“When Democrats Called Their Own 'Assistant Republicans': A Louisiana Paper's 1886 Political War”
Original front page — Lake Charles commercial (Lake Charles, Calcasieu Parish, La.) — Click to enlarge
What's on the Front Page
The Lake Charles Commercial delivers a dense directory of Louisiana's political apparatus on October 2, 1886, listing federal senators, representatives, state officers, parish officials, and town leadership in meticulous detail. Governor Samuel D. McEnery heads the state government, while local magistrates and constables maintain order in this Calcasieu Parish outpost. But beneath the bureaucratic roster lies the real story: a scorching editorial reprinted from a New York Democratic correspondent denouncing party traitors. Six Democratic congressmen from New York—Stahlaecker, Cowdeny, Merriman, Tim Campbell, Viele, and Neller—voted against their party on the tariff question, earning them scathing condemnation. Most explosive is the attack on Pennsylvania's Samuel J. Randall, branded 'the creature of the Republican party' kept in Congress by GOP manipulation. The piece warns Louisiana voters: don't send 'assistant Republicans' to Congress as your representatives, or face the wrath of unified Democratic sentiment.
Why It Matters
This page captures a critical moment in post-Reconstruction American politics. The Democratic Party, newly resurgent after the Civil War, was fracturing over the tariff—free trade advocates (mainly Southern agrarians) versus protectionists aligned with industrial interests. Randall's defection symbolized how regional economic interests were destroying party unity. The 1886 election was a referendum on whether Democrats could enforce party discipline or whether Congress would splinter into regional and ideological factions. This conflict would reshape American politics through the 1890s, eventually contributing to the party's split in 1896 over William Jennings Bryan and free silver.
Hidden Gems
- The Lake Charles Commercial carries a mystical poem about defeating 'con-Jos' (conjure spells) in Louisiana folk practice, blending African spiritual traditions with Catholic references like 'Veau de vie' (holy water) and ocean baptisms—evidence of Creole supernatural beliefs still thriving in 1880s Louisiana.
- Dr. J. C. Munday advertises as 'Physician, Surgeon and Gynecologist' on Ryan Street—one of the earliest medical directory mentions of a gynecology specialty in provincial Louisiana, suggesting surprisingly modern medical specialization in a town of fewer than 2,000 people.
- Leon Viterbo's boot and shoe factory explicitly calls itself 'Strictly One Price Cash Store'—a radical retail innovation of the 1870s-80s. Fixed pricing and cash-only sales were revolutionary concepts replacing the haggling and credit systems that dominated earlier commerce.
- The Haskell House hotel proprietor is listed as 'J. S. Hicks'—yet the establishment is called 'Haskell House,' suggesting either previous ownership or a brand name retained for reputation, showing how 19th-century hospitality businesses maintained continuity through name recognition.
- A. J. Kearney holds the position of 'District Attorney' and also appears as co-founder of the law firm 'Kearney & Gibbs'—a stark conflict of interest that would be scandalous today, revealing how casual Louisiana was about mixing public office with private legal practice.
Fun Facts
- Governor Samuel D. McEnery, listed at the top of the state directory, would serve Louisiana politics for decades and later become a U.S. Senator—this local directory captured him during his first term as governor, at a pivotal moment when Reconstruction was ending and the South was reasserting Democratic control.
- The fierce editorial attacking Congressman Samuel J. Randall references the Chicago Platform—the 1884 Democratic platform. Randall's 'betrayal' on tariff votes was so controversial that he was ultimately defeated in 1890, validating the dire warnings printed in obscure newspapers like the Lake Charles Commercial.
- The paper lists 'Warren Easton' as Superintendent of Education—Easton would become a legendary Louisiana educator whose name still graces a major New Orleans high school founded in 1906, showing how local political figures of 1886 became educational monuments.
- The classified ads offer medical services that would horrify modern practitioners: Dr. Richardson advertises he answers calls 'Day or Night' from his home office on mixed residential and commercial streets, with no mention of licensing boards, malpractice insurance, or formal credentials beyond 'M.D.'
- F. Chavanne's bakery and confectionery advertises 'Fine Cakes for Wedding Parties Furnished on short Notice'—evidence that 1886 Lake Charles had a wedding culture sophisticated enough to demand custom cakes, suggesting a growing merchant class with disposable income for celebrations.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free