Wednesday
March 17, 1886
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.) — Washington D.C., Washington
“When Senators Debated Poker Rules and Teachers Yanked Kids Bald: A Night at Cleveland's White House (March 17, 1886)”
Art Deco mural for March 17, 1886
Original newspaper scan from March 17, 1886
Original front page — The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

Washington D.C. is ablaze with political intrigue on this March evening in 1886. Governor Murray of Utah has been asked—and promptly complied—to resign after receiving a telegram from Secretary Lamar, with his resignation to be hand-delivered by a Mormon delegate coming to the capital. Meanwhile, the Senate is digesting President Cleveland's dinner the night before, where he seated 41 senators in careful alternating Republican-Democrat order, with Senator Saulsbury on his right and Senator Logan on his left. The White House social season is in full swing: Miss Cleveland herself is holding her first morning-hour receptions on Tuesdays and Thursdays from noon to 1 p.m., receiving visitors quite informally in the Red Parlor. On the business side, the government has dramatically reduced Star Route mail contracts across the western territories and states—from $8,003,015 last year to just $1,715,005 this year, a stunning 78% cut. The steamship Oregon disaster looms large: 118 of 593 mail bags have been recovered, but the registered mail is nearly a total loss, with 2,300 letters estimated in 60 missing bags of heavily registered matter. The State Department's own official mail dispatch bags are gone.

Why It Matters

This moment captures America at a critical juncture: the end of Reconstruction is still recent, the Civil Service Reform movement is gaining real traction (note the appointment of Mr. Oberly to the Civil Service Commission), and the federal government is actively trying to rein in corruption in mail contracts—the infamous 'Star Route frauds' of the 1880s had been a massive scandal involving kickbacks and embezzlement. President Cleveland's election in 1884 marked a return of Democratic power after 24 years of Republican dominance, and every dinner, every appointment, every resignation carried symbolic weight in a deeply polarized capital. The Utah territorial issue foreshadows the coming conflict over Mormon polygamy that would dominate federal-territorial relations for years. Meanwhile, the mundane government business—fourth-class postmaster appointments, competitive bidding on bricks and cement—reveals an era trying to professionalize itself.

Hidden Gems
  • Warren Green's rejection as Consul-General to Japan was being challenged on the grounds that he 'opened a Jack-pot with a pair of tens' in a poker game at Kanagowa—'which experts in the Committee on Foreign Relations know is highly reprehensible'—a delightful bit of congressional snark suggesting some senators had very particular opinions about poker etiquette.
  • A teacher named John Lattimore stands accused of yanking a student named Willie Carroll out of his seat by the hair hard enough to leave a bald spot 'as large as a silver half dollar'—and the teacher's defense is merely that the boy was 'a ringleader in mischief.' The complaint was filed with authorities, showing even then, concerns about corporal punishment in schools.
  • The fastest ocean mail delivery on record is noted: New York to Havana in just 73 hours by rail to Tampa and then steamer—a fact proudly announced suggesting how cutting-edge this routing was.
  • Miss Cleveland's receiving hours drew 'many gentlemen among the callers' and the paper notes she was 'quite informal'—a subtle nod to the fact that an unmarried presidential daughter receiving male visitors at all was relatively progressive social behavior for 1886.
  • The Hot Springs, Arkansas reservation is being pressured to allow bath houses to relocate off the grounds, with Mayor Walsh testifying that removing the waters 'will deprive them of their medicinal qualities'—showing early government stewardship of natural resources and the belief that location itself affected water's healing powers.
Fun Facts
  • The Electoral Count Bill passed by the Senate on this very day related directly to the trauma of the 1876 Hayes-Tilden election disaster—Congress was still trying to create better procedures for certifying electoral votes after that constitutional crisis 10 years prior.
  • Governor Murray of Utah was being pressured to resign specifically over the Mormon question—within a decade, the federal government would pass the Edmunds-Tucker Act (1887) essentially dissolving the church's temporal power and stripping polygamists of voting rights, the harshest religious persecution in American history.
  • The Star Route contracts reduction from $8 million to $1.7 million represented Cleveland's attack on the Republican machine's patronage system—this was *real* reform, eliminating nearly 4,000 contract routes in the West in one stroke, a massive blow to Republican political infrastructure in rural America.
  • Those fourth-class postmaster appointments to Virginia towns like 'Ash Grove' and 'Averett' seem trivial, but these posts were gold—postmasters got paid commissions and wielded real local political power, so every one represented a loyalty battle in the emerging civil service reform movement.
  • The mention of naval cadets Albert Matthews and John McDonald arriving 'from the Pacific squadron' on the Shenandoah and Mohican presages America's coming rise as a Pacific power—naval expansion under Cleveland and his successors would make these remote squadrons the vanguard of American empire.
Contentious Gilded Age Politics Federal Crime Corruption Politics State Disaster Maritime Education
March 16, 1886 March 20, 1886

Also on March 17

1846
Bread, War & Escape: The Week Britain Remade Economics (and India Invaded Back)
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
The $7.75 Million Ghost Debt: How the U.S. Finally Paid Off Texas—One Year...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1861
Three Weeks Before Fort Sumter: Nashville Pretends Everything Is Normal (It...
Nashville union and American (Nashville, Tenn.)
1862
New Orleans Goes Scorched Earth: The Day the South Decided to Burn Its Cotton...
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1863
The South Blew Up Its Own Warship Over a Wooden Fake—And It Gets Worse
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1864
How Did Xerxes Feed 5 Million Soldiers? A Soldier Asks, and the Intelligencer...
Weekly national intelligencer (Washington [D.C.])
1865
Grant Crushes War Profiteers & A Blind Woman Sees for the First Time
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1866
One Year After Lee's Surrender, the South Is Turning Violent—And Johnson Is...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
Inside a Maine Newspaper From America's Centennial Year: When a Horse Liniment...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1896
Troops at the Capitol, Bodies in Cuba, and a Powder Keg in Kentucky—March 17,...
Waterbury Democrat (Waterbury, Conn.)
1906
🗳️ 1906: Heliotrope neckties, failed melons, and a nail-biter election in...
Grand Rapids herald-review (Grand Rapids, Itasca County, Minn)
1926
Death Watch at the White House: President's Father Dying as Townspeople Gather...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1927
America Says 'No' to League Control—While Navy Gunships Guard Shanghai Shipyards
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free