“1886: When a Michigan Editor Railed Against Chicago's 15,000 Saloons—and Praised Militia Crackdowns on Strikers”
What's on the Front Page
The Weekly Expositor, published by James A. Menzies in Brockway Centre, Michigan, leads this June 1886 edition with news of ambitious local development—a special school meeting has voted to sell old school property and build a new brick schoolhouse on land owned by Levi Morrill, with a graded school district newly organized and five trustees elected. The paper overflows with notices of Fourth of July celebrations planned across the region (Brockway Centre celebrates July 5th in style), dramatic society performances, and agricultural reports. Editor Menzies also features a lengthy travel narrative about his recent trip to Southern Wisconsin, offering vivid descriptions of the Chicago and Grand Trunk Railway, commentary on Chicago's vice and the evangelistic work of Sam Jones, and praise for Wisconsin's Governor Rusk for deploying militia to quash labor strikes in Milwaukee. The front page is densely packed with local gossip, business directory listings, church announcements, and classified advertisements for real estate, insurance, and agricultural implement dealers.
Why It Matters
This 1886 snapshot captures rural Michigan during a period of intense social transformation. The region was experiencing the rural school consolidation movement that would reshape American education, while labor unrest in industrial centers like Milwaukee reflected the growing tensions between capital and organized workers—a conflict that would define the coming decades. The paper's prominent coverage of Governor Rusk's militia response to strikes reveals how quickly authorities moved to suppress labor organizing, setting a tone for the violent labor confrontations of the 1890s. The editor's lengthy meditation on Chicago's 'vice' and optimism about evangelical reform also reflects the urban anxiety and moral crusades characteristic of the Gilded Age, when many believed cities threatened American virtue.
Hidden Gems
- The Brockway Centre Bank advertises $75,000 in responsibility and boasts 'a large amount of money to loan on real estate' at rates 'lower than can be procured elsewhere'—a vivid glimpse of rural banking before deposit insurance, when local banks were personal institutions and lending rates were brazenly competitive.
- True Bros. advertise Poland China pigs bred at Armada, Michigan, with 'a fine lot of spring pigs for sale'—showing how agricultural entrepreneurship was migrating upmarket; specialized livestock breeding was emerging as a commercial niche even in rural areas.
- The paper mentions wheat stalks six feet long picked from J.H. Keyes' farm at Brockway—suggesting unusually favorable growing conditions that year, yet the editor's earlier trip narrative notes crops were 'badly set back by frosts and cool evenings,' revealing the precarious, hyperlocal nature of 19th-century agriculture.
- An ad for the Lexington Woolen Mill aggressively solicits 'all the fine wool in St. Clair, Sanilac and Huron counties' and boasts unexcelled facilities for custom carding and spinning—evidence of how rural mills competed to consolidate production before mechanization centralized the industry.
- The dramatic company performance of 'How to Pay the Rent' earned over $35 in receipts at Lexington—a modest but real income stream for amateur entertainers in an era before cinema, showing how live theater was the primary entertainment resource.
Fun Facts
- Governor Rusk of Wisconsin, praised here for deploying militia against strikers in Milwaukee, was part of a wave of Republican governors using state power against labor organizing; within a decade, such heavy-handed tactics would spark the Pullman Strike of 1894, one of the deadliest labor conflicts in American history.
- The paper's breathless admiration for Chicago's railroad infrastructure and commercial prowess—calling it 'one of the greatest railroad and business centers'—was written just 20 years before the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, which temporarily shifted economic dominance westward and challenged Chicago's preeminence.
- The editor's criticism of Chicago's '10,000 or 15,000 liquor saloons' and call for their elimination was published during the height of the temperance movement; by 1920, Prohibition would attempt exactly what this editor demanded, with catastrophic unintended consequences.
- James A. Menzies' editorial voice praising summary justice and suggesting that 'summary justice might save the country from fear of communists, anarchists and socialists' reflects the paranoia of the mid-1880s; just one year later, the Haymarket bombing in Chicago would seeming validate these fears and trigger the first Red Scare.
- The school consolidation vote documented here—moving from a small local schoolhouse to a graded brick building—was part of a national movement to professionalize and standardize education; by the 1920s, rural consolidation would reshape American schooling and accelerate the decline of one-room schoolhouses.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free