Sunday
May 21, 1876
The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — New York, New York City
“Congressional Bombshell: How a Political Operative Admits to Signing Hundreds of Fake Payroll Vouchers to Buy Louisiana Votes (May 21, 1876)”
Art Deco mural for May 21, 1876
Original newspaper scan from May 21, 1876
Original front page — The sun (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The front page is dominated by explosive testimony from O. W. Ferguson before a Congressional committee investigating massive fraud in post-Reconstruction Louisiana. Ferguson, a political operative, confessed to signing hundreds of fraudulent Custom House payroll vouchers in New Orleans, admitting he scrawled fictitious names like "Brown, Jones, Smith" on documents for which no actual work was performed. The scheme was orchestrated by C. C. Sypher, an ex-congressman, who allegedly paid Democratic and Liberal Republican operatives—"election strikers"—with government money drawn from the Treasury. Ferguson testified that some employees were essentially bribed: sailors were "prevented from shipping until they had voted for Sypher." The vouchers came in blank, with names and amounts filled in afterward. When confronted with denials from cigar importers and Customs officials via telegram, Ferguson insisted the accusations were true and that these men simply wouldn't admit their involvement in fraudulent importing schemes that cheated the government of duty payments.

Why It Matters

This scandal captures the toxic collision of federal power, Southern politics, and raw corruption in the waning years of Reconstruction. By 1876, the Grant administration was besieged by scandals, and the South's reintegration into the Union was fragmenting into brutal partisan warfare. The Customs House at New Orleans was a prize patronage post—controlling it meant controlling money and influence. Ferguson's testimony shows how federal offices were weaponized for electoral purposes, with government funds literally buying votes. This was the year of the disputed 1876 presidential election (Hayes vs. Tilden) that would effectively end Reconstruction, and corruption allegations like these fueled the broader narrative that both parties in the South were hopelessly corrupt, justifying Northern retreat from enforcing rights in the region.

Hidden Gems
  • Ferguson was paid $50 monthly—not as a Custom House employee, but as a 'political striker,' revealing an entire informal economy of paid political operatives funded by the government in 1876.
  • Deputy United States Marshal le Klyn allegedly ordered Custom House officers to remove 2,000 cigars from a shipment without paying duties and carry them to the Marshal's office—federal law enforcement participating in the theft.
  • The Custom House had a band that was 'used for political gatherings, serenades, etc., and was taken about the country to furnish music at political gatherings'—a government musical ensemble as a campaign tool.
  • A witness reported that cigar cases destined for F. Massoch appeared to have been 'cut down from a very large one' and recovered with the original cover replaced, using American nails instead of imported ones to hide the tampering—ingenious fraud detection by the 1870s.
  • The African M.E. Conference section reveals Rev. J. V. Thompson was owed $10 back salary and refused a note for it, demanding cash instead—even churches in 1876 were dealing with unpaid worker grievances and written IOUs as a survival mechanism.
Fun Facts
  • C. C. Sypher, the ex-congressman at the center of this scandal, represented Louisiana during Reconstruction and embodied the rise-and-fall pattern of many carpetbagger-era Republicans who accumulated power through federal patronage and lost it when their machines collapsed.
  • Ferguson's testimony reveals the Custom House payroll fraud occurred in September 1875—just eight months before this article—meaning federal investigators were moving at remarkable speed to expose it during an election year.
  • The cigar smuggling scheme mentioned (144,000 cigars imported, duty paid only on 70,000) represents tax evasion on a scale that would dwarf typical fraud; if cigars cost $20-30 per thousand, the government was being cheated of thousands of dollars per shipment.
  • The dispute over whether M'Carty imported cigars on the 'Merida' or 'Juniata' shows how steamship manifests were crucial paper trails—the first systematic way to catch fraud was tracking which ship carried contraband.
  • Bishop Clinton's declaration 'I do not conceal anything, I bring it out' during the African M.E. Conference reflects the parallel reform moment in Black religious institutions, where transparency and accountability were becoming ideological touchstones even as federal government corruption was endemic.
Sensational Reconstruction Gilded Age Politics Federal Crime Corruption Election Economy Trade
May 20, 1876 May 22, 1876

Also on May 21

1836
1836 New Hampshire: When Orphans' Farms Were Sold, Stagecoaches Still Ruled,...
New-Hampshire statesman and state journal (Concord [N.H.])
1846
War Declared: Inside the May 1846 Battle That Would Reshape America (and Split...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1856
Inside a Border Town's Bustling Commerce (1856): When River Trade Connected...
The Evansville daily journal (Evansville, Ia. [i.e. Ind.])
1861
"Your Homes Are in Danger": Tennessee's Elite Issues Desperate Call to Arms...
Memphis daily appeal (Memphis, Tenn.)
1862
Richmond Panics as McClellan's Army Closes In—Confederate Treasury Already...
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1863
1863: When a U.S. Minister's Speech Nearly Stopped Britain from Backing the...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1864
Grant vs. Lee at Spotsylvania: The Turning Point Battlefield Dispatches from...
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1865
May 21, 1865: Jefferson Davis Behind Bars—The Rebel President's Dramatic Capture
New York dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1866
One Year After Appomattox: How Baltimore's May 1866 Paper Reveals a Nation...
Baltimore daily commercial (Baltimore, Md.)
1886
Dakota Territory Burns—Congress Won't Act, Cattle Are Dying, and a Frontier...
The Warner sun (Warner, Brown Co., Dakota [S.D.])
1896
Managing 'Madam Tyrant': How 1890s Women Battled Their Dressmakers (And Won)
The Sioux County journal (Harrison, Nebraska)
1906
When a U.S. Senator got caught taking bribes (and the Supreme Court didn't care...
The Topeka state journal (Topeka, Kansas)
1926
The Day Coolidge Tried to Save Prohibition (While Al Capone Ran a Whole Town)
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
1927
A Yale Surgeon's Tribute & Mussolini's Long Shadow: Italian Bridgeport, May 1927
La sentinella = The sentinel (Bridgeport, Conn.)
View all 14 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free