“Maine's Deer War: When hunters burned down game wardens' homes—and other chaos from 1886”
What's on the Front Page
The Augusta daily newspaper leads with patent medicine advertisements—Hood's Sarsaparilla promising to cure scrofula, Adamson's Botanic Cough Balsam, and Syrup of Red Spruce Gum all competing for readers' ailments. But buried in the telegraphic dispatches is far more dramatic news: in Wesley, Maine, a band of young deer hunters known as the "Shacker" gang stands accused of burning down the homes of state game wardens in retaliation for game law enforcement. Four men—led by the daring J. Wilbur Day—face trial for burning Fred Munson's buildings to the ground on July 17th and, six weeks later, torching Samuel Cushing's barn filled with hay, tools, and a $300 horse. The violence was so intense that the county called in special counsel from the Maine game association to prosecute. Meanwhile, a schooner named Isaac Burpee limps into Boothbay harbor after a harrowing week at sea—her deck load torn away, crew frost-bitten, and hull damaged after battling a northeast gale off Cape Cod. In lighter news, Portland's base ball association reports receipts of $21,180 against expenses of $20,002, with players' salaries consuming $8,137 of the budget.
Why It Matters
This January 1886 edition captures America in transition. The prominence of patent medicines reflects the Wild West of American pharmaceuticals—before the FDA existed, anything could be marketed as a cure, with testimonials from readers swearing to miraculous results. The Wesley case reveals the profound tension between rural communities and state authority: young men resented outsiders enforcing game laws that restricted their hunting rights, leading them to terrorism. This conflict would fester throughout rural America for decades. Meanwhile, the emerging Knights of Labor movement appears in a brief Camden dispatch—workers demanding cash wages instead of company store scrip, an early battle in labor's long fight for economic dignity. The baseball league's detailed financial accounting shows how thoroughly the sport had professionalized in just a decade.
Hidden Gems
- Hood's Sarsaparilla promised to cure scrofula—a tubercular infection of the lymph nodes—by 'expelling all trace of scrofula from the blood.' The testimonial from C.E. Joyeroy of Lowell, Massachusetts claimed five bottles cured him after two running sores on his neck lasted over a year. This was standard 1880s medicine.
- The Flower Medicine Company offered a free 'Flower Family Formula Book' containing recipes for homemade skin treatments, hair tonics, tooth pastes, and croup remedies—essentially a DIY medicine manual mailed to anyone who sent their name and address to Boston.
- A Portland art student named John McDonald, who had come to New York three years prior to study at the Art Student League, was arrested for stealing about $50 in cash and a gold watch from fellow students at Wood's gymnasium—an early documented case of art school crime.
- The Sandy River National Bank in Farmington reported being 'in good condition and doing a large business,' with Francis G. Butler as president and a board of five directors—all prominent local men overseeing what appears to be robust regional finance.
- The chess match between Wilhelm Steinitz and Johannes Zukertort for $4,000 and 'the championship of the world' was being played across three cities: New York, St. Louis, and New Orleans, with draws not counting and requiring best-of-nine victories. Zukertort won the third game in 47 moves.
Fun Facts
- The Wesley 'Shacker' gang's violent retaliation against game wardens points to a nationwide conflict: state-imposed hunting seasons were new and deeply resented by rural hunters who'd always seen deer as communal resources. This tension would culminate in violent poaching wars throughout the Appalachian and Western regions well into the 20th century.
- Steinitz vs. Zukertort's chess championship was being played across three American cities in 1886, with the match itself a major public spectacle drawing large crowds—chess was genuinely a mass entertainment in the Gilded Age, with championship matches attracting thousands of spectators and newspaper coverage rivaling sports.
- The Knights of Labor victory in Camden and Rockport—forcing S.E.H.L. Shepherd to switch from company store scrip to weekly cash wages—represented a rare labor win in the 1880s, just as the Knights were reaching peak membership around 700,000 before their dramatic collapse after the Haymarket affair later that year.
- Patent medicines like Hood's Sarsaparilla dominated American newspapers because they were among the few products with national distribution and aggressive advertising budgets—this era essentially invented American mass marketing through medical testimonials, a practice that wouldn't face serious regulation until the FDA's founding in 1906.
- The schooner Isaac Burpee's ordeal—surviving ice-choked waters off Cape Cod with a frost-bitten crew—reflects Maine's still-vital maritime economy in 1886, even as industrial fishing and steam-powered vessels were beginning to eclipse wooden sailing ships in the Atlantic fishery.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free