“When a French Scientist Met Apaches in Arizona—and Congress Fought Over Mail Contracts”
What's on the Front Page
The Arizona Citizen brings word of a major development in territorial mail service: contractor E.C. Kerens testified before the House Committee on Post-offices and Postroads about his lucrative contract running mail from San Diego, California to Mesilla, New Mexico via Tucson. The route, originally awarded at $60,000 annually for tri-weekly service with a 12-day schedule, was dramatically upgraded to $100,000 per year after intervention by the Attorney General, the Territorial Delegate, and California Congressmen—who pushed for a grueling five-day delivery schedule instead. Kerens claimed his costs more than doubled under the new terms, though he acknowledged the country was safer now with fewer Indian raids and more settlements. The paper also carries extensive coverage of a French scientific expedition: scholar M. Alphonso Pinnart has spent nearly five months in Arizona conducting ethnological and philological research among Apache and Pima Indians, assembling a 2,000-word Apache dictionary and collecting prehistoric stone implements, pottery, and skeletal remains for the Paris scientific societies. Additionally, destructive fires ravaged settlements along the mail routes themselves—Cullen's Station near Wickenberg burned almost entirely, and Ehrenberg lost six horses and considerable property when T.J. Goodman's corral caught fire.
Why It Matters
In 1876, Arizona Territory was still raw frontier, six years after the end of the Civil War and the Indian Wars that defined western settlement. The mail contract dispute reflects the federal government's struggle to impose order and connectivity across vast, dangerous distances—and the political muscle required to secure infrastructure improvements in remote regions. The Kerens testimony reveals how military security gains (fewer Apache raids) were reshaping the economics of frontier life. Meanwhile, Pinnart's scientific mission exemplifies a broader 19th-century obsession with cataloging Native American cultures and languages before they vanished—work that would influence anthropology for decades, though often through a problematic colonial lens. These stories together capture Arizona in transition: a place still being mapped, still being subdued, where survival depended on government contracts, military protection, and the steady infrastructure of communication.
Hidden Gems
- The Arizona Citizen charged $5 per year for subscription (or $3 for six months), making it a significant household expense for settlers—that's roughly equivalent to $135 today. Yet they also offered single-copy purchase at 15 cents, suggesting a mix of regular subscribers and occasional readers.
- Merino sheep were being actively traded in Tucson in 1876: L. Clark advertised his 'entire flock' for sale at 'very low rates' in lots to suit purchasers, showing that fine-wool sheep ranching was a serious commercial enterprise in the Arizona Territory, not just cattle.
- Pinnart collected approximately 2,000 Apache words into a formal dictionary—a linguistic achievement that was considered 'of considerable importance in comparative philology,' yet the newspaper notes he 'does not think highly of the Apaches,' describing them as 'a low type even of Indian races.' This revealing contradiction shows how scientific work could coexist with racial prejudice in the era.
- The Kerens contract reveals merchandise mail rates: merchandise cost 16 cents per pound via U.S. mail, down from 8 cents previously, yet private express companies charged 30 cents per pound on the same San Diego-to-Tucson route. The government mail service was actually competitive pricing, contrary to modern complaints about postal inefficiency.
- A physician named R.A. Wilbur advertised he would 'resume the practice of his profession Thursday, July 1' and would 'give attention by preference to diseases of women and children'—suggesting a summer absence for rest or travel, a luxury available to established professional men in territorial towns.
Fun Facts
- M. Alphonso Pinnart spent years collecting Apache language and archaeological artifacts from Arizona and also compiled what the article claims was 'a complete documentary history' of the Russian occupation of California and Alaska. His work helped establish modern anthropological methods of participant observation—literally living among indigenous peoples to gather data—a practice that would become standard in 20th-century ethnography.
- The mail contract for the San Diego-to-Mesilla route cost the federal government $100,000 annually in 1876 (roughly $2.7 million today), making it one of the most expensive government service contracts of the era. This single Arizona mail line commanded significant political attention in Congress, reflecting how crucial communication infrastructure was to settling and controlling the West.
- Fires at Cullen's Station and Ehrenberg in May 1876 destroyed not just buildings but the supply chains that kept frontier settlements alive—the loss of horses to Goodman's corral fire was catastrophic for both individuals and the Arizona-New Mexico Express Company that depended on them for mail and freight service.
- The grand jury report from Maricopa County (Phoenix) appears at the bottom of the page but is cut off, suggesting serious legal business in the territorial courts—in this era, grand juries were the primary investigative bodies for territorial governance and law enforcement.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free