Monday
September 14, 1896
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.) — Maine, Augusta
“Murder, Money & McKinley: The 1896 Election's Darkest Week in Maine”
Art Deco mural for September 14, 1896
Original newspaper scan from September 14, 1896
Original front page — Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Augusta Daily Kennebec Journal of September 14, 1896, leads with a dramatic murder case that had gripped Maine: Mrs. Clara Getchell of Sidney has been denied a new trial by the state's Law Court in her conviction for poisoning her husband with strychnine mixed into gin and sulphur—a concoction he'd taken daily as a medicinal tonic. The court found the circumstantial evidence overwhelming: she had motive (intimate relations with another man), opportunity (she prepared his final dose), and guilty conduct (she contradicted herself repeatedly). Strychnine pure alkaloid was found in his stomach, kidneys, and lungs. The verdict stands, and Getchell reportedly takes the decision "very hard," having believed her appeal would succeed. Elsewhere on the page, the 1896 election dominates: Republicans claim a "splendid victory" coming tomorrow, with estimates of 20,000 to 50,000 plurality for William McKinley, while Democrats concede at least 10,000. Major McKinley himself is in Canton, Ohio, receiving endless delegations—50,000 political pilgrims are expected this week alone.

Why It Matters

September 1896 marks the climax of one of America's most bitter electoral battles. William McKinley's Republicans were fighting William Jennings Bryan's Democrats over the future of currency: should America embrace "free silver" (unlimited coinage) or maintain the gold standard? The issue consumed the nation. Simultaneously, this front page captures American anxieties about crime, poison, and domestic betrayal—the Getchell case embodied the era's dark fascination with poisoning cases, a genre of murder that gripped the Victorian imagination. The convergence of politics and sensational crime on the same front page tells us how Maine readers consumed their news: national destiny and local scandal intertwined, both demanding urgent attention.

Hidden Gems
  • The Diamond Spring Water ad reveals startling competition anxiety: C.F. Temple must prove his spring is the "PUREST MINERAL WATER in the city" by publishing actual chemical analysis—showing that water safety in 1896 Maine was murky enough to require aggressive marketing with scientific credentials.
  • A mysterious Peter Nelson from Bangor appeared at the Waterville train station "poorly dressed," carrying two Testaments and behaving strangely enough to warrant a newspaper report—suggesting vagrants and mentally ill wanderers were common enough sights to report as local news.
  • Tasker Bros. advertises "Stiff Gold Hat" in "different proportions to become the wearer," priced from 50 cents to $2.50—meaning a hat cost roughly what a working person earned in a day, and millinery was sophisticated enough to offer custom fits.
  • The Pittsfield Democrat gathering notes that the speaker criticized "the judicial routine of the United States," paid "his respects to Hon. Thomas B. Reed," and spoke for two solid hours on silver—yet the audience was so "very old" and the speech so "deep...bombless" that listeners actually left the hall mid-speech.
  • John Brown, a pulp mill fireman in Fairfield, nearly died in a boiler explosion when kerosene vapor ignited while he was oiling the flues inside—an industrial accident so mundane it barely exceeds a few column inches, yet the injuries were described as "frightful" and potentially fatal.
Fun Facts
  • The Getchell murder trial is cited as happening in "1894," but this 1896 appeal reveals poisoning cases dominated Maine courts for years—by the 1920s, poisoning would peak as America's second-most-common murder method (after firearms), partly because toxicology was new enough that murderers believed they could escape detection.
  • Major McKinley's campaign received 50,000 visitors to Canton, Ohio in a single week—this grassroots "front porch campaign" would become legendary in political history, yet what's striking is the logistics: no telephones, no cars for most, just trains and dedication, meaning supporters invested days of travel to shake his hand.
  • The paper mentions Hon. Thomas B. Reed, the Maine congressman and Speaker of the House who McKinley supporters praised—Reed would be one of McKinley's most powerful allies, and his decision to retire from the House in 1899, disillusioned by McKinley's imperialism and the Spanish-American War, would shock Washington.
  • The chemical analysis of Diamond Spring Water lists specific compounds (chlorine content, free ammonia, organic ammonia, nitrites, nitrates, iron, lead) using parts per million—this represents the early days of water quality science; the FDA wouldn't exist for another decade, so bottled water companies were essentially self-regulating their purity claims.
  • The McKinley campaign's confidence is palpable—"estimates running high as 30,000 plurality"—and history proved them right: McKinley would win by 51% nationally, carrying Maine decisively, beginning 24 years of Republican dominance that would shape the progressive era.
Contentious Gilded Age Election Politics Federal Crime Trial Crime Violent Science Medicine
September 13, 1896 September 15, 1896

Also on September 14

1836
How Americans Got Around in 1836: Steamboats, Stages & the Scramble for...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
One Penny for Your Thoughts: Inside Washington's New Temperance Paper (Sept....
The Columbian fountain (Washington, D.C.)
1856
Paris Defends the Empress—And Warns American Women About Fortune-Hunting Nobles
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1861
A Massachusetts Newspaper Calls to War (And Tells a Haunting Story About Duty)
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1862
Lee Invades Maryland: A Confederate Newspaper Reports America's Turning Point...
The Chattanooga Daily Rebel (Chattanooga, Tenn.)
1863
Fort Wagner Falls: Union Breaks Into Charleston Harbor (and What Soldiers Found...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1864
September 1864: How Democrats 'Started the War,' One Furious Newspaper Claims
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1866
A City Divided: Cholera, Commerce, and Contradictions in Reconstruction New...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1876
1876: Why Farmers Were Bankrupting Their Own Land—and Why Grant's Navy...
The Republican journal (Belfast, Me.)
1886
Why the White House Needed TWO Gas Lines (And Why the Treasury Was Obsessed...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1906
When Connecticut Democrats Snubbed Their Own Mayor (And Other 1906 Political...
The Willimantic journal (Willimantic, Conn.)
1926
1926: When Lawyers Turned on Each Other & Football Teams Faced Playing in Their...
The Indianapolis times (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1927
Minnesota's 12-Year-Old Canning Champions Head to Chicago—And Why Their County...
Grand Rapids herald-review (Grand Rapids, Itasca County, Minn)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free