“One Year After Appomattox: Thaddeus Stevens Plots the President's Downfall (1866)”
What's on the Front Page
Just one year after the Civil War ended, the front page of The Evansville Journal on November 28, 1866, is consumed by the fractious politics of Reconstruction and lingering international tensions. President Andrew Johnson's annual message to Congress has been completed and sent to the printer—a routine affair that would normally merit modest attention. But the subtext crackles with danger: a Buffalo newspaper reports that radical Republican Thaddeus Stevens has called a secret caucus of GOP congressmen for Thursday to organize President Johnson's impeachment. Meanwhile, abroad, the Alabama claims crisis deepens as Britain finally reopens discussion of the Confederate raider's wartime depredations. Secretary of State Seward demands reparations. European telegraph reports dominate the back pages: the Fenian troubles in Ireland have exploded into open conflict, with Irish-American sympathizers threatening British interests and forcing the deployment of two regiments and marine detachments. The Times and other London papers hint darkly that American complicity lurks beneath the surface. On the financial front, U.S. Five-Twenty bonds trade at 70½ in London, commodity markets show weakness (cotton flat, corn advancing slightly), and there's word that $100 million in specie now rests in the U.S. Treasury.
Why It Matters
This page captures America in its most unstable year since Appomattox. Johnson's presidency was already under siege—his lenient Reconstruction policies had alienated the Republican Congress, setting the stage for the bitter battles that would define the next two years and ultimately lead to his impeachment trial in 1868. The Alabama claims represented unresolved grievances between the U.S. and Britain that could have escalated into renewed conflict. And the Fenian raids—Irish-American veterans attempting to invade Canada—reflected the explosive mix of Civil War surplus arms, ethnic nationalism, and the porous northern border. This was a nation still convulsing with the aftershocks of civil conflict, trying to settle accounts both domestic and international.
Hidden Gems
- A telegraph operator named H. A. Bogardus in Toronto 'has fallen heir to $2,300,000, through the death of relatives who own interests in the Trinity Church property in New York'—an astronomical sum managed by prominent New York lawyers. The detail captures the Gilded Age's dawning wealth concentration in real estate and church holdings.
- The Delaware, Lackawana & Western Railroad sold 10,000 tons of anthracite coal in a single day at drastically reduced prices: lump at $4.80, steamboat quality at $4.25, egg coal at $4.95—all delivered at Elisabethport in standardized 2,240-pound tons. This industrial-scale commodity trading shows the nation's post-war manufacturing boom beginning to reorganize around rationalized measurement and pricing.
- Hon. Cave Johnson, President Polk's Postmaster General who served 14 years in Congress, died at age 72—but the obituary notes he refused a seat in the 1866 Tennessee State Senate 'because of the aid and comfort he had extended to the rebellion.' Even in November 1866, political rehabilitation from Confederate sympathy was so fraught that a national figure would publicly decline office.
- The newly-opened suspension bridge over the Ohio River at Cincinnati—2,252 feet long with a 1,057-foot single span—will be 'the longest single span bridge in the world' and cost $2,000,000 to build. It's celebrated as an engineering marvel, yet the page treats it almost as an afterthought amid war claims and Fenian invasions.
- Large numbers of emigrants 'pouring into the interior' of Texas faced a housing crisis so acute that in Rush County it was 'impossible to get out lumber fast enough to provide shelter for the new-comers.' Yet Federal troops stationed at Waco were allegedly 'amusing themselves by appropriating horses of residents, which once taken were never returned'—Reconstruction occupation at its most petty and corrosive.
Fun Facts
- The page reports that Thaddeus Stevens called a secret caucus to organize Johnson's impeachment—exactly one year later, on November 26, 1867, Stevens would introduce the impeachment resolution that passed the House. Stevens died in August 1868, just weeks before the Senate's acquittal vote in May 1868. He never lived to see his arch-enemy escape removal by a single vote.
- The Alabama claims referenced here—over British-built Confederate raiders preying on Union merchant ships—would haunt Anglo-American relations for four more years until the 1872 Geneva Arbitration finally settled them. That arbitration established international law precedents still cited today in maritime disputes.
- The page mentions H. A. Bogardus's $2.3 million inheritance tied to Trinity Church property. Trinity Church's real estate holdings in lower Manhattan would eventually become worth billions—this 1866 inheritance was an early hint of the explosive value buried in New York's oldest institutions' land portfolios.
- Cave Johnson's refusal of his state senate seat 'because of aid and comfort to the rebellion' occurred while most former Confederates were being rapidly pardoned and reintegrated. Within two years, most ex-Rebels would be restored to full political rights—Johnson's scruples were already becoming anachronistic.
- The Fenian raids mentioned here represent the only foreign invasion threat the United States faced between 1815 and 1941. These Irish-American Civil War veterans actually invaded Canada multiple times in 1866-1870. Their activities pushed Britain and America closer together diplomatically, ironically strengthening the very bond Irish-Americans meant to weaken.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free