Thursday
January 7, 1886
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.) — Washington, District Of Columbia
“1886: Why Teddy Roosevelt's Mentor Got Fired (and What It Cost America)”
Art Deco mural for January 7, 1886
Original newspaper scan from January 7, 1886
Original front page — The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Washington Critic's front page on Thursday, January 7, 1886, leads with government gossip and personnel moves, including President Cleveland's decision to relieve General George Crook from command of the Department of Arizona and replace him with General Nelson A. Miles—a shake-up driven by dissatisfaction with the Apache campaign despite Crook's reputation as one of the nation's finest Indian fighters. The paper also reports that the President has granted amnesty to Mormon polygamists willing to abandon the practice under the Edmunds law, and notes that over 700 French Spoliation Claims cases have already been filed in the Court of Claims, with another 800 expected before the deadline—cases involving vast sums of money and requiring interpretation of six different treaties with France. In a curious detail, a Post Office clerk named Oliver P. Burger was dismissed for circulating cards that offered, for a fee, to help people get government jobs through civil service examination—a scheme the administration took seriously enough to fire him over. The page is dominated by a massive Woodward & Lothrop department store advertisement announcing their 'Regular Weekly Remnant Day Sale,' featuring heavily discounted fabrics, clothing, and household goods.

Why It Matters

This snapshot captures late-Gilded Age America at a crucial moment: the federal government was wrestling with Indian policy (the Apache Wars would drag on for years), civil service reform was still contested (the spoils system died hard), and the French Spoliation Claims—stemming from pre-War of 1812 attacks on American merchant ships—represented old international debts finally being litigated. The Mormon amnesty reflects the federal government's complicated relationship with Utah Territory, where polygamy remained a flashpoint. The massive department store advertisement shows the rise of urban retail and consumer culture in an increasingly prosperous Washington. Meanwhile, the small scandal of a postal clerk offering to sell civil service advice hints at the friction between the new merit-based system and older patronage traditions.

Hidden Gems
  • Woodward & Lothrop's 'Remnant Day Sale' offered hand-painted lacquered boxes originally priced at $7 for just $1.00—a discount of 85%—suggesting either massive overstock or aggressive competition in Washington's retail market.
  • The army news section notes that Lieutenant David G. McRitchie, who 'commanded the Tallapoosa for so many years,' was visiting from Maine and staying at No. 1010 Eleventh Street—a casual detail revealing that military officers in Washington maintained boarding house residences, not permanent homes.
  • A signal line was being established between Washington and Point of Rocks 'to give the Graduating class at Fort Myer an opportunity to practice field signaling'—meaning a remote communication experiment using Army cadets as test subjects.
  • Oliver P. Burger's dismissal for selling civil service exam tips suggests that coaching for government jobs was already a hustled commodity in 1886, decades before test-prep became an industry.
  • The paper mentions that General Sheridan was presented with a cane made from wood collected from the Chickamauga and Mission Ridge battlefields, with a Confederate bullet 'protruding from one side'—showing how Civil War relics were being venerated and weaponized as souvenirs.
Fun Facts
  • The article mentions General George Crook's imminent removal from the Arizona Department—what the paper doesn't note is that Crook would be reassigned, but the Apache Wars would continue for three more years until Geronimo's surrender in September 1886, validating some critics' view that the campaign needed fresh leadership.
  • General Nelson A. Miles, poised to take over the Arizona command, was already one of the most ambitious officers in the Army; he would go on to command U.S. forces in the Spanish-American War (1898) and become Commanding General of the entire Army by 1903.
  • The 700+ French Spoliation Claims cases mentioned would ultimately result in the U.S. government paying out roughly $5 million (in 1880s dollars) to American merchants and their heirs—a testament to how the U.S. was finally settling old imperial debts from the Napoleonic era.
  • President Cleveland's amnesty to Mormons 'who desired to abandon polygamy' was part of a larger federal pressure campaign: Utah wouldn't achieve statehood until 1896, partly because polygamy wasn't fully abandoned until the 1890 Manifesto.
  • The Woodward & Lothrop advertisement shows that Washington's retail scene was already using modern marketing tactics—'Remnant Day Sales,' loss leaders on luxury goods, and multiple store locations (921 Pa. Ave. and 912 D St.) to drive foot traffic.
Contentious Gilded Age Politics Federal Military Crime Corruption Religion Economy Trade
January 6, 1886 January 8, 1886

Also on January 7

1836
Inside Washington's 1836 Breakfast Table: Steamboats, Slave Auctions, and the...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Inside Washington's Most Exclusive Ball (and the Merchant Dentist Offering 'No...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
Before the War: A Day in Cotton Country's Greatest Port (Jan. 7, 1856)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1861
Nashville in January 1861: Still Selling Homes & Sewing Machines While the...
Daily Nashville patriot (Nashville, Tenn.)
1862
When NYC's Newspapers Turned into Recruiting Stations (1862)
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1863
Arkansas Fights to Stay Civilized as War Closes In: What One 1863 Newspaper...
Washington telegraph (Washington, Ark.)
1864
1864 Begins: Can Lincoln Stop a French-Backed Mexican Monarchy? (Plus: Starving...
Weekly national intelligencer (Washington [D.C.])
1865
1865: Sherman Declares 'Savannah Already Gained' + Gold Miners Fill Pans with...
The Idaho world (Idaho City, Idaho Territory)
1866
Theater Riot, Railroad Monopolies & Fenian Trials: The Day Reconstruction...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
1876: When Java Coffee Cost 40¢ and Miracle Worm Pills Outsold Everything Else
The daily gazette (Wilmington, Del.)
1896
Maine's Deadly Deep Freeze: When Ice Was Gold and Winter Killed Without Warning...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1926
When Nebraska's Worst Blizzard Trapped Mail Carriers & Still-Raiders Alike
The Gordon journal (Gordon, Sheridan County, Neb.)
1927
Senator Borah Breaks With Coolidge Over Nicaragua—As First Transatlantic Phone...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free