“Boston Dreams Meet Arizona Reality: 150 New Englanders Head West to Build a Mountain Colony (1876)”
What's on the Front Page
The Arizona Citizen's April 1, 1876 edition leads with news of an ambitious Boston colonization scheme aimed at Arizona's Little Colorado region. Judge O.W. Cozzens has organized a company sending 150 artisans and laborers westward—the advance guard of what's planned as a much larger settlement. The first cohort departed Boston with 300 pounds of baggage per person, provisions for 90 days, and agricultural and mining tools, paying $140 per head for transport via the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railroad to the San Francisco mountain area. The New York Herald reported the colonists are 'nearly all artisans, representative New Englanders, evidently full of energy and determination,' prepared to plant 'civilization in those wilds, hitherto infested by murderous and treacherous Apaches.' A second wave of over 80 registered emigrants is planned within a month, with female family members to follow. The Citizen's editors urge the colonists to keep Judge Cozzens with them—not trusting promises of his arrival later—and note that a $10 million San Francisco mining company is simultaneously forming to work claims on San Francisco mountain, suggesting the region is on the cusp of explosive development.
Why It Matters
This colonization effort captures a pivotal moment in Arizona territorial expansion. In 1876—just a year after the 1875 San Francisco Peaks gold discoveries—eastern capital and labor were beginning to flow westward in earnest. The Apache conflict was still acute (Geronimo wouldn't surrender until 1886), making this venture genuinely perilous. Yet the sheer confidence of these Boston investors reflects the post-Civil War American obsession with westward development and the belief that eastern organization and capital could 'civilize' the territories. This episode also illuminates how newspaper networks and lecture circuits (Judge Cozzens' public speaking) functioned as venture capital recruitment tools in an era before modern advertising.
Hidden Gems
- A single worsted dog masquerading as a live pet caused a train conductor and brakeman to be 'sold'—an entire humorous story buried on the front page about a young woman evading the 'no dogs in passenger cars' rule by substituting a toy.
- The Celestial Restaurant, run by 'Hop Kee & Co.,' advertised as 'first-class' with their own garden to supply fresh produce—indicating a Chinese immigrant business operating openly in 1876 Tucson, on Congress Street near Church Plaza.
- Dr. J.C. Handy advertised his Tucson practice at the corner of Church and Convent streets, while Dr. R.A. Wilbur specifically advertised he would give 'preference to diseases of women and children' and wouldn't resume practice until July 1—suggesting women's medical care was becoming specialized.
- Samuel Hughes offered assay services for single samples at $3.50 for gold and silver, or $5.00 for copper alone—pricing that hints at the region's mineral wealth hierarchy and the growing professionalization of mining assessment.
- L.V. Gaidy advertised an entire flock of 'very high grade Merino Sheep' for sale at 'very low rates' in bulk lots—evidence of large-scale pastoral investment in Pima County at a moment when ranching was expanding alongside mining.
Fun Facts
- Judge O.W. Cozzens, the Boston colonization scheme's figurehead, was leveraging public lectures to recruit investors and settlers—a pre-modern form of venture capital pitch that worked so effectively the Herald called him out by name in national coverage.
- The $140 per-person transport cost from Boston to Arizona (roughly $3,200 in modern dollars) was steep enough to select for committed colonists, yet the $10 million San Francisco mining company being formed simultaneously suggests outside capital believed Arizona's mineral wealth could justify such infrastructure investment.
- The Vermont Supreme Court ruling on Catholic schoolchildren refusing to attend public school on Corpus Christi day (reported on this page) foreshadowed the 'Pierce v. Society of Sisters' case of 1925—a foundational religious liberty battle still being fought in 1876 state courts.
- The paper's casual reference to 'murderous and treacherous Apaches' reflects the genuine Apache Wars still ongoing—Geronimo wouldn't surrender for another decade, making these Boston colonists' 'wilderness' venture genuinely dangerous, not romantic.
- The Palace Hotel advertisement promising 'Comfortable Rooms well Ventilated' and meals 'in the BEST STYLE' on Congress Street captures Tucson in transition—no longer a frontier outpost but a place where proprietors could sell genteel hospitality to an influx of investors, engineers, and settlers.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free