“December 1876: Coffee for a Dime, Court Scandal in Wilmington, and Why Wanamaker's Was Watching”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Gazette's December 8, 1876 front page is dominated by official state business: Secretary of State Ignatius D. Grubb certifies the complete list of Justices of the Peace and Notaries Public commissioned by Delaware's Governor for the year ending December 4th. The document meticulously records fees paid to magistrates across the state's three counties — New Castle, Kent, and Sussex — with entries like Andrew J. Wright of Dover and Thomas H. Cooper listed among the newly appointed officials. Below the governmental notices, massive advertising dominates: Wanamaker's expansive warehouse operation in Philadelphia runs what appears to be a multi-column promotional blitz, inviting Delaware readers to visit the Philadelphia Exhibition and touting the availability of information services at their facilities. Meanwhile, local merchants compete for attention: James Grippen's "Best Tea Store" on West Third Street advertises roasted coffee for just 18 cents per pound and superior Rio coffee at 25 cents, emphasizing "Great Reductions" suited to "hard times." Period medical advertisements promise miraculous cures — Benson's Capeline Porous Plasters claim to relieve pain instantly and cure disease in hours, endorsed by 3,000 physicians, priced at 25 cents.
Why It Matters
This December 1876 edition captures America at a pivotal moment. The nation had just elected Rutherford B. Hayes in one of the most disputed elections in American history — the Electoral Commission would rule in Hayes's favor just days after this paper was printed, effectively ending Reconstruction and abandoning the South's freedmen to Democratic control. The official state commissions reflect the machinery of local governance that would soon be weaponized as Democrats regained power. Simultaneously, the vibrant commercial advertising reveals a nation recovering from the Panic of 1873 but still grappling with economic anxiety — notice the repeated emphasis on "hard times" and "great reductions." The prominence of Wanamaker's Philadelphia warehouse reflects the emerging urban department store culture transforming American retail and consumer life.
Hidden Gems
- Coffee sold for 18 cents per pound roasted and ground at James Grippen's tea store — extraordinary value that speaks to 1870s deflation and agricultural abundance, yet Grippen still emphasizes "hard times" and "great reductions," revealing consumer anxiety persisted despite low prices.
- M.C. Boyer of Norriton, Pennsylvania advertises his horse hoof uniment as a cure for lameness, claiming 15 years of experience — the ad promises to prevent 'quarter' (a hoof disease) and sprung back sinews, revealing how agricultural America still dominated and how remedies were marketed with impressive medical-sounding language for animals and humans alike.
- The Calvert-Sutton seduction case dominates the Superior Court coverage: testimony reveals Mrs. Calvert ran a business in East Second Street where her daughter Annie worked, and James Sutton was a regular visitor who eventually took Annie out sleighing on the Sabbath — a detailed public court record of courtship protocols and social scandal in Victorian Wilmington.
- Earthenware pottery advertised at George Zeigler's Crockery Ware factory (corner Orange and Water Streets) offered custom yard vases and greenhouse pots, indicating Wilmington supported specialized ceramics manufacturing alongside its better-known industries.
- The Peabody Medical Institute's mail-order advertisement for 'The Science of Life' book boasts of selling 'more than 1,000,000 copies' and receiving a gold medal set with diamonds from the National Medical Association in March 1876 — quintessential 19th-century mail-order medical publishing, blending pseudoscientific authority with shameless self-promotion.
Fun Facts
- John Wanamaker, whose warehouses dominate this page's advertising, would revolutionize American retail in the coming decades, pioneering the department store model. His Philadelphia warehouse complex mentioned here would expand into the largest department store in the world by 1911, and he'd later serve as Postmaster General under Benjamin Harrison.
- The Calvert-Sutton seduction trial was tried under common law principles where 'seduction' itself — the act of persuading an unmarried woman to surrender her chastity — was a prosecutable offense. This case reflects pre-20th-century American jurisprudence that made intimate relations outside marriage a legal matter, a framework that would slowly erode through the 1900s.
- Coffee at 18-25 cents per pound in 1876 reflects the post-Civil War agricultural boom and the opening of Brazilian coffee plantations to American markets — the same forces that would eventually make coffee America's favorite beverage and create the commodity trading markets that still exist today.
- The Peabody Medical Institute's advertisement for mail-order medical books represents a booming 19th-century publishing industry built on anxiety and pseudoscience — offering cures for 'exhausted vitality' and 'spermatorrhoea' (nocturnal emissions), conditions that were largely invented by doctors as diseases. This particular marketing approach would explode during the Progressive Era before being curbed by the FDA.
- The official state commissions listed here were issued just 10 days before the Hayes-Tilden electoral crisis was resolved on December 18, 1876 — meaning Delaware's magistrates took office in the midst of the greatest constitutional crisis since the Civil War, though the front page gives no hint of the political earthquake occurring nationally.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free