. Wheeler. The elaborate scheme unraveled only when Babbitt got greedy—his final $5,000 check bounced because Wheeler's account held just $1,200. Police say Babbitt had been living lavishly for months, taking automobile trips to Philadelphia and blowing money on Wall Street speculation and horse racing. The twisted family drama deepened when investigators revealed this wasn't Babbitt's first offense—Wheeler had previously forgiven him for a $700 forgery, but this time the young man had gone too far, systematically draining his benefactor's bank account while Wheeler toured Europe. Meanwhile, tragedy struck Syracuse when bleachers collapsed during the Colgate-Syracuse football game, mortally wounding Father Christopher J. Donigan and injuring twenty others when 300 spectators plummeted to the ground.

Why It Matters

These stories capture America in 1906 at a pivotal moment—a nation rapidly modernizing but still small enough that bank fraud relied on personal relationships and forged signatures rather than sophisticated schemes. The Babbitt case reflects the era's growing financial complexity, with multiple banks, clearing houses, and the new mobility that allowed criminals to operate across state lines by automobile. The football tragedy underscores how America's obsession with college sports was already drawing massive crowds to hastily-built facilities, foreshadowing decades of similar disasters that would eventually force safety regulations.

Hidden Gems
  • Babbitt had exactly $187 in his pocket when arrested and claimed a $45 balance remained in the Mutual Bank—after stealing $60,000
  • The newspaper cost just five cents but ran forty-four pages, making it an incredible value for readers
  • President Roosevelt personally ordered the release of bank embezzler James Ekes, who had served five years for stealing $4,807—showing presidential mercy was dispensed for relatively small crimes
  • A runaway horse galloped straight down a pier and plunged into the East River, drowning both horse and driver George Heubner while his friend rolled out of the buggy just in time
  • Italian conspirators threatened to blow up the steamship Napolitan Prince to free deportees, but Captain Egerton laughed off the threat, reasoning the explosion would kill the conspirators too
Fun Facts
  • Captain Wheeler belonged to both the Union and Manhattan clubs—exclusive New York institutions that still exist today, with the Union Club being America's oldest city club, founded in 1836
  • The Pinkerton Detective Agency, which tracked Babbitt to Philadelphia, was founded by Allan Pinkerton and became so powerful it was larger than the U.S. Army at one point, leading to laws restricting private police forces
  • The newspaper mentions the 'Corbett-McGovern fight' in Philadelphia—this refers to Young Corbett II vs. Terry McGovern, part of boxing's golden age when prizefights drew wealthy spectators on automobile excursions
  • The Second National Bank and Mutual Bank featured in the fraud were part of New York's banking boom—by 1906, the city had become America's undisputed financial capital, surpassing London in some measures
  • Father Donigan's death at the football game reflects the sport's brutal early era—in 1905 alone, 18 players died and 159 were seriously injured, prompting President Roosevelt to demand rule changes
October 20, 1906 October 22, 1906

Also on October 21

View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free