“"Are We Rome?" A Small Maryland Newspaper Warns America on Its 100th Birthday (1876)”
What's on the Front Page
The Saint Mary's Beacon's March 2, 1876 front page opens with a fiery editorial titled "Righteous Governors" that reads like a jeremiad against the moral collapse of American democracy. The anonymous editor, writing just months before the nation's centennial celebration, laments that legislators arrive in state and national capitals as incompetent men of questionable character who "run after scarlet women, get drunk, visit gambling saloons, and may be build." The piece catalogs national scandals—the Whiskey Ring conspiracies involving millions of dollars, government corruption in Washington, epidemic divorces, and a general rot in public and private life. Drawing on biblical and classical history, the writer asks: if Nineveh, Babylon, Jerusalem, and Rome all fell to God's judgment for moral decay, why should America assume it will survive? The editorial invokes Bishop Huntington of New York, who asked in an Advent sermon whether America could truly rest "approved at the foot of God's righteous judgment seat." The page also features serialized fiction—"Briggs: A Love Story" about a cavalry soldier named John Weare caught in a love triangle at Woolwich garrison, and a touching poem, "The Mother's Vow," celebrating divine mercy. A charming anecdote about Napoleon sharing roast potatoes with a common grenadier rounds out the moral instruction.
Why It Matters
This editorial captures a crucial moment in post-Civil War America—the Centennial year of 1876 was supposed to be a triumphant celebration of national progress, yet the nation was reeling from genuine institutional corruption. The Grant administration (1869-1877) was notoriously scandal-ridden, with the Whiskey Ring exposing massive tax fraud and the Indian Ring threatening the President's inner circle. Beyond Washington, Americans were grappling with Reconstruction's failures, economic instability, and deep moral anxiety about whether democracy could survive. The editor's invocation of fallen empires was not alarmist hyperbole—it reflected a genuine intellectual current among educated Americans who feared their republic might follow Rome into decline. The emphasis on personal morality and religious faith as the foundation of political order reveals how Victorian-era Americans understood governance: not primarily through institutions or law, but through the character of men in power.
Hidden Gems
- The newspaper's subscription terms reveal the economics of provincial journalism: $2.00 per annum (about $45 today), and the fine print warns that 'no paper to be discontinued until all arrearages are paid except at the option of the publishers'—meaning deadbeat subscribers could have service cut off only at the paper's discretion.
- Advertisement rates were surprisingly standardized: '75 cents per square for the first insertion, and 50 cents for every subsequent insertion. Eight lines of type constitute a square.' This pricing structure meant a small local ad cost roughly $13.50 in today's money.
- The editorial board includes J.F. King and T.F. Tatum as proprietors, yet the masthead demands that 'all communications for publication must be accompanied with the real name of the author or no attention will be paid to them,' suggesting a small-town paper wrestling with anonymous letters and local gossip.
- The serialized romance 'Briggs: A Love Story' references Woolwich garrison and Plymouth military stations, grounding this melodrama in real British military installations—suggesting the Beacon reprinted stories from British newspapers, a common practice for American provincial papers seeking content.
- The 'Crimson Soldier' anecdote about Napoleon appears to be reprinted from an English source, credited to 'an Englishman, who was considerable time in the French military service.' This story would circulate in American papers throughout the 1870s as a morality tale about honor and integrity across class lines.
Fun Facts
- The editor's invocation of the 'Whiskey Ring' was timely and scandalous—this massive tax evasion conspiracy, exposed in 1875, ultimately implicated President Grant's personal secretary, Orville Babcock, and represented one of the worst corruption crises in 19th-century American government. The ring defrauded the government of millions in whiskey taxes.
- Bishop Huntington of New York, quoted in this editorial as asking whether America was 'safe,' was Frederic Dan Huntington, a prominent Episcopal clergyman and intellectual who served as bishop from 1869 onward. He was genuinely known for his prophetic social criticism—the editor isn't inventing authority here.
- This newspaper was published in Leonard Town, a county seat in rural southern Maryland with perhaps 500 residents. That such a small-town weekly was publishing sophisticated theological and political philosophy suggests how newspapers served as America's primary intellectual commons—even in villages, editors curated serious national debate.
- The centennial celebration referenced—commemorating 1776-1876—was occurring during the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia, which would draw nearly 10 million visitors and showcase American industrial progress. This editor's pessimism about moral decline stood in direct counterpoint to that celebration of material achievement.
- The serialized love story 'Briggs' mirrors the moral concerns of the main editorial: a soldier of humble rank must navigate seduction and moral hazard in garrison life. That fiction and editorial reinforce each other suggests intentional editorial design—the paper was teaching its readers about character and virtue through multiple genres.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free