Thursday
May 20, 1886
The Republican journal (Belfast, Me.) — Waldo, Maine
“How Maine Mourned the Civil War 23 Years Later—and Why a South American Plant Threatened the Rum Trade”
Art Deco mural for May 20, 1886
Original newspaper scan from May 20, 1886
Original front page — The Republican journal (Belfast, Me.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Republican Journal's May 20, 1886 edition leads with Maine's solemn preparations for Memorial Day, featuring Grand Army of the Republic Commander Samuel W. Lane's stirring proclamation that Monday, May 31st would be observed statewide to honor the Civil War dead. Lane's order is both reverent and pointed—he warns that "if the cause in which, and for which they died was the cause of wrong, oppression and injustice then are the services of Memorial Day unholy," but asserts their sacrifice was for "government of the people, by the people, and for the people." The paper also covers bustling commodity markets: Brighton Cattle Market reports brisk trade with beef prices up 6 cents per pound, Western cattle commanding premium export prices, and lamb costing 6-8 cents per pound. Meanwhile, a spirited editorial titled "Let the Grangers Speak" takes aim at ex-Governor Garecelon's patronizing remarks about making farming "respectable," arguing that agriculture is actually "this country's strongest bulwark of respectability, honesty and intelligence." The page is dense with patent medicine advertisements—Dr. King's New Discovery for consumption, Carter's Little Liver Pills, and notably, Coca wine, a South American plant drink rapidly replacing liquor and claiming to have already captured half the rum trade in Lowell, Massachusetts.

Why It Matters

This 1886 edition captures America at a pivotal moment: just twenty years after Appomattox, the nation was still wrestling with how to honor and remember the Civil War while moving forward economically. The elaborate Memorial Day proclamation reflects deep emotional wounds not yet healed. Simultaneously, the paper shows an America in the throes of industrial transformation—robust commodity markets, patent medicines flooding the market (many of dubious efficacy), and the emerging controversy over agricultural labor and dignity. The Coca wine phenomenon hints at broader shifts in American consumption and drug regulation that would ultimately lead to the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906. The editorial defending farmers against elite condescension reveals class tensions simmering beneath the Gilded Age's surface prosperity.

Hidden Gems
  • Coca wine was claimed to have captured half the rum trade in Lowell, Massachusetts and was "growing into Boston, Providence, Brooklyn, New York, Baltimore and Washington"—a South American plant-based drink marketed as a miracle cure for paralysis and insanity, selling at agencies for just 25 cents. This unregulated patent medicine would eventually be superseded by Coca-Cola, which was first sold in Atlanta in 1886, the same year this paper ran.
  • The subscription rate was $2.00 per year if paid in advance—but a painful $3.00 if paid at expiration. The paper explicitly warned that 'subscribers in arrears must forward the sum due,' showing how tight cash flow was for rural newspapers dependent on small-town readers.
  • A dispatch from Interlachen, Florida reported no fresh meat had been available for sale in three weeks—when half an ox finally arrived from Jacksonville, the man who'd ordered it couldn't raise enough money to pay for it, so it was sent back to spoil in the Florida heat. This glimpse of rural deprivation contradicts the era's prosperity narrative.
  • The 20th Maine Regiment monument at Gettysburg had just been completed, honoring the unit that lost 131 men (38 killed, 93 wounded) while repulsing Longstreet's attack and capturing 308 prisoners on July 2, 1863—precisely 23 years before this paper ran. The monument names every officer and man who fell.
  • Hotel Colfax in Colfax Springs, Iowa advertised as opening May 20, 1886 (the very date of this paper) with 'Thayer's Northwestern orchestra' engaged for the season, mineral baths, and 'Old Man Water' as a 'great restorer and invigorator'—a luxury resort promising healing waters to America's growing leisure class.
Fun Facts
  • The paper's advertising rates were $1.00 per square inch for one week—meaning a modest quarter-page advertisement cost roughly what a skilled worker made in a day. Yet pharmaceutical companies flooded the pages with patent medicines like Dr. King's New Discovery, part of an unregulated industry that wouldn't face serious federal oversight until 1906.
  • Commander Samuel W. Lane's Memorial Day order invokes Lincoln's Gettysburg Address ("government of the people, by the people, and for the people"), showing how thoroughly that speech had become the moral vocabulary of Civil War commemoration by 1886—only 23 years after Lincoln delivered it.
  • The paper notes that the New York Senate committee found the Broadway Surface Railway Company guilty of 'wanton and wilful disregard of law' with 'no precedent in the annals of the state'—just as America's urban transit boom was exploding, creating both fortunes and scandals that would define the Progressive Era.
  • Ex-Governor Garecelon's condescending remarks about making farming 'respectable' triggered a furious editorial response, foreshadowing the Populist movement that would explode just four years later in 1890, when rural America would demand political recognition of their economic grievances.
  • The Brighton Cattle Market report shows Chicago beef being shipped to Florida and the sophisticated national livestock trade network already operating in 1886—yet Interlachen couldn't afford to buy it when it arrived, revealing deep inequality even as industrial efficiency grew.
Contentious Gilded Age Politics State Military Economy Markets Agriculture Public Health
May 19, 1886 May 21, 1886

Also on May 20

View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free