“What Savannah's Biggest Store Was Selling for 25 Cents in 1886 (And It's Shocking)”
What's on the Front Page
The Savannah Morning News from October 24, 1886, is dominated by an extraordinary advertising spectacular from Altmayer & Co., a major Savannah department store occupying nearly the entire front page. The merchant announces "Unprecedented Bargains" and "Extraordinary Drives" across an astonishing range of departments: shoes (infants' kid button shoes for 25 cents, boys' fine calf buttons for $1.75), dress goods (250 different styles marked down to 19 cents per yard), silk and velvet selections, elaborate cloaks and wraps for ladies, and linens for hotels and housekeepers. The sheer density of merchandise—shoes for every family member, Paris and Berlin imported garments, 800 dozen pairs of ladies' silk-lisle thread hosiery—reveals a store positioning itself as a one-stop emporium. The paper's masthead credits H. B. Still as Editor and Proprietor, established 1850.
Why It Matters
This advertisement captures the post-Reconstruction South in a moment of commercial optimism. By 1886, Savannah was rebuilding its mercantile importance after the Civil War devastation, and department stores like Altmayer & Co. represented the new consumer culture sweeping America. The aggressive price competition and emphasis on "bargains" signal the rise of mass retail and factory production, moving away from the artisanal economy of previous decades. The specific mention of imported French and Berlin goods, New York prices, and comparison shopping reflects how national commercial networks were binding regional markets together—Savannah merchants were now competing directly with "monster houses" in New York and Philadelphia.
Hidden Gems
- Altmayer & Co. advertises they have purchased 'an immense line of John Murdell Co.'s "SOLAR TIP SHOES"' for youth—this is actually referencing a specific shoe manufacturer's patented heel technology, representing industrial innovation in footwear design that was still noteworthy enough to be a selling point.
- The store promises an 'Illustrated Fashion Catalogue, just out, containing 100 pages'—mail-order catalogs were revolutionary retail tools in 1886, allowing rural and distant customers to shop by post, fundamentally transforming American commerce.
- Ladies' 'Curacoa Kid Button Shoes' are advertised at $2.25, with the store claiming 'We defy any house in this city to give you as good a shoe'—Curacoa kid was a premium leather from the Caribbean island, making this a luxury import item even for a 'bargain.'
- The hosiery section lists '800 dozen Ladies' Black and Solid Colors Lisle Thread Hose at 19c'—that's 9,600 pairs of stockings in a single inventory lot, demonstrating the industrial scale of late-19th-century retail.
- Infants' shoes with 'silk worked button holes and hand sewed' details at 50 cents suggest that even mass-produced children's shoes still retained hand-finishing touches—the industrial and artisanal hadn't fully separated.
Fun Facts
- Altmayer & Co. emphasizes their 'Seal Plush Sacques' at $14.50, noting 'similar goods sold last year from $25 to $35'—seal plush was a luxury imitation fur material made from cotton, showing how late-Victorian fashion was becoming democratized through synthetic alternatives.
- The store advertises '400 Ladies' Boncle Newmarkets' (a type of fitted overcoat) at $4.95—newmarkets were named after Newmarket racecourse in England and became a fashion craze in the 1880s; this ad captures a specific moment when a British sporting reference was driving American women's fashion.
- Three years after this 1886 edition, Savannah would suffer a devastating yellow fever epidemic (1889), killing nearly 10% of the population; the commercial confidence radiating from this front page would soon give way to crisis, reminding how fragile 19th-century prosperity could be.
- The repeated claim that Altmayer & Co. can undercut New York prices reflects the reality that by the 1880s, railroads had compressed geographic advantage—a Savannah merchant could now compete nationally in ways impossible just 20 years earlier.
- Ladies' 'French calf skin hand sewed' shoes advertised at $7 represent the last generation of shoes still made with significant hand labor; within a decade, assembly-line shoe manufacturing would make this a rarity.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free