Saturday
January 20, 1906
Goodwin's weekly : a thinking paper for thinking people (Salt Lake City, Utah) — Salt Lake City, Ogden Canyon
“1906: 'Has It No Shame?' — A Utah Editor's War on Mormon Power”
Art Deco mural for January 20, 1906
Original newspaper scan from January 20, 1906
Original front page — Goodwin's weekly : a thinking paper for thinking people (Salt Lake City, Utah) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The front page of Goodwin's Weekly delivers a blistering attack on the Mormon Church and Senator Reed Smoot under the provocative headline "HAS IT NO SHAME." Editor C.C. Goodwin accuses the church's official newspaper, the News, of publishing "appalling falsehoods" about obedience and doctrine to protect Apostle Smoot's precarious position in Washington. Goodwin rails against church president Joseph F. Smith, calling him "an intolerant, avaricious and absolutely cold-blooded money-getter" who claims divine authority while admitting he's never received a revelation. The piece condemns what Goodwin sees as "a hostile kingdom" operating within the American republic, with Mormon leaders breaking "solemn covenants with the Gentiles of Utah" while demanding representation in the U.S. Senate. Balancing this political fire is a surprisingly lyrical meditation on "Winter Splendors" that reads like nature poetry. Goodwin argues that winter's harsh beauty created civilization itself—that cold and hunger originally tamed wild animals and forced humans to develop compassion, charity, and greatness. He describes winter as nature's sublime plan for storing moisture as snow, creating phenomena "more beautiful" and "more sublime than anything seen in summer land," including the Aurora Borealis with its "perpetual glory."

Why It Matters

This 1906 edition captures the height of the Reed Smoot hearings, a three-year Senate investigation that would reshape American church-state relations. Smoot, a Mormon apostle elected to the Senate in 1903, faced calls for expulsion over polygamy and theocracy concerns—issues that Goodwin's Weekly aggressively championed. The paper represented the anti-Mormon "Gentile" perspective in overwhelmingly Mormon Utah, making it a crucial voice in the national debate. The Smoot case would ultimately establish that religious leaders could serve in government if they followed civil law over religious doctrine—a precedent still relevant today. Goodwin's fierce rhetoric reflects the genuine fear among non-Mormons that Utah remained a theocracy masquerading as an American state, twenty-six years after the territory's admission to the Union.

Hidden Gems
  • This 'thinking paper for thinking people' cost just 5 cents per issue, or $2 for a full year's subscription—equivalent to about $75 today for weekly delivery
  • The paper operated from two P.O. boxes (1274 and 1020) and occupied rooms 217-232-233 in Salt Lake City's Commercial Club Building, suggesting a substantial operation
  • Phone service existed but was still novel enough that the paper advertised simply 'Phone 301'—no area codes or exchanges needed
  • A 'See America First' convention was scheduled for January 25th, appearing at the bottom of the page as an early example of domestic tourism promotion
  • The editor believed that without winter, 'there would have been no great men or any domestic animals' because harsh conditions forced human and animal development
Fun Facts
  • Reed Smoot, the Mormon apostle under attack in this issue, would ultimately keep his Senate seat and serve 30 years, becoming one of the most powerful Republicans of his era and co-author of the infamous Smoot-Hawley Tariff
  • C.C. Goodwin's reference to 'Fernström' likely refers to Swedish-born Mormon David Fernström, showing how Utah's religious conflicts intersected with its diverse immigrant population
  • The paper's lyrical winter essay mentions the Aurora Borealis as winter's greatest spectacle—in 1906, scientists were just beginning to understand that solar activity caused the northern lights
  • Goodwin's claim that Joseph F. Smith 'has never received a revelation' was actually accurate—Smith was the first LDS president to openly admit this, fundamentally changing Mormon leadership claims
  • The phrase 'See America First' at the page bottom was part of a national tourism movement launched in 1905 to keep American tourist dollars from going to Europe—the predecessor to modern domestic travel promotion
January 19, 1906 January 21, 1906

Also on January 20

1836
A Slave Trader's Ad and Winter Ice Boats: What Washington Was Really Selling on...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Going, Going, GONE!—Portsmouth's Epic 1846 Clothing Auction (Plus John Quincy...
The New Hampshire gazette (Portsmouth [N.H.])
1856
A 1856 Debate on Evolution, Women's Rights & God—100 Years Before Anyone...
New-York dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1861
A Convict's Confession and Prayers Erased: Memphis on the Brink of Secession...
Memphis daily appeal (Memphis, Tenn.)
1862
Union's First Real Victories: Garfield Routs Rebels in Kentucky, McClellan...
The daily dispatch (Richmond [Va.])
1864
Mrs. Lincoln's Secret: Inside the Massive Soldiers' Fair That Took Over...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1865
Jan 20, 1865: Confederate plot to raid from Canada exposed as Fort Fisher falls
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1866
A Serial Killer in Church Clothes: The Execution of the 'Modern Borgia' &...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
January 1876: When Augusta's Fish Market and Photography Studio Were the Height...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
In 1886 Nebraska, a Danish pastor asked: Why are Americans so spiritually...
Stjernen (St. Paul, Howard County, Nebraska)
1896
How a Man's Prank Gone Wrong Led to 'Unintentional Suicide' in 1896 Maine
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1926
When a 58-year-old society woman beat up her attacker near the White House
The Washington times (Washington [D.C.])
1927
A Valley Drowns for Boston's Thirst: How Springfield Grappled With Progress in...
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free