Sunday
October 7, 1906
The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“When Hearst Battled Tammany Hall (And Mattresses Were Stuffed With Gold)”
Art Deco mural for October 7, 1906
Original newspaper scan from October 7, 1906
Original front page — The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

New York politics exploded into chaos as newspaper magnate William Randolph Hearst and Tammany Hall boss Charles F. Murphy engaged in a bitter power struggle over judicial nominations. The front page screamed "JUDICIARY DEAL IS ON AGAIN" as the two political titans attempted to broker a compromise after days of public feuding. Murphy was reportedly willing to give Hearst five of the thirteen judgeships in exchange for peace, while Hearst threatened to run his own independent slate of candidates if his demands weren't met. Meanwhile, Charles Evans Hughes brought his gubernatorial campaign to Brooklyn with unprecedented fervor, delivering what the paper called his most personal attack yet on Hearst at Prospect Hall. Before a crowd of thousands waving small flags and cheering themselves hoarse, Hughes "went after him in a personal way harder than he has on any other occasion." The political drama was heightened by a corruption scandal in Texas, where Senator Joseph W. Bailey faced accusations of selling his influence to the Waters-Pierce Oil Company, with critics claiming Hearst was orchestrating attacks on Bailey to advance his socialist agenda.

Why It Matters

This October 1906 front page captures American democracy at a crossroads. The Progressive Era was reshaping politics as reformers like Hughes challenged the old boss system, while media barons like Hearst were pioneering new forms of political influence through newspaper empires. The judicial nomination fight represented a classic struggle between traditional machine politics and emerging populist movements. The Hearst-Murphy battle embodied the tensions of an era when industrialization and immigration were transforming American cities, creating new political coalitions while old-guard organizations fought to maintain control. These weren't just local New York squabbles—they were rehearsals for the national political realignments that would define the 20th century.

Hidden Gems
  • Voter registration in 1906 required appearing in person on just four specific days, with polling places open from 7 AM to 10 PM—quite different from today's extended registration periods
  • Two Philadelphia women, Jane McDermott and her daughter Eliza, were found starving to death in their home despite owning property assessed at $35,000 (worth about $1.2 million today)—police discovered their mattresses were stuffed with money and gold
  • The paper cost five cents but contained a whopping 46 pages, making it quite the bargain for readers hungry for news
  • A special train fare to New Orleans was being advertised for October 10th-11th via Southern Railway, suggesting some major event drawing travelers south
  • Republican Party workers planned to station themselves at elevated and subway stations to hand out voter registration reminder cards to commuters returning from work
Fun Facts
  • William Randolph Hearst's media empire was so powerful that Texas Senator Bailey accused him of orchestrating a national campaign to destroy Democratic politicians who opposed his 'socialist programme'—foreshadowing modern concerns about media influence on politics
  • The judicial nomination fight involved 13 positions worth $17,500 annually each—equivalent to about $600,000 per year in today's money, explaining why the political stakes were so high
  • Charles Evans Hughes would go on to become Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, making his 1906 attacks on judicial politicization particularly ironic given his later role atop the very court system he was trying to reform
  • Tammany Hall's influence was so extensive that boss Charles Murphy could realistically promise to deliver judicial nominations—the organization controlled not just elections but the entire machinery of New York government
  • The Independence League mentioned in the political coverage was Hearst's own political party, which he founded in 1906 after breaking with the Democrats—it would eventually merge back into the Democratic Party by 1910
October 6, 1906 October 8, 1906

Also on October 7

View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free