Wednesday
December 19, 1866
The Evansville journal (Evansville, Ind.) — Vanderburgh, Indiana
“Burned Theaters, Fenian Scares & Political Fire: Evansville's Window on America's Fractured December 1866”
Art Deco mural for December 19, 1866
Original newspaper scan from December 19, 1866
Original front page — The Evansville journal (Evansville, Ind.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The New Bowery Theatre in New York burned down this afternoon with a very heavy loss, dominating the day's dramatic headlines. But the real political story is that Rep. Ashley's impeachment resolution against President Johnson will pass—though observers believe it signals a broader investigation rather than outright removal. Meanwhile, the Fenians are causing panic on both sides of the border: Canadian troops marched out to meet an "imaginary army" near Sweetsburg after a false alarm, while James Gibbons, President of the Fenian Senate, issued a rousing address to the Brotherhood declaring "a necessity for prompt and determined action, never before presented to them." Across the Atlantic, President Johnson's recent message to Congress arrived in London and drew mixed reviews; the British press found his financial statements reasonable but thought his remarks about the Fenians weak and tame.

Why It Matters

December 1866 finds America in the raw aftermath of the Civil War, with Reconstruction politics tearing Congress apart. Johnson's lenient policy toward the South infuriates Republicans, making impeachment resolutions a recurring threat. Simultaneously, Irish-American Fenians—Civil War veterans and Irish nationalists—are mobilizing to invade Canada, treating the border as a staging ground for Irish independence. These aren't fringe conspiracies; they're major security concerns drawing troops and diplomatic attention. The Mexican situation (Maximilian's fever, anti-American sentiment, rumors of annexation) shows how unsettled the hemisphere remains. Even Treasury Secretary McCulloch's bureaucratic orders about steamboat inspectors reflect the chaotic state of federal authority—offices aren't reporting, delinquency is rampant, and Washington is struggling to impose order.

Hidden Gems
  • Lewis C. Weber placed an ad announcing he'd just opened a new saddlery shop on Third Street in Evansville, promising 'lowest cash prices'—a reminder that this front page wasn't just national drama; it was a real marketplace where local craftsmen competed daily for customers' attention.
  • Cardinal Antonelli in Rome had just settled a diplomatic dispute between the U.S. Minister (General King) and the Pope—the paper notes 'the Pope misunderstood Gen. King'—a deliciously vague detail suggesting how easily Cold War-era tensions between the Vatican and Washington could erupt from simple miscommunication.
  • The Bank of Upper Canada had failed, and shareholders filed suit asking courts to hold directors personally liable for money they'd spent buying the bank's stock—an early example of accountability litigation that wouldn't become routine in American corporate law for decades.
  • At Cooper Institute in New York, a working-men's meeting was addressed by R. T. Revihck of Detroit on behalf of the eight-hour workday—this was 1866, and labor activists were already organizing nationally for what wouldn't become standard until the 1930s.
  • General Benjamin Butler, the controversial Union general, was about to have published letters connecting his name to 'several profitable speculations during the war'—suggesting wartime corruption was becoming a public scandal even before the Reconstruction era really began.
Fun Facts
  • The Fenian Brotherhood mentioned here would attempt the actual Fenian Raids across the Canadian border just weeks later in early 1867—this December alarm wasn't paranoia; it was the warning sign of real invasions to come that would nearly spark war between the U.S. and Britain.
  • President Johnson's message prompted debate in London about American policy—but within months, Congress would override Johnson on Reconstruction measures repeatedly, fundamentally shifting power away from the presidency and foreshadowing his near-impeachment in 1868.
  • The Internal Revenue Committee was already discussing reducing taxation on 'many articles, and possibly on cotton'—cotton, the war's central commodity, was about to become cheap again as Southern production ramped up, reshaping global trade.
  • That National German Conference convening in Berlin in December 1866 occurred just months after Prussia's stunning victory in the Austro-Prussian War—Bismarck was consolidating German unification, a process that would reshape Europe and eventually lead to very different wars.
  • The Supreme Court's 'Indiana conspiracy case' mentioned here as a sign the court wouldn't favor 'extreme opinions on political questions' was actually a ruling protecting civil liberties during Reconstruction—the opposite of what would happen in the Plessy era decades later.
Contentious Reconstruction Politics Federal Politics International War Conflict Disaster Fire Economy Banking
December 18, 1866 December 20, 1866

Also on December 19

View all 11 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free