“A $32-Per-Ton Silver Mine, a Corruption Scandal, and 300 Mormons: Arizona in 1876”
What's on the Front Page
The Arizona Weekly Miner's June 23, 1876 edition captures a territory in frantic mineral development and political intrigue. Col. H. C. Hodge's sprawling letter dominates the page, detailing his inspection of the McCrackin mine near Mineral Park—a massive spar formation running north-south through a 6-by-2-mile mountain, visible from ten miles away with the naked eye. Hodge reports the main shaft already down 250 feet with four tunnels totaling 1,085 feet, producing carbonate ore that assays at $32.55 per ton in San Francisco and milling ore yielding $65 daily at a 10-stamp Greenwood mill. But the letter begins with explosive allegations: Dr. J. A. Tonner, Indian post trader at Colorado River Reservation, allegedly extorted $3,000 from trader John H. Salt for the tradership position—a corruption case Hodge fears will be 'smoothed over and covered up by the old Indian ring of the Territory.' A secondary story reports on the Boston Colony near San Francisco Mountain, which arrived to find 300 Mormon families had already claimed the richest territory, forcing the colonists to establish camp 40 miles beyond at Canon Diablo.
Why It Matters
In 1876—the nation's centennial year and just 13 years after the Civil War—Arizona Territory remained a lawless frontier where mineral wealth and political corruption intertwined. The McCrackin mine story reflects the frenzied silver and copper boom transforming Arizona from Apache territory into an industrial resource colony. Simultaneously, the Indian Service scandals Hodge mentions were part of a broader rot: the Grant administration (still in power) was notorious for corrupt Indian agents and traders using their positions for personal enrichment. The Boston Colony's clash with Mormon settlers foreshadows the religious and demographic tensions that would define Arizona's territorial politics for decades. These three narrative threads—mining speculation, federal corruption, and sectarian settlement—reveal Arizona in 1876 as a space where fortunes were made and lost by those willing to bend (or break) the rules.
Hidden Gems
- The Arizona Weekly Miner's masthead proudly declares it 'the oldest, and best newspaper in the Territory'—having launched March 9, 1864, making it just 12 years old at this moment, yet already considered venerable in frontier Arizona.
- Single copies of the Miner cost 25 cents; a six-month subscription cost $4.00. For context, those carbonate ore shipments Hodge praises were worth $32.55 per *ton*—meaning one ton of ore was worth roughly 130 copies of the newspaper.
- The business cards reveal Prescott's professional ecosystem: attorneys like Leonard Weber operated from distant Mineral Park (80+ miles away), while pharmacist J. N. McCandless, physician J. C. Otis, and jeweler L. A. Bertbling all clustered on or near Montezuma Street—proto-specialization in a town of perhaps 1,500 people.
- B. H. Weaver's Ready Pay Store advertised accepting 'Greenbacks, Gold Coin, Bullion, Gold Dust, Farm Produce and County Scrip' in exchange for goods—revealing that Arizona Territory's money supply was so fragmented that a single merchant needed to be a de facto currency exchange.
- The 'Cabinet' establishment on Arizona Street simply listed proprietor D. C. Thorne, who paid 'Cash for Valuable Specimens'—a euphemism for what was likely an artifact and curio shop catering to miners and prospectors seeking to sell geological finds.
Fun Facts
- Col. Hodge mentions the Johnson mine 15 miles south was 'lately sold to a Boston Company for $30,000, cash'—that same year, 1876, the Boston Colony itself was attempting to establish an agricultural settlement in Arizona, suggesting Eastern capital was flooding westward during this peak boom period.
- Hodge notes the McCrackin mine ore doesn't 'compare in richness' with earlier bonanzas like the Metallic Accident or Silver King, yet still yields $32.55 per ton—by 1876, even 'ordinary' Arizona silver was valuable enough to ship to San Francisco. This would change dramatically after the silver crash of 1893.
- The Planet copper mine had shipped over 8,000 tons since 1863, averaging $45 per ton—that's roughly $360,000 in gross ore value over 13 years, yet the mine is barely mentioned in Hodge's letter, treated as just one of many properties in the region, showing how routine massive mining operations had become.
- Dr. J. A. Tonner's alleged $3,000 extortion scheme mirrors the Grant-era Indian Service scandals that would eventually lead to reformers like Helen Hunt Jackson exposing systematic corruption—Hodge's letter is essentially a contemporary cry of frustration that would take another decade and political change to address.
- The Boston Colony party departed Boston on February 28, 1876, and arrived in Arizona to find Mormons had beaten them by weeks—this was the period of active LDS migration to Arizona, part of a settlement strategy that would make Mormons the dominant religious force in the territory by 1900.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free