“1906: Three German Businessmen Vanish at Pearl Harbor (Plus a Pastor Becomes a Farmer)”
What's on the Front Page
The Hawaiian Star's New Year's Day 1906 edition opens with Rev. Dr. Kincaid announcing his departure after seven years as pastor of Honolulu's Central Union Church — but not to take another pastorate. Instead, he plans to join his son Douglas in "scientific farming" near Washington, D.C. Meanwhile, Honolulu's German community spent a tense night worrying about three prominent businessmen who vanished during a sailing trip to Pearl Harbor. Paul Ehlers (of B.F. Ehlers & Company), chemist C. Elschner, and B. Bruhn (of H. Hackfeld & Company) left Sunday morning in a small skiff but couldn't beat back against strong winds at Pearl Harbor, forcing them to tie up to a buoy overnight. Friends alerted police and the U.S.S. Iroquois was prepared for a rescue mission before Young Brothers' gasoline launch P.D.Q. spotted and rescued the sunburned, hungry trio several miles from Honolulu harbor.
Why It Matters
This snapshot captures Hawaii just two years before it would become a U.S. territory, when Honolulu was still a small community where three missing businessmen could panic an entire ethnic enclave. The stories reveal a society in transition — Protestant missionaries' children like Rev. Kincaid were moving on, while German merchants had become integral to the islands' economy. Judge Robinson's careful maneuvering around legal holidays to open court shows the delicate balance between American legal procedures and local Hawaiian practices, foreshadowing the complex cultural negotiations that would define Hawaii's path to statehood decades later.
Hidden Gems
- Classified ads cost just 25 cents for three insertions — roughly $8 in today's money for multiple newspaper placements
- The Roneo duplicating machine promised to produce up to 5,000 copies from a single handwritten original for exactly $104.00, marketed as equaling 'the speed and capacity of a modern printing press'
- Sheriff Brown hosted a police luau in Judge Whitney's courtroom with tables arranged in a V-shape and walls covered with flags, ferns, and croton vines
- The S.S. Alameda was scheduled to sail Wednesday at exactly 10 a.m. for San Francisco — a level of precision that suggests steamship travel was remarkably reliable
- Tuesday's special at a local store featured 'Apolican laces 2 to 8 inches wide' for 12½ cents per yard, marked down from 25-50 cents
Fun Facts
- The Stanford case mentioned involved Mrs. Jane Stanford's mysterious death in Honolulu in 1905 — she was the co-founder of Stanford University, and her death remains controversial today with some historians still debating whether she was poisoned
- H. Hackfeld & Company, where missing businessman B. Bruhn worked, would be seized by the U.S. government during WWI due to its German ownership and eventually become the foundation of today's Liberty House department stores
- Pearl Harbor in 1906 was just a sleepy anchorage where weekend sailors got stranded — within 35 years it would become the site that launched America into World War II
- The mention of 'scientific farming' reflects the early 1900s agricultural revolution when the USDA was pioneering new farming techniques that would transform American agriculture
- Judge Robinson's concern about 'lapsed terms' reveals how territorial Hawaii was still working out basic legal procedures — the kind of administrative growing pains that would complicate Hawaii's path to statehood for another 53 years
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free