Monday
June 11, 1906
The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“When a Flying Barrel Terrorized Coney Island: The Deadly 1906 Squall That Claimed 3 Lives”
Art Deco mural for June 11, 1906
Original newspaper scan from June 11, 1906
Original front page — The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

A deadly squall struck New York Harbor on June 10, 1906, claiming three lives when the fishing yacht Lottie capsized off West Bank Light. Captain Theodore Bonnet had left West Twenty-ninth Street with eleven men aboard for a fishing expedition, but around 5 P.M., the sudden storm overturned their vessel. William Mormon of Brooklyn, Paul Smith, and George Glso all drowned, with Mormon's body lost to the depths. The survivors clung desperately to the yacht's hull until rescued by the tugboat Sommers and the excursion steamer Little Silver, whose quick-thinking crews pulled eight men from the churning waters. The storm wreaked havoc across the region's waterways and amusement areas. At Coney Island, an estimated 225,000 visitors scrambled for cover as the squall hit, with one unlucky man getting struck by a flying barrel that "rode the gale" through the sky. The Staten Island ferryboat Richmond rescued a family of five from a sinking launch, while four people sheltering under a tree in Jamaica, Queens, were struck by lightning. Bishop Henry Potter, just returned from a European tour, found himself discussing everything from the recent beef scandal to America's diplomatic shortcomings as the city recovered from nature's violent display.

Why It Matters

This dramatic storm captured New York at the height of its Gilded Age transformation into a modern metropolis. The city's waterways teemed with recreational boaters, excursion steamers, and weekend pleasure-seekers — a sign of growing prosperity and leisure time for the middle class. Coney Island's massive crowds of 225,000 on a single day reflected the emergence of mass entertainment and the democratization of fun. Meanwhile, Bishop Potter's comments about America's diplomatic inadequacies and the ongoing beef scandal highlighted the growing pains of an emerging world power. His observation that American consulships were "rewards for political service" rather than merit-based appointments would prove prophetic as the U.S. struggled to manage its new international responsibilities following the Spanish-American War.

Hidden Gems
  • Grace Van Buskirk, a 'crack ticket seller' at Luna Park, sold an astounding 17,000 tickets in a single day, collecting $1,700 in receipts — roughly $60,000 in today's money
  • A mysterious barrel 'rode the gale' through the sky at Coney Island, ultimately striking Joseph Stulowitz of Livingston Street and splitting his brown derby hat 'fore and aft from rim to rim'
  • The tugboat Sommers was towing a disabled launch called the Hildegarde when it rescued the yacht survivors, turning a simple towing job into a dramatic sea rescue
  • Charles S. Corey of 1 Madison Avenue was so impressed by the ferry rescue that he pulled a diamond scarf pin from his tie and presented it to crew member Keogan on the spot
  • Charles L. Tucker, convicted murderer of Mabel Page, had his Monday morning execution mysteriously postponed in Boston, with prison warden giving no explanation for breaking usual custom
Fun Facts
  • Bishop Potter discovered that George Washington's actual coat of arms had been recovered and was being mounted in Gurxton Church — debunking the myth that it had been stolen from the Manor house at Belgrave
  • The massive Coney Island crowds of 225,000 in a single day were possible thanks to new subway lines and trolley systems that had just connected the resort to Manhattan, democratizing leisure for the working class
  • Potter's criticism of American diplomatic appointments being 'rewards for political service' would prove prescient — it would take until 1924 for the Rogers Act to create a professional diplomatic corps based on merit
  • The squall that killed three men was part of a broader pattern of extreme weather in 1906, the same year that would see the devastating San Francisco earthquake just two months earlier
  • Luna Park's record-breaking day occurred during the height of the 'City Beautiful' movement, when urban planners were reimagining cities as places of both work and elaborate recreation
June 10, 1906 June 12, 1906

Also on June 11

1836
A 1836 Governor's Brutal Takedown of Congress: 'Talkers, Not Doers' — And He...
New-Hampshire statesman and state journal (Concord [N.H.])
1846
EXCLUSIVE: General Gaines's Secret War Orders from June 1846—America Mobilizes...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
When America Fought Over the Admiral Rank: A Navy Divided Before the Civil War
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
Six Weeks into the War: How One Southern City Drilled for Battle While Selling...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
Richmond in Peril: McClellan's Army Battles Lee—and Barely Holds the Line (June...
Clearfield Republican (Clearfield, Pa.)
1863
Lincoln's Legal Shield: How a Prussian Scholar Protected Black Soldiers (and...
Weekly national intelligencer (Washington [D.C.])
1864
Richmond Under Siege: Can Grant Finish What He Started? (June 11, 1864)
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
1865
Is Jefferson Davis Faking Insanity? Chicago Reports on the Confederate...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1866
Canada Hangs Fenians on U.S. Soil: The Invasion That Changed Everything
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1876
High Society & Gunfights: The Day Polo Came to New York (and Nobody Knew the...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1886
Patent Medicine Miracles vs. Real Medicine: How 1886 Maine Believed in the...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1896
A Famous Preacher's Terrifying Sermon About the 'Parasites' in Your Whiskey...
The Sioux County journal (Harrison, Nebraska)
1926
When small-town papers ran steamy romance novels on the front page (1926)
Montgomery County sentinel (Rockville, Md.)
1927
Workers Made Billions in 1926—But Here's Who Actually Got the Money
Amerikanski srbobran (Pittsburg, Pa.;Pittsburgh, Pa.)
View all 14 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free