Wednesday
September 9, 1896
The Louisiana Democrat (Alexandria, La.) — Alexandria, Louisiana
“The Slaver's Noose: Why a 35-Year-Old Execution Haunted 1896 America”
Art Deco mural for September 9, 1896
Original newspaper scan from September 9, 1896
Original front page — The Louisiana Democrat (Alexandria, La.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Louisiana Democrat's September 9, 1896 front page leads with a gripping historical account: the capture and execution of Captain Nathaniel Gordon, the only American slave ship captain ever hanged for his crimes. The story, recounted by a former U.S. Navy officer now living in Cleveland, details how the sloop-of-war Mohican intercepted the slave ship *Erie* off the Congo in spring 1861, discovering 890 enslaved people aboard. Gordon was executed on Bedloe's Island (where the Statue of Liberty now stands) just a year after his capture—a swift and severe punishment reflecting the nation's raw nerves over slavery as the Civil War erupted. The article notes that other crew members received lesser sentences, though some eventually volunteered for military service and went free. Also featured is a tall tale about railroad engineer Boothby racing against the Ohio and Mississippi train's engine #60, only to learn afterward that an earthquake had been pushing his competitor along—making his victory bittersweet.

Why It Matters

This 1896 retrospective on Gordon's execution arrives at a pivotal moment: Reconstruction has officially ended, the Civil War is 31 years in the past, and America is grappling with its legacy of slavery through Jim Crow laws and systemic racism. The story's prominence reflects how slavery—despite being abolished—remained a defining trauma in the national consciousness. The fact that a newspaper is still narrating this 1861 execution suggests Americans in 1896 were still processing the moral reckoning the war had forced upon them. Meanwhile, the paper's masthead declares 'The World Is Governed Too Much,' suggesting growing populist and anti-establishment sentiment that would shape the 1896 presidential election between William McKinley and William Jennings Bryan.

Hidden Gems
  • The Louisiana Democrat subscription rate was just $1.00 per year, or 50 cents for six months—roughly $33-$16 in today's money—making newspapers accessible to working-class readers despite their modest incomes.
  • First-class railroad fare from Alexandria to New Orleans cost $5.80, suggesting a wealthy traveler's budget; meanwhile, enslaved people on the *Erie* were valued in the thousands of dollars each, illustrating the obscene economics of the slave trade.
  • The paper advertised a 'Two for One' bundle offer: The Louisiana Democrat plus the Cincinnati Weekly Enquirer for $1.10 annually—an early example of media consolidation and cross-promotion to boost circulation.
  • A small note mentions that 37,000 girls work in the American telephone service, and the Boston Transcript sardonically suggests they must possess 'comprehensive knowledge of the science of profanity' from male callers—revealing both women's expanding workforce participation and persistent sexism.
  • The railroad schedules list four separate rail lines serving Alexandria, Louisiana (Texas & Pacific, Morgan's Louisiana & Texas, St. L.I.M.S.-H.C.A.N., and Kansas City-Watkins-Gulf), showing how critical rail infrastructure was to even small Southern towns in the 1890s.
Fun Facts
  • Captain Nathaniel Gordon was hanged on Bedloe's Island in 1862—the very location where the Statue of Liberty would be dedicated just 23 years later in 1885. The irony is staggering: a monument to freedom erected where an enslaver was executed for trafficking in human beings.
  • The story mentions that the *Erie* carried 890 enslaved people—this was during the final years of the American slave trade, which the U.S. had officially banned in 1808 but continued illicitly. Gordon's execution marked a rare moment of federal enforcement; most slavers operated with impunity.
  • The railroad engineer Boothby story, while likely apocryphal, reflects the obsessive competitive culture of late-19th-century railroad companies and the dangerous speeds locomotives were already reaching—foreshadowing the railroad disasters that would plague the 1890s.
  • The paper's motto 'The World Is Governed Too Much' echoes the populist fervor sweeping America in 1896, the year of Bryan's famous 'Cross of Gold' speech demanding currency reform and attacking Eastern banking interests.
  • The classified ads and business notices (railroad tickets, notary services, insurance) reveal a small-town Louisiana economy still heavily dependent on cotton, railroads, and agricultural commerce—the very systems built on slavery's legacy just 30 years after emancipation.
Tragic Gilded Age Crime Trial Civil Rights Transportation Rail Economy Trade
September 8, 1896 September 10, 1896

Also on September 9

1846
How a Traitor's Shame Haunted Him Across an Ocean: Benedict Arnold's Forgotten...
Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1856
Inside Antebellum New Orleans: The Business Directory of a Doomed Economy (1856)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
Dogs Gone Mad, Counterfeits, and Parade Day in Wartime New Orleans (Sept. 9,...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
The Tax That Won the Civil War: October 1st Changes Everything (And the Feds...
Daily State sentinel (Indianapolis, Ind.)
1863
50 Deserters a Night: The Confederacy Comes Apart (September 1863)
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1864
Last Gasp of the Confederacy: What Mississippi's War Department Charged for a...
The daily clarion (Meridian, Miss.)
1865
1865: 'We own everything by conquest' — Sherman's shocking speech & the...
The daily Gate City (Keokuk, Iowa)
1866
One Year After Appomattox: A Radical New Orleans Newspaper Argues Why Democracy...
New Orleans tribune (New Orleans [La.])
1876
Silver Riches & Stagecoach Misery: Inside Booming Arizona, 1876
Arizona citizen (Tucson, Pima County, A.T. [i.e. Ariz.])
1886
When a Foundryman Stole a Newspaper's Horse: Life in 1886 Michigan
Weekly expositor (Brockway Centre, Mich.)
1906
When the Czar's Uncle Went Too Far: Royal Scandals & Forgotten Wars of 1906
Albuquerque morning journal (Albuquerque, N.M.)
1926
When Teachers Had Their Names in the Paper & $35 Could Land You in Jail
Pocahontas times (Huntersville, W. Va.)
1927
Ford's Mystery Car Has the World Obsessed (And We Still Don't Know What It Is)
Clinch Valley news (Jeffersonville, Va.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free