“Congress Punishes Johnson's Allies & Investigates 'Hundreds of Millions' in Wartime Frauds (Dec. 6, 1866)”
What's on the Front Page
Congress is in open warfare with President Andrew Johnson over Reconstruction, and the tensions are explosive. The Union caucus has systematically punished three senators—Cowan, Doolittle, and Dixon—by demoting them to the lowest positions on their committees, a deliberate humiliation for daring to support the President. Meanwhile, a House committee is rushing to frame a "Tenure of Office" bill designed to strip Johnson of his power to remove federal officials without Senate approval. Most sensational: a New York dispatch reports "startling frauds upon the Government" involving parties in high society during the war, with losses reaching "hundreds of millions of dollars." In separate congressional action, investigators are being appointed to examine the New Orleans massacre, the mysterious release of Union soldiers' murderers from Delaware, confiscated lands being returned to rebel owners, and whether pensions improperly struck from rolls have been restored. Secretary of State Seward's retirement is rumored imminent.
Why It Matters
This December 1866 front page captures the Republican Congress at a breaking point with Johnson just months after his failed attempt to preserve a lenient Reconstruction policy. Having lost political leverage, Johnson's allies in Congress are now being isolated and punished. The Tenure of Office Bill would become one of the central pieces of legislation leading to Johnson's impeachment in 1868—a constitutional crisis that tested whether a president could be removed for political reasons. The investigations into wartime fraud and confiscated property reveal deeper Republican concerns: that the war's moral victories (emancipation, confiscation of rebel property) were being systematically reversed by a sympathetic executive. These aren't abstract policy disputes—they're about whether the Union's sacrifice meant anything.
Hidden Gems
- Henry J. Raymond, editor of the New York Times and a congressman, was interrogated at the Union caucus about his attendance at the Philadelphia-Johnson Convention. He faced expulsion from the Republican caucus for appearing insufficiently radical on Reconstruction—showing how even prominent editors weren't immune to political purges.
- The Senate is considering a constitutional amendment requiring Congress to convene on March 4th each year instead of leaving the timing to the President—a mundane-sounding reform that actually stripped the executive of scheduling power during a critical transition period.
- A special committee is investigating whether 'a certain high official' was paid $10,000 to secure the release of Union soldiers who had been sentenced to death by court martial—an explicit bribery allegation buried in dry language.
- Joan Walter, proprietor of the London Times, was feted at a banquet attended by Chief Justice Chase and Speaker Colfax, with the British editor praising Queen Victoria's restraint in preventing war with America during the rebellion—a reminder that foreign recognition hung by a thread during the Civil War.
- The fire report mentions the Temperance Dining Rooms on F Street were destroyed with $7,500 insurance despite only $3,000 in losses—an oddly common occurrence suggesting possible insurance fraud patterns.
Fun Facts
- Senator Reverdy Johnson (mentioned as potentially replacing Seward) would later serve as Minister to Britain and become deeply unpopular for defending the British position during the Alabama Claims dispute—the very foreign relations chaos his appointment was supposed to smooth over.
- The Nebraska Senators-elect arriving with their state constitution represent the 37th state's admission—Congress had to pass legislation just to seat them, showing how fragile the Union's political machinery still was in late 1866.
- Chief Justice Chase, dining with Joan Walter that evening, was simultaneously positioning himself as a potential 1868 presidential candidate and a check on Johnson's power—the Supreme Court and executive were becoming openly adversarial.
- The rumor that Montgomery Blair hoped to replace Johnson's appointee Creswell in the Senate reveals the brutal musical-chairs game Johnson loyalists were playing—within months, this entire faction would be politically obliterated.
- Associate Justice Grier taking his seat to complete a 'full bench' at the Supreme Court is quiet, but crucial: the Court was finally at full strength to handle the constitutional questions Reconstruction would hurl at it, including cases involving Southern litigants frozen since the war's start.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free